Vol. XIX No. 944 |1 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Vol. IXI No. 944 | October 11, 2014 | ADDIS ABABA, ETHIOPIA www.thereporterethiopia.com Price 5.00 Birr MEDIA COUNCIL ON THE HORIZON By Solomon Goshu Photo By: Reporter/ Nahom Tesfaye After intense negotiations and fierce debates that went on for over a decade, the Ethiopian media took a decisive step forward this week in establishing a media council, a self-regulatory body of media practice and the conduct and discipline of journalists in Ethiopia. A lively two-day consultative forum of media stakeholders held at the UNECA (United Nations Economic Commission for Africa) on October 9 and 10 deliberated on the draft Articles of Association and Code of Conduct, which was prepared by members of the organizing committee, reaching agreement on the sticky issues of membership and finance. According to the draft Articles of Association, publishers, broadcasters, professional journalists’ associations as well as private and public journalism schools can become members of the council on a voluntary basis. The forum debated whether to allow individual journalists to be members of From left: Amare Aregawi, General Manager of Media and Communications Center and Vice-Chair of the organizing committee; Abdissa Zeray (PhD), Dean of School of Journalism of Addis Ababa University; Kabral Blay-Amihere (Amb.), Chair of Ghana’s National Media Commission and Zewdneh Beyene (PhD), Moderator of the Consultative Forum Water ministers urge Egypt to rejoin NBI Ethiopia loses more than USD 90 mln due to rough gemstones export By Kaleyesus Bekele “GERD is very important investment to all of us and to the wider region” Mutaz Musa Abdalla Salim, Chair of Nile-COM By Yemane Nagish, Nairobi, Kenya and reiterate its commitment cooperation on the Nile. Concluding the Fourth Nile Basin Development Forum, a high-level meeting held at the Intercontinental Hotel, Nairobi from October 6-7, the Nile-Council of Ministers (Nile-COM), which comprises of the water ministers of all member states of the Nile basin, urged Egypt to resume its membership Advertisment Mutaz Musa Abdalla Salim, Sudan’s Minister of Water Resources and Electricity, Current Chair of the NileCOM noted, “Cooperation over the Nile is not an option but a necessity.” He added that Sudan has resumed its membership for Water ministers... page 34 Media Council... page 33 Ethiopia is losing more than 90 million dollars annually because of the exports of rough gemstones, it was learnt. At a two-day consultative meeting on the mining sector held on October 7 and 8 jointly by the World Bank and the Ethiopian Ministry of Mines (MoM) at Addis Ababa Hilton, gemstone manufacturers and exporters told participants that the country is losing a huge amount of foreign currency and jobs due to failure to process (curve and polish) gemstones. Tewodros Sintayehu, managing director of Orbit Ethiopia PLC, said that instead of exporting processed gemstones the country is supplying rough gemstones to the international market. Tewodros said in 2012 Ethiopia exported 16,500 kg of gemstones, mainly opal, and earned only seven million dollars. “Had this been processed we could have earned more than 100 million dollars and created more than 1000 jobs for Ethiopian citizens,” Tewodros said. Ethiopia loses... page 34 2| Vol. XIX No. 944 EDITORIAL The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Published weekly by Media & Communications Center Address: Bole Sub City, Kebele 03, H. No. 2347 Tel: 011 6 616180 Editorial 011 6 616185 Reception 011 6 616187 Finance Fax: 011 6 616189 PO Box:7023 0910 885206 Marketing E-mail: mcc@ethionet.et Website: www.thereporterethiopia.com General Manager Amare Aregawi Managing Editor Bruh Yihunbelay bruh@ethiopianreporter.com Editor-in-Chief Asrat Seyoum Sub city: N.lafto, K. 10/18, H.No. 614 asrat@ethiopianreporter.com Senior Editors Yacob Wolde-Mariam Dibaba Amensisa Editors Kaleyesus Bekele kaleyesus@ethiopianreporter.com Yonas Abiye yonasa@ethiopianreporter.com Assistant Editor Tibebeselassie Tigabu tibebeselassie@ethiopianreporter.com Senior Reporters Henok Reta Columnist Leyou Tameru bitsandpieces@ethiopianreporter.com Chief Graphic Designer Yibekal Getahun Senior Graphic Designer Tewodros Kebkab Graphic Designers Tsehay Tadesse Fasika Balcha Endale Solomon Semenh Sisay Netsanet Yacob Bezaye Tewodros Head of Photography Nahom Tesfaye Photographers Tamrat Getachew Mesfen Solomon Website Bezawit Tesfaye Binyam Hailu Cartoonist Elias Areda Fasil W/giorgis Marketing Manager Endalkachew Yimam Biruk Mulugeta Biruk Chernet Computer Secretaries Birtukan Abate, Helen Yetayew, Print Tesfaye Mengesha, Yeyesuswork Mamo,Gezaghgn Mandefro Exercising strict oversight over the executive The current Ethiopian year of 2007 (2014/2015) is the closing year of the Ethiopian government’s 5-year Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP). It is also the year the draft of the second round of the GTP is set to be deliberated upon and implemented after a critical assessment of the implementation of the plan over the period of its execution. This process needs to involve an in-depth evaluation of the performance of the executive over the past five years by members of the current House of Peoples’ Representatives if the country’s overarching plan for the next five years is to be accomplished successfully. The past four years of the GTP have witnessed the launching of huge infrastructure and other projects that have been unprecedented in the history of the country. The construction of major highways, rail ways, hydro-power dams, education and health facilities, residential condominiums, sugar factories as well as the expansion of the national telecom network can be mentioned in this regard. Commendable as the commencement of these projects may be, questions must be asked about their progress. Among the mega projects underway, the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD), which has led to the creation of national consensus that has not been matched before, has drawn the attention of the world. According to the government, the construction of the dam is some forty percent complete. Updates on the progress of the construction, which has seen unparalleled levels of public participation, are regularly provided. This, indeed, is laudable. The public, however, is not similarly kept informed about the status of the other projects. Why? Will the projects be characterized by delay and cost overrun like the majority of road, hydropower and telecom projects executed over the years? The public need assurances that they are on track. The private sector unarguably plays a vital role in transforming Ethiopia from an agriculture-led to an industrialized economy. While efforts are being exerted to deepen its role in the manufacturing sector, one cannot help but ask, among others, whether there are enabling policy frameworks and incentives in place, and whether government monopolization of mega projects has brought about a satisfactory result and if not what should be done about it. As the organ in which ultimate power resides, Parliament owes the obligation to oversee that the executive branch of the government is properly discharging the responsibilities entrusted to it. In the exercise of their oversight power members of Parliament must not be content with listening to the performance reports of government agencies and proactively seek detailed information from them. Just as the country’s economic growth is explained in figures so should the status of the implementation of the ongoing massive projects. It is with an eye to mitigating the challenges that are likely to be faced in the coming five years that the achievements of the GTP over the past five years will be assessed at the end of this Ethiopian fiscal year. Extolling successes while making light of shortcomings will not get us anywhere. Could the economy have grown faster than government statistics suggest or is it ambling along just fine? Is the successful implementation of a certain project eclipsing the poorly performing projects or is everything going smoothly though nothing has been said about it? Parliament is duty-bound to demand satisfactory explanations from the Executive on these matters. How far along are preparations to enable the national grid and transmission lines cope up with the volume of electricity that is projected to be generated at the conclusion of the GTP? Are they on or behind schedule? Is there a market for the products of the sugar factories under construction? Are they lagging behind and over budget as well? Will the potash deposit, which is hoped to bring in substantial foreign exchange once the railway linking the site it is mined to the port of Djibouti is complete, be ready for production any time soon or is it anybody’s guess when production will start? Is the construction of trunk roads along the country’s import-export corridor is on time or falling behind as usual? These are also issues on which Parliament needs to lean on the Executive to provide clarifications. There can be no going back when we are witnessing the glimmers of a sustainable growth. Aside from being a milestone for the GTP, 2015 is a year the fifth national elections are due to be held. The actions being taken by the government to ensure that the elections are free, fair and credible must be evaluated critically; it has to be asked what it is doing about widespread complaints regarding lack of good governance as well as widespread violation of fundamental rights, miscarriage of justice and rampant corruption. It’s pointless for the executive to highlight its success alone; it’s incumbent upon it to acknowledge its weaknesses as well with a sense of accountability and pave the way for immediate corrective measures. For this to happen it is imperative that parliament exercises strict oversight of the Executive. www.thereporterethiopia.com HEADLINES The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Presidential address to parliament focuses on economic performance Offers apology for power interruption Warns Eritrea, rebel groups Agency criticizes companies in relation to ISO 9001 By Neamin Ashenafi By Yonas Abiye Many companies that are gaining publicity by claiming that their company is an International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 9001 certified have been criticized by the Ethiopian Standards Agency since it is out of context and creates confusion on the public. In a joint parliamentary session, the 4th election term of the 5th working year of House of Peoples’ Representatives and the House of Federation commenced on Monday after a three-month recess. The President of the Republic, Mulatu Teshome (PhD), addressed Members of Parliament as well as the entire nation by highlighting major economic and infrastructure performances development activities, including the 10.3 percent annual GDP growth rate. Director General of the Agency, Almaz Kahsay told The Reporter, “There is a difference between management quality standard and product standard; however many companies claiming that their organization is receiving the ISO 9001 award for the product does not necessarily imply that their product is certified.” She also said that their management system might be certified but it does not necessarily imply their product is certified and in this regard the agency is working to create awareness within the society. On behalf of the government, he highlighted the major achievements that he lauded it as a successful performance implemented in the previous fiscal year in particular and the last for years of Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP) period. He said that a lot remains to be done and new plans would be intensified ahead of the current fiscal year. During the last four years of the GTP, the country’s economy had registered a consecutive GDP average growth rate of 10.1 percent, the president said, adding that the transformation, industrialization and growth in manufacturing had to be increased to sustain the registered growth. Vol. XIX No. 944 |3 The Director General also told The Reporter, “When these companies announce the certification they should Agency criticizes.. page 35 Advertisment Ethiopia welcomes Tanzania’s move to ratify the Nile treaty According to the president, the industry sector had a faster growth rate than others, and more efforts would be made to duplicate the double-digit mark of the growing economic path higher than an 11.4 percent GDP growth in the year ended July 7. As part of the economic progress and to sustain it with the said double-digit growth rate, the president indicated that efforts would be made to raise export earnings to as high as USD five billion at the end of the current fiscal year. By Mikias Sebsibe He underlined that to hold inflation rate at single-digit, works on supplying consumer goods and modernizing trade trademarket network would be strengthened. He however did not mention the specific measures to be taken-what he described as the intervention to control the possible surging of inflation. Ethiopia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) has welcomed Tanzania’s move to ratify the Cooperative Framework Agreement (CFA), a treaty which seeks to establish a commission to realize an equitable utilization of the Nile River. In a move that quelled uncertainties over Tanzania’s commitment to the treaty, President Jakaya Kikwete’s cabinet, the most senior executive branch of Tanzania, approved and forwarded the CFA to the country’s parliament. current account deficit “Though widened in the last fiscal year due to the increase in import, it was compensated by the significant income from tourism, Ethiopian Airlines and remittance,” Mulatu said The parliament is expected to ratify the treaty next month, Tanzania’s minister of State in the President’s Office, Mark Mwandosya (Prof.), said on Monday during the 4th Nile Basin Development Forum held in Nairobi, Kenya. In the last fiscal year the federal government collected 122 billion birr from tax, non-tax revenue including grants direct-budget subsidiary and debt relief, which is a 106 percent performance against the target, he noted. “The move is to be expected and we welcome it,” Dina Mufti, MoFA spokesperson, told The Reporter. “We hope and expect other signatories to do the same.” Likewise, agriculture, which had been the backbone of the country’s economic performance, according to him, had witnessed a promising progress with productivity of major food products that could hit as equal as 27 quintals per hectare. Doubts as to the ratification of the CFA emerged when Tanzania’s minister Presidential address.. page 35 