When to treat and what to use cardiac disease Mark Patteson MA VetMB PhD DVC CertVR MRCVS Jo Harris BVSc CertVC MRCVS HeartVets Vale Referrals, The Animal Hospital, Stinchcombe, Dursley, Gloucestershire 01453 547934 clinics @, South Devon Referrals in Newton Abbot, A30 referrals @ Penmellyn Vets, Newquay E-mail mark@heartvets.co.uk tel. 07970 956689 Why do we chose a drug ? I will cover • some principles of drug use – why do we use them • canine mitral valve disease • canine dilated cardiomyopathy • feline cardiomyopathy • what evidence is there that a drug works • what practical limitations may there be to its use • which drugs to use and when to use them HeartVets Treatment things change HeartVets Background What we were told just a few years ago no more boom and bust Things have moved on in the last few years Treatment – choice of drug Why do we chose a drug? • everyone who works here uses it • • • • the rep told me to the owner suggested it because her last dog had it I get a turnover related bonus its worth a go, I will try it for a week or so and see what happens HeartVets Why do we chose a drug ? We only use drugs for two reasons • to improve quality of life • to increase longevity and this is by one of the following means: • prevent disease developing • slow disease progression • alleviate clinical signs HeartVets Why do we chose a drug ? what is our rationale based on? • evidence based medicine • what we were taught • what happened last time • who I spoke to last • what I read last • personal experience • what drugs I have available • cost HeartVets Why do we chose a drug ? Which drugs to use based on EBM: Consider: • evidence that they are helpful • evidence that they may be harmful • theoretic reasons that they may be helpful • theoretic reasons that they may be harmful • complications from concurrent disease • complications from concurrent drugs • factors that affect their bioavailability or phaemacokinetics HeartVets CDMVD - diagnosis • what evidence is that the dog has disease • – clinical signs, signalment, physical findings how bad is the disease – clinical signs, physical findings CDMVD - diagnosis • Clinical signs – cough, exercise intolerance, incidental • Physical findings – respiratory rate – heart rate – murmur intensity – hyperdynamic apex beat and increased heart sound intensity – ascites, jugular distension, arrhythmias, concomitant disease • Further investigations – echocardiography, radiography, (pro-BNP, BP, ECG) – coughing, exercise intolerance HeartVets Buchanan “heart-score” method T4 x + y = ht score Maximal width x y Base-apex HeartVets Buchanan “heart-size” method • normal heart size Dogs < 10.7 ics from T4 Cats < 9.5 ics from T4 HeartVets LA HeartVets Interstitial pattern in hilar region, + big LA = oedema (probably) HeartVets Measurement of LV size M-mode HeartVets Measurement of LA size HeartVets Treatment – choice of drug Why do we chose a drug • there is evidence based medicine to support its use? • there is a sound theoretical basis to use it? • • • there is no evidence that it is harmful? there is a wealth of experience optimistic uncertainty • cost / ease of administration HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 Table 1 Stage A Guidelines for the diagnosis of CHCV Criteria At risk but no evidence of disease (eg predisposition of breed such as CKCS). No murmur B1 Asymptomatic – have murmur of MR resulting from CVHD but have no radiographic or echocardiographic evidence of cardiac remodelling B2 Asymptomatic – have murmur of MR resulting from CVHD and radiographic or echocardiographic evidence of cardiac remodelling C Patients with current or past clinical signs of heart failure with structural CVHD. Some of these will be presenting for the first time, some have relapsed following treatment hence treatment may differ. Typically managed as outpatients. D Patients with clinical signs of heart failure with structural CVHD which are refractory to “conventional” treatment or are “end stage”. Require hospital treatment. ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 Table 1 Stage A Guidelines for the diagnosis of CHCV Criteria At risk but no evidence of disease (eg predisposition of breed such as CKCS). No murmur B1 Asymptomatic – have murmur of MR resulting from CVHD but have no radiographic or echocardiographic evidence of cardiac remodelling B2 Asymptomatic – have murmur of MR resulting from CVHD and radiographic or echocardiographic evidence of cardiac remodelling C Patients with current or past clinical signs of heart failure with structural CVHD. Some of these will be presenting for the first time, some have relapsed following treatment hence treatment may differ. Typically managed as outpatients. D Patients with clinical signs of heart failure with structural CVHD which are refractory to “conventional” treatment or are “end stage”. Require hospital treatment. ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 B2 - No consensus •Monitor the progression of underlying disease looking for clinical signs of exercise intolerance and coughing. Train owner in recognising respiratory rate and look for an upward trend that may indicate onset of congestive failure •Ongoing clinical trial looking at whether there is an indication for using drugs such as pimobendan at a stage earlier than C. HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 B2 - No consensus •Difficult to determine a level at which drugs can be introduced and difficult to run clinical trials to establish EBM without a landmark other than clinical signs. •Currently, 2D echocardiography or radiography are gold standards in establishing the severity of disease but there is a possible future role for proBNP measurement in addition to radiography and echocardiography (studies are ongoing) HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 B2 - No consensus •ACE inhibitors are recommended by some cardiologists for dogs with clinically relevant enlargement of the LA or dramatic increase in the size of the LA •A few ACVIM panellists considered the use of pimobendan, digoxin, amlodipine, spironolactone, in general with a view that additional data on efficacy and safety are needed HeartVets Benazepril drug data (BENCH) % mortality rate in dogs treated with benazepril or placebo (P< 0.05) 40 placebo 30 20 benazepril 10 0 0 10 20 30 40 days from start 50 60 HeartVets IMPROVE study - Pulmonary oedema % reduction in pulmonary wedge pressure in dogs treated with ACE inhibitor or placebo, and standard treatment (P< 0.05) 60 ACE inhibitor 50 40 placebo 30 20 10 0 day 2 day 20 HeartVets SVEP trial (Scandinavia, enalapril, not drug sponosred, CKCS only) • Efficacy of enalapril for prevention of congestive heart failure in dogs • • • • with myxomatous valve disease and asymptomatic mitral regurgitation. Kvart C, et al J Vet Intern Med. 2002 16(1):80-8. Multivariate analysis showed that enalapril had no significant effect on the time from initiation of therapy to heart failure (P = .86). When absence or presence of cardiomegaly at the entrance of the trial was considered, still no differences between the treatment and placebo groups (P = .98 and .51, respectively). Long-term treatment with enalapril in asymptomatic dogs with MVD and MR did not delay the onset of CHF regardless of whether or not cardiomegaly was present at initiation of the study. HeartVets ICVS 08 Stockholm Paul Pion: Evidence based review of survival studies in Canine Myxomatous valve disease Quotes of insight: “Based on the current evidence provided by the SVEP and VETPROOF trials, we believe that there is adequate data to conclude that, prior to the onset of CHF, we can discount ACE-inhibitors as the “silver bullet” HeartVets HeartVets • The study compared Pimo vs Benazepril, this does not mean that dogs don’t benefit from both • • • It doesn’t mean that they do either But that’s what I do It doesn’t mean that they don’t benefit from mineralocortocoid blockers like spironolactone HeartVets Quotations from Mark Oyama editorial JVIM Sept 08 • Treatment of this highly prevalent condition remains an immense challenge • Despite myriad advances in the diagnosis, imaging, and pharmaceutics, morbidity and case fatality rate of dogs with congestive heart failure remain surprisingly high. HeartVets Quotations from Mark Oyama editorial JVIM Sept 08 the ‘‘ideal’’ treatment of heart failure in dogs with DMVD likely involves a combination of several agents, some of which offer hemodynamic benefits (ie, diuretics, positive inotropes, vasodilators) and some of which (ie, ACE inhibitors, b-blockers, and