Ethiopia welcomes... page 35 www.thereporterethiopia.com 4| Vol. XIX No. 944 HEADLINES The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 eLearning conference Tullow moves out staff, machinery returns to Ethiopia Calls exploration results “a nightmare” By Yonas Abiye By Kaleyesus Bekele In what is said to be the largest ICT conference on African soil, Ethiopia will host this year’s eLearning Africa, which is also the tenth anniversary edition of it being held under the patronage of the Ethiopian government. The British oil company which is prospecting for oil in the South Omo basin of Ethiopia, Tullow Oil, is moving its staff and machineries out of Ethiopia. At a consultative meeting on the Ethiopian mining sector jointly organized by the World Bank and the Ethiopian Ministry of Mines on October 7 and 8 at the Addis Ababa Hilton, Nick Woodal-Mason, country manager, Tullow Oil, said that his company is taking its staff and mining equipment out of Ethiopia. “After drilling four wild cat wells in the South Omo basin we found nothing. We found only clay. Geologically, the results are a nightmare,” Nick told the participants. The company has already released the well drilling rig. In a statement sent to The Reporter, the organizers indicated that the conference, the largest international event in Africa on ICT for education, training and development, would be held in Addis Ababa from May 20 to 22 next year. Speaking of Ethiopia’s decision to host the event, Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD), Deputy Prime Minister for Finance and Economic cluster, who is also the Minister of Information and Communication (MoIC) said, “My government is pleased to host eLearning Africa as this is a conference returning to Ethiopia, where my government joined arms with ICWE in conceiving and launching the first eLearning Africa platform on African soil.” Debretsion Gebremichael (PhD) Rebecca Stromeyer, CEO of ICWE GmbH, and Founder of eLearning Africa, said that during its 10-year history, the conference had led to an explosion of new ideas, new projects, new agreements and new partnerships. Accordingly, the conference has brought the leading experts on learning, development and technology to take part in our discussions and has shown the world the ambition and wisdom of Africa. “eLearning Africa 2015 will create an opportunity to reflect on the 10-year journey traversed by eLearning Africa since its first conference in Addis Ababa. Furthermore, Ethiopia, as the seat of the African Union, welcomes conferences that bring together African policymakers and experts once more back to their home,” the statement quoted the minister as saying. eLearning conference... page 35 Tullow Oil began prospecting for oil in the South Omo basin in 2011 after it bought a 50 percent stake from Africa Oil, a Canadian oil company. Africa Oil and Marathon Oil own 30 and 20 percent working interest in the South Omo basin respectively. Tullow drilled four exploration wells; Sabisa-1, Tultule-1, Shimela-1 and Gardim-1 but it did not find any oil and gas reserve. Nick explained how Tullow decided to come to Ethiopia. “We came here after we discovered oil reserves in Uganda and Kenya. We got positive results in the Advertisment BAMBIS NEWS Just Arrived !! FROZEN SEA FISH : FROM DUBAI / "$*$ &% / $&% / '%%%! / )"" / !%" / / / / %%9.23-27.31-37.41-47.51 ""! '$ #% $ #% !!%-"!'"! ## Stella : SWISS Chocolates &%% / & / &(&+!'& / (&+!'& / (&$'&%,'&% / &&$%(& / !86:(& "!% / !83:""(&% *% / )#$!'$""211: / $!% !&!%%0'"$076: / ""&&"%$ / (&" / (&$! / &&$(&%(&$ &%% / / ""& / &""&(&% / 71:""(&" $!& ROVELLI CHOCOLATE BOXES : FROM ITALY / %%"$& !&"&")% ! ### !%&&"))'&&%($%)))%))+( www.thereporterethiopia.com Great East Africa Rift Valley. The rift system extends to Ethiopia. Our blocks are found in South Omo near the Kenyan border where we found hundreds of millions of barrels of oil. The decision to come to Ethiopia was good but it did not work out.” According to Nick, 35 expatriates from Tullow’s Ethiopian office have already left and there are about only five expatriates who are still here dealing with logistics and customs issues. “By December we are all leaving Ethiopia and we will keep only a skeleton office for the coming two years,” Nick said. Nick explained the complexity of the oil exploration project in South Omo. “The concession is found in one of the remotest places not only in Ethiopia but in Africa. It is located 1600km southwest of the port of Djibouti. It takes ten days for a truck to reach the concession from Galafi, the Ethio-Djibouti border, to our camp. It costs us 10,000 USD per truck for a one-way trip. This makes our exploration work very expensive,” Nick said. He noted that the drilling work was the most challenging one due to well instability and the hot temperature, as hot as 200 degree centigrade underground. Tullow moves... page 35 HEADLINES The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Safeway, Mulmul join Total’s Café bonjourr shop Vol. XIX No. 944 |5 Diageo’s Meta Abo to double its production capacity in a few months Launches 3.5 million birr investment in community development program By Henok Reta Photo By: Reporter /Tamrat Getachew Diageo’s Meta Abo Brewery announced the final stages of its USD 1 million expansion project that will double the existing production capacity in a few months last Tuesday at Hadmes Hotel, near the factory’s site. While launching the new community development program that cost the factory 3.5 million birr, Francis Agbonlahor, Managing Director, said that the factory’s growth should be maintained in line with supporting the community. Marc de Lataillade By Henok Reta Total Ethiopia inaugurated the first Café Bonjourr in collaboration with Safeway Supermarket and Mulmul Bakery introducing the French concept, Happy Sud. This concept will be a new trend in the city’s retail industry. “The partnership with the two important brands in the retail business in Ethiopia will promote standards and global marketing strategy,” Marc de Lataillade, Managing Director, Total Ethiopia said when delivering a speech at the official inauguration event at the Head Office, Roosevelt Street, yesterday. country. Currently, the company is undertaking an international standard depot in the town of Dukem, 30 km away south east of the capital with an outlay of 270 million birr to boost its capacity of covering ¼ of the country’s fuel demand, the managing director told The Reporter. This announcement of the new investment into the Sebeta community falls in line with Meta Abo Brewery’s strategy of growth, commitment and sustainability, he stated. This year the factory is looking to double its production capacity, as the expansion appears to be on the verge of completion after striking the deal to buy the state owned brewery for USD 255 million in 2011. “Diageo and Meta Abo Brewery are in Ethiopia for the long haul,” the managing director reaffirmed. This year, the brewery will also provide an independent water supply line to the community surrounding the brewery from a borehole, through an expanded water distribution pipeline, expanding the reach of its water distribution to more households, according to the managing director. Mayor of Sebeta town, Ejersa Donssa, on his part praised the factory’s effort in an attempt to increase its social responsibility as it successfully maintains its growth and expansion. “We will keep our way forward together,” he said. The factory has also launched its first scholarship program in the name of a late employee who died of a car accident a few months ago. The Meseret Mamo scholarship of Meta Abo brewery will grant 5-10 students money every year to cover their expenses at the university. On the other hand, the factory is also part of the local barley sourcing program in partnership with 6000 smallholder farmers, the Ethiopian Agricultural Transformation Agency (ATA) and Oromiya Agricultural Bureau to play a role in fostering agriculture, the managing director told The Reporter. Advertisment EHRC, Irish government sign MoU The new concept that aims at introducing the renowned French tradition of making a mini market, fast food and café available together at one place has been introduced for the first time in Ethiopia, according to Marc de Lataillade. The Partners of Total Ethiopia in this new concept are renowned in the retail business in Ethiopia, and this is fully in line with Total marketing and service strategy. The Café Bonjourr concept was realized to create a more comfortable zone for customers at the gas station, and has become another trademark for Total worldwide, he stated. By Neamin Ashenafi The Ethiopian Human Rights Commission (EHRC) and the government of Ireland have signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) to work together in the areas of the right to justice in different regions of the country to provide a legal service for the poor and vulnerable members of the society, mainly women. Fekadu Kebede, Managing Director at Safeway Supermarket said that the partnership with Total was a result of loyalty and consistence that has been well observed by esteemed customers of the supermarket over the past four years. “We greatly feel honor to join Café Bonjour, almost all shops across the city, that will indeed, help our effort in promoting the retail business,” he said. The newly formed café is keeping its expansion across the city with a grand shop being opened in the Gelan service station and other locations in the coming months. Irish Ambassador to Ethiopia Aidan O’Hara told The Reporter that, based on the signed agreement, the government of Ireland will provide 400,000 Euro for the program and it will extend for the span of two years and will support poor and vulnerable members of society who seek legal advice. On his part Ambassador Tiruneh Zena, Ethiopian Human Rights Commission Commissioner also told The Reporter that the criteria to select these universities are mainly based on “performance delivery, activities of the universities, commitment of the universities and sound financial report.” Total was established in Ethiopia in 1950 as a petroleum product distribution company, it developed its activities by merging with Mobil Oil East Africa in 2006. Today, the company operates 173 service stations and four depots in the He also said that the commission has been working in this area for the last EHRC, Irish... page 36 www.thereporterethiopia.com 6| Vol. XIX No. 944 In-depth The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 IMF vs. Government The issue of fiscal consolidation By Asrat Seyoum Table1. Ethiopia Comparison of PPG External Debt Baseline Scenario It has been one of those weeks. Ethiopian monetary and fiscal authorities are kept on their toes ‘defending’ the outcome of their policies and what they have in-store for the current budget year. Yes, it is time for receiving their report card; perhaps one of the most influential country’s overall reports about economic standing. By one of the most influential international institution namely the International Monetary Fund (IMF). A well-established practice by now, a team of IMF experts pay a visit to countries like Ethiopia, countries receiving their financial assistance, to see how the economy is managed. The visits and the subsequent staff report are all done under what is dubbed the Article IV consultations between the IMF and respective nations. For many, the routine is more than consultation to say the least. It is an epic showdown where experts and authorities from both side get to test their intellectual and professional prowess. Well, this much can be said regarding the the Article IV consultation between the Fund and Ethiopia. A lot of the ‘consultation’ is about macroeconomic matters and the Fund is one of the two Bretton Wood institution designated for such areas. The exchange becomes even more Fiscal year ending July 7 2034 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2024 (percent, unless otherwise indicated) PV of Debt to Exports Ration 2014DSA* 1150 135.9 141.9 141.1 131.9 120.1 78.7 25.2 2013DSA 116.8 120.9 124.1 122.2 117.6 113.4 92.6 … 2014DSA 15.4 18.9 21.0 21.9 21.3 20.4 15.3 6.7 2013DSA 16.4 17.5 18.8 19.1 19.0 18.9 16.2 … PV of Debt to GDP Ratio PV of Debt to Revenue Ratio 2014DSA 102.0 131.5 147.1 154.6 149.4 140.8 105.4 38.7 2013DSA 127.9 131.9 141.9 144.6 144.7 140.8 121.9 … Source: Ethiopian authorities; IMF and world Bank staff estimates and projections. *Debt Sustainability Analysis lively when a fundamental ideological divide exists between the two parties. Apparently, nothing sums up the Ethiopian government’s relationship with the IMF than a “fundamental idealogical difference”. So, there appears to be an issue year-in-year-out. In the past, a number of macroeconomic matters like inflation, financial sector regulation, sectoral liberalization and overall growth paradigms had been sources of contention. In fact, severe resistance to IMF’s policy recommendation is one of things that the late Prime Minister Meles Zenawi is remembered for. To put it into perspective, neither sides had the complete upper hand historically. While the Fund remained loyal to the widely championed market economy with a IMF vs. Government... page 38 Hospitality business in the making By Birhanu Fikade from the tourism and hospitality sectors annually. Back in the days of the emperors, Addis Ababa was able to host the first ever Etege Taitu Hotel, named after Empress Taitu, the wife of Emperor Menelik II. It opened doors some 116 years ago. The establishment of Taitu Hotel gave the capital a new face. A face of hospitality at least for the royal circle. Members of royal family and ranking inner circles of the emperor were hesitant to give it a try, because it was not a regal thing to do at that time; to have a meal inside a place called hotel. As some literatures proclaim they even discarded it all together. There are a number of factors which had deterred the growth of hospitality industry in Ethiopia. Before, 1991 Ethiopia was struggling to be in the list of the hospitality sector. The famous 13 months of sunshine slogan which still serves in promoting Ethiopia was launched during the time of Emperor Haialesellaise I. Behind branding and cultivating the tourism sector, one bold figure is to be mentioned. Habtesellaise Tafesse was a minister of tourism back in imperial days. It was that time which gave opportunities for many local as well as international brands like the Hilton to come into the play until the Derg seized power. Before the military took over the government, Bekele Mola Hotels, Ghion Imperial Hotel, Wabi Shebelle Hotel, Ras Hotel, Ethiopia Hotel, Omedad