so on) tilt the balance of neurohormonal activity toward a more favorable equilibrium. HeartVets Quotations from Mark Oyama editorial JVIM Sept 08 • In cases where circumstances dictate an ‘‘either-or’’ approach (ie, financial restraints, recalcitrant pets who are difficult to medicate), the data from Haggstrom et al clearly favor the use of pimobendan. • In all other cases of dogs with heart failure caused by DMVD, the most reasonable course of action is combined therapy with pimobendan, ACE inhibitor, and diuretics. • Just how much greater effectiveness this combination might have over the either-or approach requires further trials, but in the absence of these data, there is every theoretic and practical reason to assume that these agents retain their individual beneficial effects when co-administered. HeartVets Efficacy of Spironolactone on Survival in dogs with naturally occurring mitral regurgitation caused by Myxomatous Mitral Valve Disease. Bernay, Bland, Haagstrom et al Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 2010 214 dogs with mitral valve disease • Exercise intolerance • Dyspnoea, cough and/or syncope • Evidence of mitral regurgitation on echocardiography • Cardiomegaly on X-ray (VHS>10.5) i.e. congestive heart failure cases HeartVets Efficacy of Spironolactone on Survival in dogs with naturally occurring MR caused by MVD. Bernay, Bland, Haagstrom et al Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 2010 • Double-blind • Placebo controlled • Continued for 15 months • Dogs given: ACE inhibitor +/- furosemide + placebo or ACE inhibitor +/- furosemide + Prilactone® (Digoxin and L-carnitine also authorised) HeartVets Results - Survival benefits: • End point reached - 10.8% (Prilactone® group) versus 25.5% • (placebo group) 55% reduction in the risk of mortality in the spironolactone group (p=0.017) HeartVets Spironolactone in CHF dogs significant improvement in quality of life in spironolactone group vs placebo ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 B2 - No consensus •Beta-blockers are not recommended by many cardiologists but some are recommended for dogs with clinically relevant enlargement of the LA or dramatic increase in the size of the LA. A low dose is recommended with upward titration over a one to two months •Dietary changes with a highly palatable diet, mild sodium restriction and adequate protein and calories recommended by some cardiologists HeartVets Treatment of CDMVD with failure Now general agreement that when CHF is present the following have a strong case for use: • Furosemide • Pimobendan • ACE inhibitors – no case for one vs another although price, palatability and consistency are important • • • spironolactone other decisions are owner management client compliance is essential and education is required HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 acute – largely consensus •Aim to mitigate heart failure by optimising preload, afterload, heart rate and contractility to maintain cardiac output. Reduce MR if possible: •Furosemide. Wide range of doses (1-4 mg/kg) ranging from oral to IV boluses or infusion. CRI recommended at 1mg/kg/hr for life threatening pulmonary oedema (no EMB) •Free access to water once diuresis has started •Pimobendan 0.25 – 0.3 mg/kg every 12 hours •Oxygen supplementation if needed HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 acute – largely consensus •Drain effusions if affecting breathing •Optimal nursing care •Sedation if anxiety exacerbating dyspnoea (typically narcotics with anxiolytics [eg, 0.0075-0.01 mg/kg buprenorphine and 0.01-0.03 mg/kg ACP]) •CRI of sodium nitroprusside for up to 48 hours in dogs with poorly responsive pulmonary oedema HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 acute – largely consensus •ACE inhibition is clearly indicated in chronic therapy but no definitive proof of efficacy in acute therapy, although it has been shown to reduce pulmonary capillary wedge pressure •Nitroglycerine 2 per cent ointment approximately _ inch per 10 kg every 12 hours for 24 to 36 hours (relative strength of opinion is unclear) HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 chronic – largely consensus but different tricks •Furosemide orally to effect, often 2mg/kg every 12 hours. Wide range of doses (1-2 