Hotel and the likes were mushrooming in the capital and regional cities. Little by little, the inner circles of the royal society started to become accustomed to the concept of wining and dinning at an establishment called hotels. From then on to now, the hospitality business came to serve many including travelers across the world. Yet, fifty years later, Ethiopia sticks with only three hotels which could be named for their international presence. The 47-year-old Addis Ababa Hilton was built by Emperor Haileselassie I. Some 15 years ago, followed Sheraton Addis, which bears one of the luxury brands of Starwood Hotels and Resort Worldwide. Radisson Blu came up with the brands of Carlson Rezidor Hotel Group as only the third hotel Ethiopia has ever registered in the name of international brands. But right this time, the hospitality industry seems to be picking up trying to catch up with at least the neighboring nations which amasses billions of dollars The private sector was forced to hibernate throughout the 17 years of military rule. Most private sector holdings were nationalized; one best example to be cited from the hotel business was Omedad Hotel. It was built and operated by private owners before being nationalized. These sorts of measures and the maximum capital ceiling placed on the private sector made it difficult to own and operate hotels in the country at that time. Half a million was the limit set for investors by the socialist government. Currently, the total number of hotels both b th privately i t l owned d and d those th belonging to the Government in Ethiopia is around 426. According the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, these and those of “unclassified hotels” are estimated to have some 19,000 rooms in 2011. To have a recent data on the real number of hotels in the country is a hugely challenging task. However, some researchers dare to project that the number of hotels grow by 20 percent based on the 2009 figures. The assumption works out that the total number of hotels probably reaches some 500 or so in 2014. Out of which, 93 hotels with a little over 5,000 rooms, fall under the star-rated standards of the ministry. These are hotels which are dubbed to be holding a two to five stars showing their standard and status in the internationally recognized language. However, the standards set for star rating was introduced long before the country was introduced to the luxury standards such as Sheraton Addis. Before Radisson Blu, came into the face of Ethiopia’s hospitality business, the government considered some 17 hotels which meet the international standards in the capital, which means they fall into the standard of two stars and beyond. According to officials of the ministry, the hotel rating system will be introduced in the industry soon. Previously, the ministry had attempted to bring in a new grading system which was aimed at delineating star-rated hotels in the country. But that was boldly rejected by the industry players and property owners. Following the opposition, three years ago, the ministry came up with www.thereporterethiopia.com similar attempts. It was challenged by the local hotel operators once again. But, not only them, ministry’s contacted the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) and presented the guidelines which it attempted to implement. UNWTO experts, however, did what the hotel operators had done and rejected it. The experts discarded the guidelines set out by the government. Instead, they tried to develop a new form of guidelines and that still is on the making, Tadesse Endaylalu, tourism licensing services directorate director at the ministry told The Reporter. But the absences of regulation on grading, some industry players were seen manipulating the industry. Across the city, to the layman’s understanding, many hotels give themselves star ratings perhaps for other commercial purposes. When they found out that the hotel business is the ideal one to venture on, easily labels the building with hotel flags and start rates. These usually are those hotels mostly complained by lack of accommodating parkings, public areas or swimming pools. In his exclusive interview with The Reporter, Neway Berhanu, managing director of Calibra Hospitality Consultancy and Business Plc (a company which has facilitated the contacts recently to develop six internationally branded hotels here), said that most of the hotel owners and developers previously were not convinced by the idea of hiring hotel Hospitality... page 36 HEADLINES The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Vol. XIX No. 944 |7 Ethiopian to AWiB to honor ‘exceptional’ women commence Dublin, LA By Neamin Ashenafi Tewolde Gebremaraim By a Staff Reporter Ethiopian Airlines yesterday announced that it has finalized preparations to start flights to Dublin and Los Angeles starting from June 2015. Ethiopian said flights to Dublin and Los Angeles will be operated three times a week with the ultra-modern Boeing 787 Dreamliner, which offers unparalleled on-board comfort to passengers. The flights will be the only direct service connecting Africa with Ireland and the West Coast of the United States. Ethiopian said travelers from Los Angeles and Ireland will be able to enjoy seamless and convenient connectivity options thanks to Ethiopian extensive in Africa covering 49 network destinations. Similarly, as the flights will be the only direct service between Dublin and Los Angeles, the Irish and US traveling public between the two cities will greatly benefit from the opening of the route. “Our new flights connecting Addis Ababa, Dublin and Los Angeles will play a critical role in the expansion of trade, tourism investment between the fast growing continent of Africa, and the United States and Ireland. As the these flights will be the first and only direct air route linking Africa with Ireland and the West Coast of the US, they will bring these two seemingly far away cities much closer to Africa and will facilitate mobility and connectivity for businesses and the large African Diaspora community living in the West Coast of the United States”, Ethiopian Airlines Gorup CEO, Tewolde Gebremaraim, said. The third edition of the Women of Excellence annual celebration of leadership and contribution made by Ethiopian women, hosted by the Association of Women in Business (AWiB), will take place on October 19 at the Sheraton Addis. Seven candidates have been identified for this year’s title, Seble Hailu, president of the association, told The Reporter. This was disclosed during a press conference held on October 7 at SaroMaria Hotel. Blen Sahilu, board member and head of public relations of the association, told The Reporter that each year the association celebrates the dedication, ingenuity and achievement of amazing Ethiopian women, one of which will take the title of AWiB 2014 Women of Excellence (WOE). It was also disclosed that the nominees are chosen for their vision, proven record of success, courage and compassion as demonstrated by how they have helped other women to succeed. For this year’s title some 21 nominees were identified and due to various reasons, such as some of the nominees being outside Ethiopia, refusal from some of the nominees for various reasons and more, the list was reduced to 12. The Court Sentences three magazine publishers in absentia months jail terms each. By Tamiru Tsige General Managers of publishing companies of the now defunct Addis Guday, Fact and Lomi magazines received jail terms of more than three years. The Sixteenth Criminal Bench of the Federal High Court passed the sentence on Tuesday in the absence of the defendants who fled the country following the charges. Endalkachew Tesfaye, general manager of Rose Publishing Plc - publisher of Addis Guday magazine and Gizaw Taye, general manager of Dadimos Entertainment and Press Works Plc - publisher of Lomi magazine were sentenced to three years and three The sentence against Fantu Nuriye, general manager of Yofa Entertainment and Press Works Plc - publisher of Fact magazine, received a jail term of three years and 11 months. The publishing companies and the general managers are accused of public incitement through spread of false rumours and subversion of the constitutional order. Gizaw was the only defendant to appear before court back in August. However, he fled the country after the court granted him a 50,000 birr bail. Except Fantu, a defendant whose identity and whereabouts is yet to be established, a total of 15 journalists have fled the country for fear of persecution. Advertisment In this regard, the runners for this year’s award are Dr Bogalech Gebre, Founder and Director of KMG Ethiopia, Frealem Shibabaw, Founder and Director of Bahir Dar Academy and Director of the Ethiopian School Meal Initiative, Dr Liya Tadesse, CEO and Vice Provost at St. Paul Hospital Millennium Medical College, Rachel Mekuria, Former Head of the Educational Television Production Division and Former Board President AWiB to honor... page 36 Israeli Knesset with Ethiopian counterparts By Yonas Abiye A handful of the Israeli parliamentary (Knesset) officials and staff visited their Ethiopian counterparts to confer and share experiences at the House of Peoples’ Representatives (HPR) yesterday. Headed by the Director General of the Knesset, Ronen Plot, the Israeli delegation briefed their counterparts on the formation and activities of the Israelis main legislative and government system. According to Plot, in the Israeli government and legislative system the head of any opposition party will get similar respect as a house speaker or any other senior government official in the executive body. According to the Director General, the Knesset is the house of representatives (the parliament) of the State of Israel, in which the full range of current opinions are represented. Nevertheless, parties “In line with our Vision 2025 strategic roadmap, we are expanding our network and deploying the most technologically advanced aircraft as part of our Ethiopian to commence... page 36 final 12 nominees were interviewed, and the association has shortlisted seven women for the final 2014 award. “Free grant... page 36 www.thereporterethiopia.com Israeli Knesset... page 36 8| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment www.thereporterethiopia.com Vol. XIX No. 944 |9 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment Fiber g dinP.L.C a r Glass i T Fiber w ewa r ibe Glass s s a l G FPRODUCTS | ት ዓመ Glass Fiber Glass Fiber Glass Fiber Glass Fiber 3 ከ ር ናጋ ዋስት Different sizes of water tanker from 350-25,000 liters የተለያዩ መጠን ያላቸው የውኃ ማጠራቀሚያዎች (ከ350-25,000 ሊትር)፣ | Different Design & color of bath tubs, shower trays, kitchen sink የተለያዩ ዲዛይንና ቀለም ያላቸው የገላ መታጠቢያ ገንዳዎች፣ሻወር ትሬዮች፣ የማዕድ ቤት ዕቃ ማጠቢያዎች፣ | | | | Different kinds of Design ,Size & color flower Pots የተለያዩ መጠን, ዲዛይንና ቀለም ያላቸው የአበባ መትከያዎች፣ በር በፋይ ሪም ሽከርካሪ ማ ጨ የተ ጥገና Different kinds of color Transparent roof sheets ብርሀን የሚያስተላልፉ የተለያዩ ቀለም ያላቸው የጣሪያ ክዳኖች፣ Pickup hard tops የፒክ አፕ መኪና ተቀያሪ ጎማ ማስቀመጫና የኋላ ሽፋን ግጣሞች፣ Dust bin በተ ግሎት ን፡፡ አገል እንሠጣለ የደረቅ ቆሻሻ ማጠራቀሚያዎችን በጥራት እናመርታለን:: Additional Import Goods | | | | | | Gp Resin Fiber matt Gel coat Capsule Titanium Hardener Fiber Glass | | | | | | Pigment Stayren Cobalt Woven roving Wax (MG8,MG1, MG3) Wax Solution Fiber Glass Fiber Glass Fiber Glass አድራሻ፡ ዋና መ/ቤት ተገነ ሕንጻ (ግሎባል ሆቴል) 1ኛ ፎቅ ( 0118 50 02 43 የማምረቻ ቦታ ወርቁ ሰፈር ከሰላም ሆቴል አለፍ ብሎ ( 0118 95 63 96 ለበለጠ መረጃ፡-È09 38 65 65 65/09 38 57 57 57 E-mail:-sewawitrading@gmail.com Fiber Glass Fiber Glass Fiber FFib ib Glass Gl Fiber Fib Glass Gl Fiber Glass www.thereporterethiopia.com 10| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 COMMENTARY C onsider, for example, policy toward the banking system. With the defeat of the Scottish referendum, it is clear that the UK will still have a single integrated banking and financial system for the foreseeable future. In the US, which similarly has an integrated banking system, the federal government steps in when banks in a state are in serious trouble. Americans have learned the hard way that bad financial events, even when initially localized, can quickly infect the entire system. The evolution of devolution By Barry Eichengreen The Scots have spoken. A solid majority voted against independence in their historic referendum last month. But the debate left no question that an even larger majority favors the further devolution of economic, social, and political power in Britain. And regional movements elsewhere in Europe – and around the world – are making similar demands. The logic of devolution is clear. Scotland, for example, may not want a bigger or smaller government than it has now, but it wants a different mix of taxes and spending. It wants more local control. The Scotland Act of 2012, scheduled to come into effect in 2016, provides a down payment on this desired autonomy. Prime Minister David Cameron, knowing which way the wind is blowing, has promised more. But if devolution is good for Scotland, then why not for Wales and Northern Ireland? Why not also for England, for that matter? An equilibrium in which Scots vote on English laws but the English have no vote on Scottish laws will not remain an equilibrium for long. And why stop there? Why not devolution for Yorkshire, a region with a population equal to Scotland’s and an active separatist movement, and for other English regions? A not-so-United Kingdom of regions need not be a disaster. The United States is able to function, after a fashion, as a union of 50 states of very different economic size and political complexion. Other federal states like Canada and Australia may be even better role models. But it is important to draw the right lessons from the experience of these other states. For starters, the central or federal government should retain significant fiscal powers. It must be responsible not just for defense and foreign policy, but also for key economic policies. And it must have the resources to implement those policies. Consider, for example, policy toward the banking system. With the defeat of the Scottish referendum, it is clear that the UK will still have a single integrated banking and financial system for the foreseeable future. In the US, which similarly has an integrated banking system, the federal government steps in when banks in a state are in serious trouble. Americans have learned the hard way that bad financial events, even when initially localized, can quickly infect the entire system. Specifically, the federal government steps in through the agency of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, which has a credit line with the US Treasury. With the federal government raising roughly two-thirds of all tax revenues, there is no question about the Treasury’s The evolution... page 28 VIEWPOINT By Mesued Mustefa Turkey is a vital country to defeat ISIL In my last week take on the current international issue entitled “Fighting International Threats and Challenges,” I argued that today’s international setup has failed to protect mass killings, crimes against humanity and has lack of determination and commitment to protect humanity across the globe in general, and in Syria and Iraq in particular. I raised the issue of Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant ((ISIL) as an example and asked why this group gained this much momentum in the first place? Though I am not an expert on the issue; I also stated my skepticism about the successes of the ongoing operation of the international coalition to bombard the command and communication facilities of this group. I expressed the importance of urgent and strong action from the international community before it becomes too late. Just a few days later this group is about to gain another strong strategic place located near the border of Turkey, while there have been continuous bombardments from the so called international coalition forces. Speaking Tuesday in the southern city of Gaziantep, Turkish President, Recep Tayyip Erdoan, told residents that Kobane was about to fall. “The terror will not be over…unless we cooperate for a ground operation,” Erdogan said in the eastern city of Gaziantep. “I am telling the West - dropping bombs from the air will not provide a solution.” I think Kobane is a game-changing place for this crisis for two reasons. Both the international coalition and the government of Ankara understand the ramification of the capture of Kobane by this terrorist group. In the first place the importance of ground forces may get momentum and the international community will reconsider the effectiveness of the ongoing air bombardment and at the same time Turkey will likely react and engage this group. These two scenarios in one way or another will change the whole picture of the ongoing struggle to tackle such threats. The capture of this strategic town by this group is also vital for the www.thereporterethiopia.com group too. I see the possible capture of the Kurdish populated city of Kobane as an opportunity to defeat the group because this scenario will bring Turkey into play and gives her a chance to assert her demands to the so called international coalition. As we all followed, Turkey has significant differences in the handling of the current problems in Syria and Iraq. Both the Assad regime and the Kurd separatist fighters are enemies of the Ankara regime. As far as my understanding goes, if we need to defeat this group, one country that can play a significant and vital role is Turkey. It was a well-documented fact that Turkey Turkey is a vital... page 28 Vol. XIX No. 944 |11 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment www.thereporterethiopia.com 12| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment www.thereporterethiopia.com Opinion The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Vol. XIX No. 944 |13 America’s overrated decline By Joseph S. Nye, Jr. With the approach of the US Congressional elections, questions about the health of America’s political institutions and the future of its global leadership have become rampant, with some citing partisan gridlock as evidence of America’s decline. But is the situation really that bad? According to the political scientist Sarah Binder, the ideological divide between America’s two main political parties has not been as large as it is now since the end of the nineteenth century. Despite the current gridlock, however, the 111th Congress managed to pass a major fiscal stimulus, health-care reform, financial regulation, an arms-control treaty, and revision of the military policy on homosexuality. Clearly, the US political system cannot be written off (especially if partisan gridlock is cyclical). Nonetheless, today’s Congress is plagued by low legislative capacity. Though ideological consistency has more than doubled over the last two decades, from 10 percent to 21 percent of the public, most Americans do not have uniformly conservative or liberal views, and want their representatives to meet one another halfway. Political parties, however, have become more consistently ideological since the 1970s. This is not a new problem for the US, whose constitution is based on the eighteenth-century liberal view that power is best controlled by fragmentation and countervailing checks and balances, with the president and Congress forced to compete for control in areas like foreign policy. In other words, the US government was designed to be inefficient, in order to ensure that it could not easily threaten the liberty of its citizens. This inefficiency has likely contributed to the decline in confidence in American institutions. Today, less than one-fifth of the public trusts the federal government to do the right thing most of the time, compared to three-quarters in 1964. Of course, these figures surged occasionally during that period, such as after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks; but the overall decline is considerable. The federal government is not alone. Over the last several decades, public in many influential confidence institutions has plummeted. From 19641997, the share of Americans who trusted universities fell from 61 percent to 30 percent, while trust in major companies fell from 55 percent to 21 percent. Trust in medical institutions dropped from 73 percent to 29 percent, and in journalism from 29 percent to 14 percent. Over the last decade, confidence in educational institutions and the military has recovered, but trust in Wall Street and large corporations has continued to fall. can be misleading. In fact, 82 percent of Americans still consider the US to be the world’s best place to live, and 90 percent like their democratic system of government. Americans may not be entirely satisfied with their leaders, but the country is certainly not on the brink of an Arab Spring-style revolution. Moreover, though party politics have become more polarized in recent decades, this follows the 1950s and early 1960s, when the escape from the Great Depression and victory in World War II fueled unusually high confidence in US institutions. In fact, the sharpest decline in public trust in the government occurred in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Moreover, declining trust in the government has not been accompanied by significant changes in citizens’ behavior. For example, the Internal the Revenue Service is among government institutions that inspire the least public confidence; yet there has been no major surge in tax evasion. In terms of controlling corruption, the US still scores in the 90th percentile. And though voting rates in presidential elections declined from 62 percent to 50 percent in the latter half of the twentieth century, they stabilized in 2000, and rose to 58 percent in 2012. The loss of confidence that Americans have expressed may be rooted in a deeper shift in people’s attitudes toward But these ostensibly alarming figures America’s... page 28 Advertisment www.thereporterethiopia.com 14| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 COMMENTARY + P hilosophical differences are extremely difficult to reconcile. Just as Platonists and Aristotelians struggled against one another for millennia, Kantians and utilitarians have been at one another’s throats for centuries. The new philosophers By Harold James At the recent meeting of G-20 finance ministers in Australia, US Treasury Secretary Jack Lew noted “philosophical differences with some of our friends in Europe,” before urging Europeans to do more to boost their anemic growth rate. The terminology is striking, and underscores the difficulty of Europe’s search for a way out of its current malaise. Canada’s finance minister, Joe Oliver, joined the call for fiscal expansion in Europe – a position for which there seems to be some support within the European Central Bank. Indeed, ECB President Mario Draghi has advocated higher spending by more fiscally strong countries like Germany. And ECB Executive Board member Benoit Coeure, together with his former colleague Jörg Asmussen, currently Germany’s deputy labor minister, recently suggested that Germany should “use its available room for maneuver to promote investments and reduce the tax burden of workers.” In fact, most of the world believes that Germany should adopt a more expansive fiscal policy. According to this view, austerity is counter-productive, because it induces slowdowns and recessions that make long-term fiscal consolidation more difficult. But Germans – as well as some other Northern Europeans, and perhaps some Chinese economists – remain reticent. They believe that responding to calls for stimulus would simply lead to more such calls, creating a log-rolling, porkbarrel dynamic in which any hope for fiscal consolidation is ruled out. The stimulus-versus-austerity debate is an old one. In the 1970s and 1980s, the United States regularly called on Germany and Japan to act as locomotives for the global economy. But, until recently, the divergences were viewed in terms of interests, not “philosophies.” Americans wanted additional demand for their goods and higher prices, while the Germans and Japanese defended their export industries. The problem today, as Lew’s recent statement highlighted, stems from deeply entrenched differences between the opposing sides’ belief systems, with ideological questions about fairness and responsibility trumping pragmatic discussion of the best way forward for everyone. As the historian Robert Kagan argued in 2002, Americans and Europeans do not only have different worldviews; they occupy entirely different worlds. Philosophical differences are extremely difficult to reconcile. Just as Platonists and Aristotelians struggled against one another for millennia, Kantians and utilitarians have been at one another’s throats for centuries. Such deep theoretical conflicts have real-world consequences, as they impede constructive debate and cooperative action in crisis situations. Fundamental ideological divisions over the 2003 Iraq war have strained global politics for more than a decade. The new... page 30 VIEWPOINT + By Gordon Brown A generation held hostage? On April 14 the Islamist terrorist group Boko Haram kidnapped 276 schoolgirls from the government secondary school in Nigeria’s northern town of Chibok. Many escaped, but 219 remain in captivity, their whereabouts still unknown. So deep is the despair and desolation felt by the girls’ parents that they are now considering whether to declare their daughters “presumed dead.” According to local custom, funerals are held after loved ones have gone missing for four months, so that a period of mourning can give families some closure. The girls have now been held captive for over five months. No one can overstate the families’ unspeakable anguish from not knowing if their daughters have been raped, beaten, or trafficked out of Nigeria – or even if they are still alive. The rest of the world may have moved on, but the girls’ parents wake each morning to a day of uncertainty and resignation. Hope is fast evaporating. It is difficult to see how the girls could be returned safely. Launching a military rescue operation would be highly risky. It is believed that the girls have been split into separate groups, so that any attempt to rescue one group would imperil the others. Despite talk of the government negotiating a deal with the captors, this option, too, would be fraught with danger. Even if all of the girls eventually do come home, nothing will ever be the same again for them or their families. For some, it is already too late. Seven parents, despite being relatively young, have died of heart attacks or strokes, to which the intolerable strains of their situation may have contributed. But amid the gloom, there is, perhaps, a glimmer of hope. While we cannot know the future for the girls still in captivity, 15 of the 57 girls who escaped their kidnappers are now back at school, braving Boko Haram’s threats to return and abduct more students. Hundreds www.thereporterethiopia.com of thousands of other girls in northern Nigeria are now too afraid to go to school, but these girls refuse to be cowed. They are determined to make up for lost time. This display of astonishing courage and determination to get an education should be an inspiration for us all in the fight against discrimination. To support and encourage more girls to attend school in the face of abduction threats, the Nigerian Safe Schools Initiative has been launched to fund fortifications, telecommunications, and security measures aimed at allaying children’s fears about going to what should be a safe haven. A generation... page 30 Vol. XIX No. 944 |15 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment Request q for Supply pp y of Communications and Information Systems y ((CIS)) Equipment q p and Services for Eastern Africa Standby y Force ((EASF)) ((REF: HR/ICT/002/2014)) The EASF Secretariat intends to procure CIS Equipment and Services andtherefore seeks companies to supply the CIS Equipment and Services. Interested and competent Companies should collect a detailed Terms of Reference document from "@J+Q++V('++X! of a non-refundable fee of USD 50 or equivalent in Birr. The completed bids should be returned to the address below by 17th October 2014 10.00 am and opened immediately thereafter in the presence of bidders or their representatives who choose to attend. EASTERN AFRICA STANDBY FORCE HEADQUARTERS %! [%J\-%!$X P.O. BOX: 26571 Tel +251 111 245791 Addis Ababa Ethiopia Phone: +2511-11-24-57-91 Fax: +2511-11-24-57-99 E-mail: seasbrighq@yahoo.com easbricom@easbrig.org Web: www.easfcom.org Joint Declaration by the European Union High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, and the Secretary General of the Council of Europe on the European and World Day against the Death Penalty, 10 October 2014 ! strong and absolute opposition to capital punishment in all cases and under all circumstances, and their commitment to its worldwide abolition. We are deeply concerned about setbacks in some countries, such as recent mass trials leading to a vast number of death sentences, the extension in domestic legislation of the scope of the death penalty’s use, or the resumption of executions after a period of several years. No execution has taken place in our Member States in the past 17 years. The European Union and the Council of Europe "!#!