mg/kg every 12 hours to 4-6 mg/kg every eight hours). Doses in excess of these mean move to stage D. •Pimobendan 0.25 – 0.3 mg/kg every 12 hours •ACE inhibitor. Most panellists used enalapril at the upper end of its published range (0.25-0.5 mg/kg every 24 hours) HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 chronic – largely consensus but different tricks •Monitor creatinine •No beta-blockers or nitroglycerine ointment •Monitor weight, appetite, respiratory and heart rates at home •Diet: accurately monitor weight, sustain calorific intake, ensure adequate protein intake and avoid low-protein diets, modestly reduce sodium intake (including treats and food use to help give medication), monitor K+, address anorexia where possible HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 chronic – different views •Spironolactone, 0.25-2.0 mg/kg every 12 to 24 hours, (2.0 mg/kg every 24 hours with food; (licensed in Europe but not in the USA). Mineralocorticoid blocker with no significant diuretic effect •Digoxin, 0.22 mg/m2 every 12 hours, aiming for eight-hour post-pill plasma level of 0.8-1.5 mg/litre. Indicated in cases with atrial fibrillation to reduce heart the rate. Some cardiologists use digoxin in the absence of SV arrhythmia provided that there is no contraindication (eg. raised creatinine, ventricular ectopy, owner compliance) HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 C2 chronic – different views •Diltiazem to control the heart rate, especially in larger dogs •Continued used of beta-blockers if used in stage B2 •Diet: monitor magnesium and add omega-3 fatty acids, especially in dogs with arrhythmias, reduced appetite or weight loss •Cough suppressants eg codeine or inhaled steroids •Bronchodilators eg theophylline HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 D chronic – largely consensus •Furosemide. Wide range of doses. Every eight hours preferable to every 12, with SQ doses periodically (every 48 hours is useful). Dose may be titrated to the respiratory rate measured at home, aiming for below 30 breaths per minute, or increase the dose if there is a persistently increased rate •Spiroloactone if not added at stage •Do not add beta-blockers HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 D chronic – different views •Amlodipine or hydrochlorothoazine as an adjunct to furosemide •Increase pimobendan dose •Digoxin for dogs with atrial fibrillation and to control the heart rate •Sildenafil 1-2 mg/kg every 12 hours •Cough suppressants •Bronchodilators •Some cardiologists do not discontinue beta-blockers •Beta-blockers to control rate (care) HeartVets ACVIM Consensus statement 2009 Table 1 Stage A Guidelines for the diagnosis of CHCV Criteria At risk but no evidence of disease (eg predisposition of breed such as CKCS). No murmur B1 Asymptomatic – have murmur of MR resulting from CVHD but have no radiographic or echocardiographic evidence of cardiac remodelling B2 Asymptomatic – have murmur of MR resulting from CVHD and radiographic or echocardiographic evidence of cardiac remodelling C Patients with current or past clinical signs of heart failure with structural CVHD. Some of these will be presenting for the first time, some have relapsed following treatment hence treatment may differ. Typically managed as outpatients. D Patients with clinical signs of heart failure with structural CVHD which are refractory to “conventional” treatment or are “end stage”. Require hospital treatment. The EPIC Scientific Objective Study Objective: To determine whether chronic oral administration of pimobendan in dogs with evidence of increased heart size secondary to preclinical myxomatous mitral valve disease, can delay the onset of signs of congestive heart failure. HeartVets Enrolment into EPIC • • • • • • 6 years of age or older 4.1-15 kg No other significant disease No previous treatment with cardiac drugs Have a loud heart murmur Have cardiomegaly (VHS > 10.5, echo LA:AO > 1.6:1). LVDd Cornell formula > 1.7 • Not be in CHF HeartVets What happens in EPIC • • • • • • client questionnaire physical exam basic blood tests blood pressure echocardiogram (LA:AO, LVDd, TR velocity) Chest radiographs HeartVets What happens in EPIC • 1 month, 4 months and every 4 months • primary end-point CHF (proven by radiographs) • secondary