$%&"$'() Convention on Human Rights, and urge all other European States that have not yet done so to sign and ratify these instruments which aim at the abolition of the death penalty. The European Union and the Council of Europe deeply regret the recent executions carried out by Belarus, the only European country that applies this form of punishment. They strongly urge Belarus to commute the sentences of the two remaining *+() $!!-"$ penalty. Both organisations welcome the recent steps taken by the African Union towards the adoption of an Additional Protocol to the 9;!<9$="! of the Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights of 15 December 1989, aiming at the abolition of the death penalty, have brought the number of States Parties to eighty-one. They encourage all States which have not yet done so to ratify this protocol on the occasion of its 25th anniversary in 2014. The European Union and Council of Europe call on all Members of the United Nations to support the Resolution on a moratorium on the use of the death penalty which will be put to vote at the 69th session of the UN General Assembly in December 2014.’’ www.thereporterethiopia.com 16| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment VACANCY ANNOUNCEMENT GREEK COMMUNITY SCHOOL, ADDIS ABABA. Fax : +251 115 510274 e-mail: gcs@ethionet.et Website : http//www.greekcommunityschool.com Tel.: 251 115 515870 251 115 504005 251 115 520606 Position: Human Resources Manager Job Summary y: In consultation with the Administration, Prepare and implement annual HR Plan to support the overall strategic aims and objectives of the school Board. Ensure that the staff are informed and updated on important issues in relation to their duties. Develop, implement and maintain HR policies and procedures to ensure effective, fair and consistent management of staff throughout the institutions make sure that staff handbook is up to date. " aspects of the position. Position: Science Teacher Job Summary y: Teaching a prescribed curriculum to students of age 5-10 years. Degree in Science teaching and a minimum of 3 years of experience in teaching the age group, 5 to 10 years. Place of Work:}@!!% 99$$=JX 9$= Terms of Employment: p y One year contract with the possibility of renewal. Applicants are invited to send non-returnable curriculum vitae and copies of relevant document within 7 days of this announcement to The Administrator, Greek Community School P.O. Box 598 Addis Ababa {%V"$&"= DESA PLANTS PLC is a foreign investment company in the horticulture sector located around Modjo. Our main activities are production and export of high quality seedlings to the European and USA market. Our company is growing fast and expanding its markets hence we are recruiting additional staff members and open vacancies in the position of: Quality Q y Assurance Assistant Duties and responsibilities: to assist the Quality Manager in all `9J`9X@=$! j = records to assure accuracy. To facilitate the creation of quality guidelines, forms and graphs for the QA department. Work experience: Prior working experience in a quality department @"[%{%jJ[%{|++( }9 X$$= Work place: Modjo – Ejersa Service bus from Modjo – Debre Zeit - Adama BSc Degree in Agronomy or ;"&9= Skills: -&J@"X= @"#{J- X={ feedback, committed, professional attitude. Good communication skills. Salary: Negotiable – attractive You will be part of a young and dynamic team. You will work in a dynamic business in an international company. We offer an attractive salary package including insurance cover and medical costs refund. Senior Warehouse Supervisor p Duties and responsibilities: Coordinates receiving and inspection of ordered goods by checking the correctness of the items against purchase orders. Ensures that received parts are unpacked and properly stored. Ensures that all transactions are properly recorded and documented via the store management software. Checking inventory accuracy through monitoring cycle counts. Ensure and maintain cleanness of the stores. Prepares and submits to the !! ! warehouse activities. Work experience: Prior working experience in a warehouse and basic knowledge of warehouse procedures is preferred. Also basic knowledge of store management software is an advantage. Work place: Modjo – Ejersa Service bus from Modjo – Debre Zeit - Adama Bachelor’s Degree in Procurement and Supplies Management or BA Degree in ! #! " " work experience. Skills: -&J@"X= }!@J#{X=["@" store management software. Good administration skills. Salary: Negotiable - attractive You will be part of a young and dynamic team. You will work in a dynamic business in an international company. We offer an attractive salary package including insurance cover and medical costs refund. CONTACT: CV and convincing application letter should be send to job@desaplants.com or PO box 466 – Modjo or PO box 46144 - Gerji Branch - Addis Ababa www.thereporterethiopia.com The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Feature Vol. XIX No. 944 |17 Investment setbacks in Ethiopia EUBFE panelists holding discussions with the attendees of the forum By Henok Reta When the Ethiopian Investment Agency (EIA) announced the unprecedented level of increase in investment from US and the EU back in July this year, it hardly mentioned what awaits some of these companies coming to Ethiopia. For the time, it was the increase that was the big story since the level rose to 19.27 billion birr just from 2010 to 2014, according to the EIA. “It just reached new heights,” public relations director praised it in comparison to what he called the “lion’s share” takers of the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): China and India. The figure, however, is just half of the 40.61 billion birr that reached the country through FDI, the EIA states. No doubt, the country can present itself amongst the major potential FDI destinations in world at the moment. Ethiopia’s immense natural resources, vast land, cheap labor, ideal weather, and some incentives may have something to do with this. In spite of this, the country has not been what investors from the West call an ‘ideal’ investment destination. As some prefer to put it, the administrative “gridlock” with the state bureaucracy remained the main reason behind this, especially, not for those businessmen and women who are passionate about ease of doing business with flexibility and transparency all their lives. Indeed, authorities try to sell a stable economic environment, liberalized economy, security of investment, significant tax incentives, investment opportunities, favorable tax regime, access to large market, good infrastructure, strong natural resource base, and cheap labor force to potential investors. Good enough. The country, indeed, looks fine from here. But, on the other hand, it doesn’t sound so good in light of some global indicators. It ranks 166th in the world and Africa in terms of starting business, 125th in ease of doing business and even it ranks 16th out of the 19 Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA) countries. “Since it covers 25 percent of the COMESA, it shouldn’t top the bottom,” Thierry Mutombo Kalonji, director of investment promotion and private sector development at COMESA, says. In spite of the best practices the country has shown in a few years to attract FDI, the regional block, COMESA urges for more improvements, particularly in licensing, taxation and registration. “Mauritius, Zambia and Rwanda can impart their best practices in terms of licensing for other member states,” the director points out. Since its inception in 2012, the European Union Business Forum Ethiopia (EUBFE) has held a couple of meetings that brought together government officials, businesspeople, and experts to discuss issues regarding the investment climate. While conducting the second anniversary of the forum at Addis Ababa Hilton last week, the solid evidences traced by the experts’ case studies and legal analyses ignited a heated debate on the matter. Ahmed Shide, state minister of Finance and Economic Development (MoFED), assured commitment to work on the shortcomings indicated. “We are here to listen to you,” he said. Semaw Negatu, a legal expert, on his part, said that the EU Business Forum in Ethiopia insightfully showed the edge of business impediments that have been faced by foreign investors in particular focus on registration, licensing, taxation, and renewal. According to Semaw’s study, impediments found in the investment sector were: insufficient supply of credit, shortage of foreign currency, prohibition of licensing permit (Franco valuta), loan www.thereporterethiopia.com restriction and the like. Duty drawbacks in customs, blocking the voucher system for loss of minor item, applications of non-uniform methods of calculations with the custom authority, and rigidity of laws and regulations, lack of trust, deposit advance payment and taxation procedures with the licensing and automation were also widely identified by experts as major obstacles to business. Indeed, the authorities repeatedly reacted on some of the findings of this survey. “We share some of the indicated failures, but they will find solution through consistent implementation of the laws,” Nebiyou Samuel, deputy director of Ethiopian Revenues and Customs Authority (ERCA), said. However, the Ministry of Industry (MoI) does not admit to frequent delays and lengthiness of registration and licensing process. The MoI is of the view that for a reason related to security and dishonesty experienced in the past, “We can’t issue licenses and registration documents since we have faced a lot of issues in screening some dishonest businessmen who misused licenses,” Nuredin Mohamed, Trade Inspection and Regulatory Director and advisor to the state minister, MoI told The Reporter. the willingness of the Despite government to undertake possible changes to improve the business climate in Ethiopia, shortage of skilled labor force will remain a critical problem, according to experts. Capacity building through training, facilities and adoption of best practices would transform the nation and helps to become top destination on the global investment map, they suggest. “Finance and investment reforms, in this regard, play an important role in attracting more FDI Investment... page 30 18| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 SMART PHONES FOR SMART PICTURES Thirty-year-old Aschalew Belete just had his birthday party some days ago. He had no candles, cookies or camera flashes. He celebrated it joined by a couple of friends at Ambassador Park imbibing beer. Abruptly, one of the friends took out his Samsung Galaxy S4 to take a snap shot of the birthday boy. “I need this picture now,” he told his friend. In a somewhat fanciful wittiness the three friends found themselves in a photo shop to print the picture taken on the cellphone’s camera. The print shows a very funny look of Aschalew whose eyes were gazing at the empty beer bottles on the table and another one that shows the 8-year-old Aschalew along with eight candles, and bottles of Miranda. SEE THE FULL STORY ON THE NEXT PAGE www.thereporterethiopia.com Vol. XIX No. 944 |19 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 By Henok Reta Thirty-year-old Aschalew Belete just had his birthday party some days ago. He had no candles, cookies or camera flashes. He celebrated it joined by a couple of friends at Ambassador Park imbibing beer. Abruptly, one of the friends took out his Samsung Galaxy S4 to take a snap shot of the birthday boy. “I need this picture now,” he told his friend. In a somewhat fanciful wittiness the three friends found themselves in a photo shop to print the picture taken on the cellphone’s camera. The print shows a very funny look of Aschalew whose eyes were gazing at the empty beer bottles on the table and another one that shows the 8-year-old Aschalew along with eight candles, and bottles of Miranda. Since then he has kept the two photos of different times, different history with different looks. “The difference can be easy to notice, but the way they were made is just amazing,” he says. Aschalew remembers how often he was asked to stand up properly by the cameraman 22 years ago. “I think my kids would have something quick and easy when compared to what we had back then,” he says. As a pretty modest man who avoids an exotic lifestyle, and the modern way of interaction with the people around, he has long kept himself isolated from the digital world. “I don’t know why, but I know I’m not old-fashioned,” he tells. As a result, he does not want to be on the social media or does not want to use gadgets. “That is the reason why I told my friend I need the picture in print right then,” he reasons out his quick demand of the picture taken by his friend’s phone. In one of the busiest photo shops in Addis Ababa, a group of people are seen occupying the small room busy editing images on their desktop computers. Others sat down on the bench waiting for the delivery of pictures. Selam, a front desk receptionist at photo Wondessen, Bole branch keeps herself busy cutting, cropping and issuing photos. “Most of these pictures are taken by our cameramen here in the studio,” she says. These days, many people, particularly youngsters have begun using a variety of smart phones with high megapixel cameras to capture any moment day and night. While hanging out in a café or bar and even on a picnic or while traveling people have become well accustomed with taking pictures themselves on their phone. “I usually take my own picture on my cellphone. It’s been long since I posed in front of a camera,” Zinash a self-employed young woman told The Reporter. She, however, lacks a habit of printing the pictures she takes on her phones. Since she is an active social media member for socializing and networking she posts her pictures to be viewed by friends and family members. In fact, many of the pictures posted on the social media appear to be more of self-taken phone photos (selfies), according to professional photographers. “Megapixels alone is no guarantee of heightened photographic performance,” Kalab Mengiste, a professional www.thereporterethiopia.com photographer says. Indeed, many would hardly think of the camera quality when purchasing phones. The common questions asked when people are buying a phone are thoroughly related to the battery life, hardware toughness, network access, internet and durability, according to an expert at Yonas mobile. “Yes, some might be well aware of the pixel density with their phone, but what I usually found out is that many are less aware of it,” he says. The formula for fantastic photos comes down to the entire camera module, which includes the size and material of the main camera lens, the light sensor, image processing hardware and the software that ties it all together, according to photography experts. Professional photographers say that the most important ingredient in the optical system is the sensor, because that is the part that captures the light. The sensor is essentially the “film” material of a digital camera. The fact is that if one wants a phone that is super slim and super light and still has a battery life that will last a full day and more-then some compromise has to be made and it is often done by making a smaller sensor, and making compromises on the lens, they argue. Despite the market for smart phones in Ethiopia it seems to be pretty incomparable even when compared with other African countries. Still the number of people using them is getting high, according to smart phone retailers in the Smart phones... page 31 20| Vol. XIX No. 944 Society The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Against the waves Insights of the 2014 Irreecha festival Traditionally decorated Oromos headed by a man with baboon skin head dress By Daniel Dormeyer When they left from Addis Ababa early in the morning of Sunday October 5, the two Europeans, James Cator from England and Daniel Dormeyer from Germany, accompanied by two Ethiopians, Minassie Alemayehu and Haile Mekonen, did not really gauge the significance and importance of what they would experience when attending Irreecha in Bishoftu, Oromia regional state, around 45 minutes south of the capital. With almost one third of Ethiopia’s population, the Oromo constitute the largest ethnicity in Ethiopia and the wider Horn of Africa. Cator and Dormeyer had just arrived, excited about a country charged of history, culture and noble values, and willing to overcome waves of preconceived ideas about Ethiopia. The season of blessing and love Established by Oromo forefathers, Irreacha (also called Irreessa) takes place annually throughout Oromia and amongst Oromo communities abroad on the first Sunday of last week of September or the first Sunday of the first week of October according to Oromo time reckoning (Dhahaa). Bishoftu hosts the major gathering of a festival believed to be one of the largest in Africa. Known as Oromo’s Thanksgiving to their God (Waaqa) for his goodness over the past year, Irreecha marks the beginning of a new lunar calendar and a seasonal change from winter to spring, and more particularly the end time of starvation (Gadaa Belbaa), disunity, chaos (Mormor), and the auspicious occasion to wish plentiful harvests in the upcoming year. After a pleasant drive through though unexpected enchanting landscapes on the uncrowded highway in the wee hours of the morning, during which they wondered about a dead hyena and the probability of getting hit by a car, the multicultural group of friends finally reached Bishoftu. Bishoftu means “the land full of water” in Oromiffa language. Indeed, the main ceremony would take place at the Lake Hora Arsadii. In fact they reached sacred ground, where Oromo people believe God will grant all their wishes. Waves of joy, harmony and unity The car needed to get parked right before a blocked area. It was a short, but already crowded walk down to the lake. The rising sun dispelled the last clouds around Bishoftu, and casted bright spotlights on first waves of chanting and dancing people running down the street and moving towards the venue. Like tens of thousands of Ethiopia’s ethnic Oromo, they gathered for Irreecha to celebrate the transition from the dark and challenging rain season to the sunny new Birraa (Spring) season. Even though some habitants got together in front of their homes around a delicious coffee while teenagers were still playing football, they knew that new waves of people from different parts of the country would arrive soon and just take them along to the ceremony. The effervescence, an irresistible attraction was already palpable. “I was so impressed by the huge number of people, all beautifully dressed and moving ahead peacefully and cheerfully. A real festival of colors. I can’t remember having seen in my country such a traditional event respected and followed by so many people and with so much passion.”, Cator says. Symbols of an identity and a worldview The group of four bought scarfs in the traditional white / red / black colors and a green tree on it, as well as the green grass and yellow flowers (umama) to comply with the tradition. Indeed, www.thereporterethiopia.com everything related to Irreecha has a meaning and a purpose: for instance the Oromo gather in symbolic places such as hilltops, river sides and the shades of big sacred trees. Green being a symbol of fertility, peace, abundance and rain. At Lake Hora Arsadii the three predominant Oromo colors on the Oromia’s traditional dressings sticked out of this huge green area. Waves of joy and happiness brought the pilgrims and the group of four to the shores, amongst thousands of people already standing there and waiting the elders to stir long grasses in the lake before sprinkling the blessed water. They believe to get blessed as well and that it will bring them closer to Waaqa (God). Many of them also made presents to thank God for the blessings and mercies received in the previous year. In the distance various boats could be spotted on the lake, sometimes with newly married couples aboard. An older man started explaining the spiritual significance of Irreecha to Minassie and his obligation to convey the meaning of a ritual that has been passed down many generations and that will be passed to the next ones. Against... page 26 Vol. XIX No. 944 |21 Lifestyle The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 A NEW DAY begins in Addis Ababa Meskel Square is a spot where a considerable number of sportsmen and women workout By Mark Jenkin To walk the streets of Addis Ababa at 6am gives a sense of a city coming to life. Before another hectic day has properly started in this emerging metropolis, there is relative calm. In the Shalla Public park in the Bole Sub City, birds are singing in trees and lush long grass has been freshly watered from the rainy season. There is still a coolness in the air. Women are sweeping the dusty streets with straw brushes, ensuring the front of their shops and homes are well presented. Stray dogs randomly wander by the roadside, uninterested by the activities around them. Men, with baggy tracksuit bottoms hanging from their athletic frames are out for their early runs before the traffic reaches a rush-hour crescendo. They are pounding the pavements and working hard against the heavy air that comes in a location nestled beneath the mountains, almost 2,500m above sea level. Construction workers are getting ready for a day of toil , clambering up the wooden scaffolding of emerging high rise buildings. Lorries pull up alongside the countless building sites. Addis is a place that is expanding fast. It is unrecognizable from 20 years ago and in another few years its appearance will have changed significantly again. It is hoped new roads, railway lines and modern hotels will make this a tourist destination attractive to people from across the world. Then there are signs of the old world too, as herds of goats amble by the side of the road tended by their farmers. In numerous homes, maids and mothers have been up early to do the household chores and prepare food for the day. By 8:30am, the strong sun has burnt through the cloud and thousands of people are bustling in all directions. Children in smartly pressed uniforms head for school. Large groups of worshipers in white robes make towards a religious ceremony at Bole Medhanialem Church. Blue taxis and buses dominate the busy roads. United, Liverpool, Arsenal, Real Madrid, Barcelona, Juventus and Bayern Munich are among the team colors worn. A man is trimming the grass verges, not with a petrol machine but stooped over using hand-held shears and taking pride in his work. Everywhere there are clothes shops, shoe-shine stalls, people selling confectionary and fruit on street corners. The city’s passion for sport can be seen too, at Meskel Square where scores of runners go through their paces along the steep banks. Some do their stretches and push-ups by the side of the road, others sprint up and down the steps like the boxer Rocky Balboa in the movies. Some young boys are busy washing cars. Men in business suits march confidently to their offices. Nurses, police officers and delivery drivers go about their daily business. Fashionably dressed women in vibrant colors take great pride in their appearance. For the young men, there is the more casual look of jeans, tracksuit tops and a never-ending variety of football shirts. The national colors are everywhere. The brilliant yellow, red and green of the Ethiopian flag. And everywhere you look, there are signs of the obsession with Western football. Manchester www.thereporterethiopia.com Young athletes, men and women, are practicing their tempo runs or sprints with dedication and enthusiasm. May be one day they will have the chance to become Olympic champions like their heroes Haile Gebrselassie, Kenenisa Bekele or Turunesh Dibaba. This is a typical morning in Addis Ababa. With the hustle and bustle of contemporary life and the happy, laidback manner of its people, Addis is a city where old traditions and modern culture meet in a fascinating way. Ed.’s Note: The writer is on an internship at The Reporter. 22| Vol. XIX No. 944 Travel The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 HAVE a ride on the wild side By Mette H. Sommer About 225 kilometers east of Addis Ababa and about 6 hours of driving you will find the Awash National Park, a nature reserve, surrounded by beautiful mountains and grassland. Not many foreign people do yet know about the fascinating experiences, which this area of Ethiopia offers, even though there are plenty of opportunities for visitors. First of all the park offers you the opportunity to watch the wild African animals in their natural habitat and the park is a place of residence for an exciting wildlife with spices such as oryx, gazelles, crocodiles, and baboons. Furthermore, a couple of native tribes live in the park, who like to greet you. But be aware that most of them do not want to be photographed, due to their conviction about the camera’s negative influence on the soul. Besides the wildlife and the natives, the park also includes an amazing nature. You can see everything from dry trees and bushes at the grassland to more exotic palms close to the swamp. In the north of the park you can furthermore find hot springs, in which you can bath. But be careful; if you want to jump into the hot water, you should make sure you brought some cold water as well, because the spring is even hotter than the air, which means a higher risk for you to get dehydrated. The park does also include many beautiful sights, such as waterfalls, rivers and mountains which all seems almost unaffected by the presence of man. More than just nature The area that surrounds Awash is much more than just the National Park. Also the cities in the area offer unique experiences. A city which is worth a visit is the small village, Dubti, which you can reach by shared taxis. It will cost you a little less than 90 Birr. The village, which is placed close to beautiful mountains and only 10 minutes of driving from Awash National park, is best described as a hundred houses placed next to the main road. Due to the size of the village, the facilities are far from as good as the ones in the capital, which is an experience by itself, but you will still have the opportunity to order a cup of the great Ethiopian coffee or to do some shopping in the local supermarket. Besides that, you can rent a room for only 150 birr a night, which includes a bed, a toilet, and an ice-cold shower – nor more or less. Of course, you still have the opportunity to rent a more modern room, but since you easily can spend a day on sightseeing, you do not as an ordinary traveler need to upgrade your room for further luxury – it is an experience to live simple. Besides the hotels the city offers traditional entertainment. Especially during the evening you can join go to one of the local bars, where they will show you traditional dances and songs. Furthermore, they will often give you the opportunity to join their dance and sometimes even make a verse about you as the main character of the songs. Besides, that you can also join the traditional Ethiopian Coffee ceremony – but a good idea is to friendly ask them first. In general, the village is very open and interested in the visitors and do therefore do their best to give you the best experiences, at your stay. It is recommendable to hire a local or go there by a smaller company from Addis, as they know the area and generally can show the unknown treasures of Ethiopia. Besides that they would also give you a much better price than most of the travel agencies, which often ask for a lot of money. But if you decide to hire a local, you do of course have to be aware of some differences: The guide would not be a professional tourist guide, and do therefore not expect too much of him. Second, he will probably not book you in to some fancy hotel and you will travel by shared taxi, which will make you explore of Ethiopia in a more down to earth way, which will be great if you are a young or middle-aged traveler. At the same time you will also be showed the sights which only the locals know about – everything from beautiful views to delicious food. A great place to have your lunch is for instance a restaurant, which is found close to the Awash Waterfalls. They cook great food and you can enjoy the tasteful food next to the crocodiles and the river. Other places you can order a roasted chicken and after a half an hour of waiting you will be served a perfectly roasted chicken – fresh from www.thereporterethiopia.com Oryx at the Awash National Park the backyard. Besides that you will also have the opportunity to try one of bajajs. They are an easy and cheap way to get around, and are just like the taxi’s easy to see by their blue and white colors. Great with a break It is a great idea to visit the cities out of Addis, especially if you visit Ethiopia for a longer time. But it craves some planning to find the inspiration for the trip and to decide where to visit. One of the problems is that the a considerable number of Ethiopians often do not know that much about the lowland and different tourist attractions. But when first you discover where to go it is a unique experience. Besides that – arranging a trip from a local travel agency is not that expensive: a weekend in Dubti is only about 2000 birr. But if you stay patient and do some research you will be able to arrange a cheap trip in Ethiopia. Because Ethiopia is much more than just Addis Ababa, and there is so many places which is worth a visit. Ed.’s Note: The writer is on an internship at The Reporter. The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Entertainement Vol. XIX No. 944 |23 His 50 albums and countless solo concerts, along with frequent travels between Europe and Martinique, have finally brought him to Africa to meet the continent’s legends like Manu Dibango CAB: charming trios in blending cultures By Henok Reta The Alliance Ethio-Française has been enormously involved in introducing new, talented musicians in Ethiopia. This time, the invitation brought in the CAB, a very charming trio that colorfully blends cultures and beats. “Simply awesome!” an Ethiopian bass player hailed the performance of the band that entertained a thousand of people at the Italian Cultural Institute. The Cameroonian singer, bassist and songwriter Bassy apparently looked like he was enjoying the formation of the trio as he brilliantly played his Afro-jazz songs being produced from the piano, the drum and the conga drums. Since his first band, the Jazz Crew, whose repertory already reflected his penchant for Bossa Nova, a genre of Brazilian music developed and popularized in the 1950s and 1960s, he took part in the creation of Macase. Macase is widely known as one of the most inventive of the numerous ‘jazz fusion” groups, inspired by the local rhythms which proliferated in the clubs of Cameroon. The group famously collected prestigious African prizes such as the Prix Découvertes RFI, Masa and Kora. Having released the debut album “Leman” in 2009 by the World Connection Label, he has performed in festivals and venues all over the world to envisage his soulful spectrum in Brazil. “It’s just my own sense of discovering cultures to make it music,” he says, as he himself describes himself as “a man of the world.” In the best sense of the world, he is rooted in the land but also a traveler in his soul and open to cultures to find a nexus for what he calls the “missing link” between the African and Latin continents. Conceived as a passionate Photo By: Reporter /Mesfen Solomon “First time in Addis. Are you ready?” Blick Bassy, a Cameroonian singer started the first ever concert for the CAB (Caribbean African Brazil) at the Italian Cultural Institute on Tuesday. His energy, mesmerizing dialogue with the audience and enthusiastic approach to kicking off the trio-concert in Addis Ababa has inspired the audience. He then pointed to the two musicians on the left and right. “Adrian, from Brazil,” he called upon the young percussionist who was born in Aracaju, Brazil, in 1981, to a great bass player father, Narriman Tenorio. “To the right…one of the most talented pianists, Mario Canonge from Martinique,” he introduced the man who invented and orchestrated the CAB trio. CAB preforming at the Italian Cultural Institute musical travelogue, he follows the tragic Adriano DD inherited great diversity “slave route” from Cameroon to Brazil, and fickleness, which made his music passing through Benin, Senegal and even more unique and special. “I really Cape Verde. Now, the meeting of Africa, enjoy the cultural mix that helps us to the Caribbean, and Brazil has just see music is infinite,” he says. Music opened a new era for the cultures and is so much a part of life for the talented traditional melodies to flow on the world young percussionist who built his own stage. Mario Canoge by far appears to first drums made entirely of large dishes be the point of the formation as he plays and casseroles. He tells about his first piano like a master. Born in 1960, in impression of music, particularly the Fort-de-France, capital of Martinique, bass section as his grandfather played he passionately associated himself with trombone in the military orchestra the piano. Although his parents had of Maceio city, capital of Alagoas in a significant role in helping him gain northern Brazil. access to a piano in his childhood, the Martinique star has proven to have Now, the three immensely talented an amazing ability to adapt his piano- musicians find themselves in the perfect playing to a wider variety of genres such place to recreate and reunify themselves, as jazz, zouk and salsa in France. speaking one language through a diverse His 50 albums and countless solo culture. The brilliant collaboration concerts, along with frequent travels seems to be phenomenal for many between Europe and Martinique, have as the trio excessively captures the finally brought him to Africa to meet the attention of the audience with fusions continent’s legends like Manu Dibango, of Afro-Caribbean beats. “Phenomenal Etienne Mbappe, and Gino Sitson. This combination indeed,” Ethiopian music indeed led him to discover another fan of Afro-Jazz told The Reporterr as young talent, Bassy, who’s been given some Ethiopian famous musicians, the nickname of “un angel negro” by his likes of Girum Mezmur, co-founder of fans to put him in the footprints of his the Addis Acoustic Project expressed his compatriot, Manu Dibango. Being born admiration in a standing ovation for the in the richest cultural place in Brazil, trio. www.thereporterethiopia.com 24| Vol. XIX No. 944 Interview The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Photo By: Reporter /Tamrat Getachew PART TNERS FOR DEVELOPMENT In September 2013, the Republic of Belarus opened its embassy in Ethiopia, making it the fifth in Africa. The diplomatic relations between the two countries started after 1991, when both countries were liberated from the socialist regimes Ethiopia from the military regime the Derg and Belarus from the former Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR). Ambassador Dimitry Kuptel is the new Ambassador of the Republic of Belarus to Ethiopia and representative to the African Union (AU). Before he came to Ethiopia, Kuptel was working at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Belarus in different posts and was also ambassador to Vietnam. Neamin Ashenafi of The Reporter sat down with the Ambassador to discuss various issues ranging from the depth of the relationship between the two countries to the challenges and opportunities of the relations of the two countries. Excerpts: Vol. XIX No. 944 |25 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 The Reporter: Can you elaborate on your country and the evolution of the diplomatic relations that your country has with Ethiopia? Ambassador Dimitry Kuptel: The Republic of Belarus is a democratic social-oriented state situated in Central Eastern Europe neighboring Russia on the east and Poland on the west, so after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Belarus became independent from Russia. A couple of years after that, Ethiopia and Belarus started diplomatic relations. relations between Ethiopia and Belarus have not increased, and that is why we are here and have opened our embassy in Ethiopia, to expand our economy and trade ties. This is our aim and why we have opened our embassy here in Ethiopia. It is to scale up the cooperation and to work closely with Ethiopia for mutual benefits. We have got technology, knowledge and machines, which Ethiopia needs to develop the agricultural sector and the mining industry in the future. So I hope we will have successes. And, although our relationship hasn’t been very close, we hope that it will be in the future. It is in this regard that we opened our embassy here in Ethiopia last September. After that we started rapidly and very intensively to develop our cooperation. Beside that we have to emphasize that we started structural cooperation with Ethiopia in the international arena within the frame work of the United Nations on the basis of mutual respect of both countries. We produce different types of machines such as lorries, trains and buses and so on including agricultural manufacturing products such as tractors and so many others and household products such as TV sets and refrigerators. However, unfortunately, the economic These two countries are celebrating the 20th anniversary of their diplomatic relationship. So how is the cooperation going so far: is it going as was planned some 20 years ago? Is it promising, and at the same time what are the challenges? Generally speaking, during this 20-year history of our relations and cooperation, these have been good, especially in the international arena. We also have hopes to speed up our cooperation in all fields. After that we have been providing our knowledge and we trained personnel, educated Ethiopians in our country much more after the collapse of the Soviet Union. This year we celebrate the 20th year of the establishment of diplomatic relations with Ethiopia. The Republic of Belarus is ready and keen to expand political, economic and social diplomatic relations as well as international relations with Ethiopia. So we hope to build a relationship that will be mutually beneficial to both countries. and we are ready to provide even our technologies to produce some parts and units here in Ethiopia to create more jobs. You said that your country is producing a lot of machineries. Are you going to enter the Ethiopian market, apart from your dealing with MetEC? But we don’t want to emphasize only on selling and buying products from each country. We are ready to provide our technology, knowledge and at the same time we are ready to transfer technology to Ethiopia. At this point I would like to mention that we are now working closely with the Metals and Engineering Corporation (MetEC) to renew the Belarusian tractor assembly in Ethiopia built in 1984. We now would like to restart cooperations in this field Of course we are ready to open a representative office here in Ethiopia not only with the government but also with enterprises, the private sector and other companies to work together. There is no difference for us; we are ready to establish not only tractor assemblies but road construction machines, agricultural machines and mining equipment to produce here. Generally, we are ready to provide our technologies and knowledge. www.thereporterethiopia.com You have mentioned the products that your country produces and exports across the globe but, at the same time, Ethiopia also exports some products, mainly agricultural products. So what is your country doing so far in this regard, that is importing Ethiopian products into your country? Unfortunately, Belarusian people probably don’t know much about Ethiopian products. We are already buying flowers, some coffee and some agricultural products and foods but not too much. As I mentioned, our cooperation is on the basis of mutual benefits and that is how it should be. For example we are not producing coffee in our country and we are ready to buy from Ethiopia. We are ready to buy more quantities from Ethiopia. And for this I have always been asking the Ministry of Trade, the Ministry of Industry and the Chamber of Commerce to provide us with reliable partners to establish direct relationships between the representatives of the business community of both countries. So, in this regard, is there any understanding memorandum of or any bilateral agreement with Ethiopian counterparts to boost economic cooperation and the relationship between these two countries? We are now working under the intergovernmental agreements of trade and economic cooperation between our countries as well as the agreement of the cooperation in the sphere of education. We have political consultations between our ministers and we have also signed a memorandum of understanding with the chamber of commerce. And we hope to Partners for.. page 26 26| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Against... CONT`D FROM PAGE 20 Then the group of friends also dipped their grass in the water, trying to imitate the repetitive hand movements people did to reject all possible bad vibrations while making wishes. Probably more generally about peace and health when the Oromos praise God also for fertility and abundance with regards to the one who matter to them, their livestock and the upcoming harvest. Three united dimensions Overwhelmed by this visual feast of colors and the irresistible vision of fraternity, the four friends climbed back to a clearing where the main ceremony would take place. The white seats in the shade of the big sacred trees they spotted when walking down to the lake were now occupied by the central persons of the blessing festival. At this very moment the group of four realized the union of three dimensions of Irreecha: religious, political and social. First this thanksgiving embraces all persuasions: Christians religious (amongst them Orthodox, Protestants), Muslim and Animists. They all came to thank the higher force and pray for a fruitful harvest. Second Oromos from all ages and all stripes gather to Irreecha, sharing the same values and respect for the traditions. Third various officials (speaker of the House of Peoples’ Representatives, officials from the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, President of the Oromia Regional State) performed in harmony with the honored Abagedas (the elders, the traditional leaders of the Oromo community, elected according to the traditional Gadaa principles). The speeches were held in three languages: English, Amharic and Oromiffa. Solemnity, pride, confidence and magnificence emerged from the speeches, reminding people about the uniqueness of this highly symbolic and truly global event. The festival is held annually on the shores of lake Hora Ethiopia is coming Warmth was in the air and also in the words. Besides the respect of tradition and the awareness for the Oromo culture and history, this unique event symbolizes the pride and rise of Ethiopia. Elites and supporters got encouraged to help paving the way for promoting Ethiopian values of sharing and fraternity conveyed by Irreecha, but also to convince the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization ((UNESCO) to register this outstanding festival on the representative list Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity. “The holiday is the only occasion, to the best of my knowledge, that brings together members from all religious persuasions to honor it. Seeing the masses attending this day is an evidence to how people here have not abandoned their traditional values even as they embrace modernity. It’s no wonder that it is a candidate for UNESCO’s World Heritage list with generations after generations protecting it,”Minassie says. A sign sent to the world When the