end-point death • free exams, placebo/Vetmedin (blinded) • free Vetmedin after the trial (but not other drugs or investigations) HeartVets Significance of EPIC EPIC is the largest prospective cardiology study ever conducted in dogs: • • • • 360 dogs 36 centres 11 countries 4 continents Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer • • • • • • • two episodes of syncope during excitement some exercise intolerance rapid sometimes irregular rhythm some weight loss grade 2/6 left basal ejection murmur quiet gallop sound no cough HeartVets Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer HeartVets Treating of DCM DCM – arrhythmias are common in DCM but are often intermittent variable and multiple • quiet heart sounds, +/- murmur, +/- gallop • weak apex beat and weak pulse • breed predispositions • many have arrhythmias, SVT or VT • some have ascites HeartVets Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer HeartVets Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer SVT rate 220 3 sec Bigeminal VPCs Instantaneous rate 130 6 sec NSR rate 130 HeartVets Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer HeartVets Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer 2 months later Bailey developed a chaotic rhythm HeartVets Treatment of DCM - negative chronotropes • • • what is the real rate – Holters very useful arrhythmia or sinus tachycardia control CHF may be sufficient. Do this first and then re-evaluate unless tachycardia is severe Treatment of DCM: • • • • • diuretics - if there is CHF pimobendan ACE inhibitors negative chronotropes / antiarrhythmics • digoxin Is there output failure? • diltiazem • propanolol • sotalol / amiodarone dietary supplements HeartVets Treatment of DCM - negative chronotropes • I sometime use diltiazem in big dogs with AF and a rate that is too high when on digoxin • I sometime use sotalol when the rate is too high, systolic function is OK, and there is a ventricular arrhythmia • I use Amiodarone for selected cases with terrible systolic function and VT but it is a tricky drug to use HeartVets Bailey, a 6 year old MN Boxer - Treatment but what disease are we calling this ? • Boxer cardiomyopathy, ARVC (arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, cardiomyopathy) • Focus on dog’s problems • – systolic/diastolic failure, CHF, arrhythmias • What evidence based medicine have we got for treating these dogs HeartVets Which of the following are of proven benefit in canine DCM: 1. Omega 3 supplements 2. carnitine 3. Taurine 4. low salt diet 5. homeopathy 6. very dilute extract of dragon tongue No EBM for my view or others HeartVets When do dogs develop DM? Pre-clinical phase • Probably lasts 1-2 years • No clinical signs • Sudden death (25-30% of affected dogs) • ? what benefit to identifying, should we treat these • ? how best to screen these cases • echo, Holter, biomarkers, standard ECG, radiography HeartVets Pimobendan randomised occult DCM trial to evaluate clinical symptoms and time to heart failure Study Hypothesis That the administration of pimobendan to Doberman Pinschers with occult dilated cardiomyopathy will delay the onset of heart failure and in doing so, prolong the period between diagnosis and the death of the patient HeartVets • No previous prospective study has evaluated the • • • effectiveness of any medication for the treatment of preclinical DCM in the Doberman Pimobendan treatment has been proven to significantly reduce mortality and morbidity in Dobermans with CHF secondary to DCM There is reason to believe some of the known effects of pimobendan could be of benefit in the preclinical stage of the disease The potential benefit of pimobendan therapy in delaying the progression of preclinical DCM in Dobermans has not previously been evaluated HeartVets Protocol Design • The trial protocol was prepared by independent cardiologists in conjunction with the sponsor and was approved by an ethical review committee at all sites where this was required • The contract between the sponsor and the investigators stipulated that the latter group have full access to all results and the right to independently publish regardless of the trial outcome HeartVets The study Results •the data show that treating Dobermans with pre-clinical DCM with Vetmedin results in several months longer to onset of heart failure or death compared to dogs left untreated. •Look out in JVIM for publication hopefully in the next few months HeartVets Preclinical cardiomyopathy? How should we screen ? • • • • • • Auscultation Biomarkers Echocardiography ECG Holter ECG Radiography HeartVets Feline Cardiology Myocardial diseases classified as: • Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) • • • • • • Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) Restrictive cardiomyopathy (RCM) Unclassified cardiomyopathy (FUCM) Moderator band cardiomyopathy (MBCM) Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy (ARVC) Endomyocardial fibroelastosis HeartVets Feline Cardiology • Why do we classify • diseases? Pathological documentation Structural description • • To aid treatment • To aid prognostication HeartVets Feline Cardiology Be clear about definitions Why do we chose a drug ? what is our rationale based on? • evidence based medicine • what we were taught • what happened last time • who I spoke to last • what I read last • personal experience • what drugs I have available • cost HeartVets Cat the owner give the cat tablets? Feline Cardiology Myocardial diseases could be classified as: • I can hear a murmur / gallop / arrhythmia but the echo looks pretty normal to me • I can hear a murmur / gallop / arrhythmia but the echo looks a little bit odd • Wow that’s a thick left ventricle • • • Gosh what a massive left atrium Gee, it’s got a pericardial effusion / pleural effusion too oh deary me ! there is a bloody great thrombus in the LA HeartVets Feline Cardiology Myocardial diseases can be difficult to classify: • “fortunately strict echocardiographic characterisation of the type of cardiomyopathy may be less valuable for prognosis than other echocardiographic factors” Virginia Luis-Fuentes BSAVA 2011 classify on a functional basis • • • • is there a big enough LA for failure to be possible is there evidence of diastolic dysfunction? is there evidence of systolic dysfunction? what is the rate and rhythm? HeartVets Treatment of Feline Cardiomyopathy Options • • • • • • diuretics beta blocker (atenolol) calcium channel blocker (diltiazem) ACE inhibitors positive inotropes (pimobendan) anticoagulants – aspirin 30-75 mg every 2-3 days, clopidogrel _ x 75 mg sid HeartVets Feline Cardiology What I do next: Murmur, gallop or arrhythmia but marked hypertrophic changes • Check T4, blood pressure, renal parameters • if no failure, marked LVH +/- outflow obstruction and no LA enlargement I prescribe atenolol • No LVH do nothing but repeat scan in 3 months HeartVets Feline Cardiology What I do next: tachyarrhythmias / bradyarrhythmias • Echo and assess as before • Check full biochemistry, electrolytes, T4, blood pressure, urine s.g. • if no failure I prescribe atenolol for tachyarrhythmias (either supraventricular or ventricular) • If failure and supraventricular I use diltiazem • For bradycardias treat underlying disease and consider treatments such as beta-agonists (eg terbutolene) or pacemaker only if symptomatic HeartVets Feline Cardiology What I do next: (all without evidence of CHF) • mild LA enlargement: • Add benazepril but not aspirin • +/- frusemide if in failure • moderate / severe LA enlargement • add aspirin and withdraw atenolol • humungous LA enlargement • add clopidogrel (18.75 mg ie _ x 75 mg PO q 24 hours) • withdraw atenolol HeartVets Feline Cardiology What I do next: : • congestive heart failure • frusemide • +/- spironolactone • benazepril • stop atenolol • consider whether diltiazem is practical and try to manage • • without it usually have LA enlargement therefore I use aspirin consider use of clopidogrel HeartVets Feline Cardiology What I do next: • Pleural effusion • Drain if dyspnoeic • make sure that CHF is the cause • company it keep • cytology / bioch on fluid • other lab data • Treat as for CHF Feline Cardiology What I do next: • Systolic failure • often these are RCM and FUCM cases rather that • • clear DCM • changes may be subtle and dyskinetic, furthermore FS% can be difficult to interpret (one dimensional) • LA usually large and are at risk of CHF I add pimobendan at 0.75 -1.25 mg bid per cat. This is off licence. I also use pimo when I have run out of options in CHF HeartVets
© Copyright 2024