group of four left, they walked back against further, even more massive waves of people joining the celebration. Waves of peace (Nagaa), freedom (bilisummaa), unity (tokkummaa), and reconciliation (araara), bringing people closer to each other and making religious, political and social bonds. The two Europeans perceived Irreecha PAR RTNER TNERS FOR.. TN FOR... .... be signing another agreement. What were the challenges that you have faced in boosting the cooperation between these two countries so far? The major challenge that comes to my mind first is the lack of information, lack of direct conversation and knowledge of the potentials of the economy of both countries. Therefore, we should inform business communities about the broader products we produce in both countries and about our opportunities and the potentials to establish a strong relationship and cooperation. You have mentioned that lack of information and direct contact were the major challenges of the cooperation of these two countries so far. In this regard, one of the means to overcome such a challenge is organizing a forum and business- to-business meetings. What have you done to inform the business community of both countries about the potentials and opportunities? Yes, the first step is to organize a forum together with deputy foreign minister of the Belarusian Republic and invite all Ethiopian companies to come to exchange dialogues and at the same time to see what to learn more about Belarus. This will be conducted in one week’s time here in Addis Ababa. After that we are planning to organize exhibitions in both countries to invite representatives from the Ministry of Education, industry and representatives of business to Belarus to participate in our exhibitions and conferences. How do you describe the process so far and what is your plan in the future in relation to informing and CONT`D FROM PAGE 25 addressing the business community in both countries? We will organize trips for representatives of the mass media to our country. In our country, journalists also always want to learn more about our partners like Ethiopia and they always ask what we are doing here in Ethiopia and what kind of potential we have here and so on. Now that Belarus has opened an embassy here in Ethiopia, what are you expecting from the relationship with Ethiopia? Belarus only has five embassies in Africa. The embassy that we opened in Addis Ababa is the fifth one and we are looking forward to strengthening our relations not only with Ethiopia but also with other African countries. Of course, Ethiopia is the seat of the www.thereporterethiopia.com also as a positive movement against many waves they are experiencing in their societies: tradition resisting to modernity (people still looking for endorsement by the elder), all ages united instead of generations divided, all social classes brought together rather than class struggle, all confessions in harmony unlike so many parts of the world. This year Oromos celebrated the Irreecha blessing festivities in millions. The group of four felt proud and honored to have been part of this movement. And they simply let themselves go with these positive waves. Ed.’s Note: The writer is on an internship at The Reporter. African Union (AU), which is a very important body to confront both issues in Africa and Ethiopia and that’s why we are here and we expect with Ethiopia, a better future. What comes to mind is that we are at the right place at the right time, where Ethiopia is about to finish the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) in about two years. Therefore, we are ready to provide our knowledge and technology and our machines for the country’s rapid development. Is there any specific area that the Belarusian side wants to focus on in providing technologies, know-hows and machineries in Ethiopia? We are in the beginning of the consultations between our ministries. We are only to start to find the directions and find the challenges, problems and also the potentials. But generally we are focusing on providing all that we have, all our machineries, all technologies and to participate in all fields of activity in the country, not only specific plans but be engaged in all endeavors of the country. Vol. XIX No. 944 |27 Feature + The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Photo By: Reporter /Mesfen Solomon Enhancing the contribution of the mining sector Panelists of the Ethiopian Extractive Industries Forum mine would be the Allana Potash mine in the Afar Regional State in the Dallol Depression. By Kaleyesus Bekele Ethiopia is not much known in the mining world. Except for the small-scale gold, tantalum and gemstones exports, the country is not among the list of major mineral exporters in Africa. There are no large-scale mines in Ethiopia. The only large-scale mine is operated by MIDROC Gold in southern Ethiopia. The company started mining in 1998 and annually produces four tons of gold in the Lega Dembi mine in the Oromia Regional State. It mainly exports the gold bullions to Switzerland. MIDROC’s Lega Dembi Gold mine is ranked 170th in the world in terms of value of production in 2012. The Canadian mining firm, Allana Potash, plans to mine one million tons of potash every year beginning in 2017, then by generating 430 million dollars annual revenue. According to Allana, the potash deposit is estimated at 3.2 billion tons. The project is valued at 1.2 billion dollars. Allana, together with its partners, will invest 630 million dollars in the potash mine and related infrastructure, the largest Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in the mining sector so far. The other new mine is the Tulu Kapi gold mine in western Ethiopia. A sizable gold mine was discovered by a British company, Nyota Minerals, in West Wollega of the Oromia Regional State. The Tulu Kapi gold reserve is estimated at 24.9 tons. International Finance Corporation (IFC) is involved in the project, which was expected to be operational in 2014. This failed to materialize due to the declining price of gold in the international market and the dearth of investment capital. The state-owned Ethiopian Minerals Development S.C. (EMDSC) mines tantalum concentrate in the Kenticha mine in the Oromia Regional State in Guji zone. The Kenticha tantalum mine operations has been on hold since 2013 due to the government’s effort to privatize it. EMDSC wants to process the tantalum concentrate rather than exporting the raw tantalum concentrate. The tantalum concentrate is mainly exported to China. In the south there is also a small stateowned mine called Adola, where alluvial gold has been mined for over half a century. Placer gold has been mined in Ethiopia for more than 2000 years, but a significant large-scale mining sector has not been developed yet. More than one million people are engaged in artisanal mining primarily focused on gold. Artisanal miners pan eight tons of gold every year, contributing a significant amount of foreign currency to the coffers of the government. Gemstones, mainly, opal, are produced by artisanal miners. Rough and curved gemstones are exported to India, Europe and the US. The Ethiopian Ministry of Mines (MoM) is encouraging and assisting artisanal miners. Tantalum is also produced by artisanal miners. Artisanal miners generate more than 400 million dollars, the lion’s share coming from gold export. Nyota recently farmed out the concession to another British company, KEFI Minerals. KEFI is now updating the feasibility study undertaken by Nyota. The Tulu Kapi mine could be operational within three years. Ethiopia is also endowed with a range of industrial minerals deposits including potash, limestones, coal, iron ore, tantalite, field spar, quartz, dimension stones and dolomite, among others. The third new mine will be Sakaro Gold mine discovered by MICROC Gold. The Sakaro gold mine is only five km away from the Lega Dembi mine. The gold deposit is estimated at 22.5 tons. MIDROC is expected to start production soon. In the past 25 years no new mine was opened in Ethiopia. Now there are about three new large-scale mines in the pipeline that will go operational in the coming few years. The largest new The ministry has issued 200 mineral exploration licenses. A number of companies have reported gold discoveries including ASCOM Mining, Stratex and Ezana Mining in the www.thereporterethiopia.com Benishangul, Afar and Tigrai regional states. In 2011-2012, the mining sector earned 618 million dollars from mineral exports – 2/3 coming from artisanal mining. The mining sector is expected to generate 2 billion dollars by 2024, thereby employing 8000 citizens. The Ethiopian government aims at building and developing an essentially new economic sector – a large-scale mineral sector. The current policy framework envisions the mineral sector to be the backbone of the industry by 2020-2023. The World Bank this week released an extensive study on the Ethiopian mining sector at a consultative meeting held at the Hilton Hotel on Octrober 7 and 8. The report assesses the potential of the mining sector and the challenges the sector is facing. The study, entitled Strategic Assessment of Ethiopia’s Mining Sector, jointly prepared by the World Bank and the Department for International Development (DFID), the governments of Australia and Canada as well as the Ministry of Mines, was launched during the two-day forum. The study assesses the potential of Ethiopia’s mining sector to contribute to sustainable economic growth and development. It further provides recommendations for the initiatives and actions that will be required for such development to take place, and identifies the risk and opportunities that this entails. The World Bank says the need for this type of strategic analysis follows from the Government of Ethiopia’s (GoE) ambition to – as part of the Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP) – develop the mining sector to become the main pillar of the economy. Enhancing.. page 31 28| Vol. XIX No. 944 This approach to governance has had a profound impact on the mentality of the American people. A 2002 study indicated that three-quarters of Americans feel connected to their communities, and consider their quality of life to be excellent or good, with nearly half of adults participating in a civic group or activity. America’s... CONT`D FROM PAGE 13 individualism, which has brought about decreased deference to authority. Indeed, similar patterns are characteristic of most post-modern societies. This social shift probably will not influence US institutions’ effectiveness as much as one might think, given America’s decentralized federal system. In fact, gridlock in the national capital is often accompanied by political cooperation and innovation at the state and municipal levels, leading citizens to view state and local governments, as well as many government agencies, much more favorably than the federal government. This approach to governance has had a profound impact on the mentality of the American people. A 2002 study indicated that three-quarters of Americans feel connected to their communities, and consider their quality of life to be excellent or good, with nearly half of adults participating in a civic group or activity. That is good news for the US. But it does not mean that America’s leaders can continue to ignore the political system’s shortcomings, such as the gerrymandered “safe seats” in the House of Representatives and obstructive processes in the Senate. Whether such sources of gridlock can be overcome remains to be seen. And there is legitimate reason to doubt America’s ability to maintain its “hyperpower” status, not least owing to the rise of major emerging economies. But, as the conservative author David Frum notes, over the last two decades, the US has experienced a swift decline in crime, auto fatalities, alcohol and tobacco consumption, and emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide, which cause acid rain – all while leading an Internet revolution. Given this, dire comparisons to, say, the decline of Rome are simply unwarranted. Ed.’s Note: Joseph S. Nye, Jr., is a professor at Harvard and the author of Presidential Leadership and the Creation of the American Era. The article was provided to The Reporter by Project Syndicate: the world’s pre-eminent source of original op-ed commentaries. Project Syndicate provides incisive perspectives on our changing world by those who are shaping its politics, economics, science, and culture. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of The Reporter. The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 The evolution... ability to provide the financial backstop needed to prevent contagion. This implies that transferring the majority of revenue-raising capacity to the regions would be a mistake for the UK, because doing so would give the country a banking union without a fiscal backstop. And that, revealingly, is precisely what the eurozone has. That is not somewhere the UK should want to go. additional federal transfers. To counter this deficit bias, federations in which states do much of the spending and the central government raises most of the taxes typically impose balanced-budget rules on subnational governments. Forty-nine of the 50 US states, for example, have such rules in one form or another. In the US, control over social policy is delegated to the states, allowing local legislatures to tailor programs to local tastes and use resources efficiently. But those local policies are still subject to federal oversight. The federal government steps in – and has the capacity to do so – when, for example, civil liberties are being violated. The Scotland Act of 2012 caps the region’s deficit at 10 percent of its budget and limits how much the Scottish government can borrow. These issues are now likely to be reopened with further devolution. But reconsidering debt and deficit limits on regional governments is not the same thing as abandoning them. The experience of other federations shows that the latter would be a mistake. And yet there also is the danger that federal authorities will assign responsibilities to state and local governments but not give them the resources they need to carry them out. And even where revenues are otherwise adequate, states have an incentive to spend more on social programs and, pointing to the resulting deficits, ask for At the same time, rigid rules limiting deficit spending by regional governments could place the UK in the same fiscal straitjacket as the eurozone, where member states are prevented from borrowing in recessions. Fiscal policy would then become dangerously procyclical, aggravating business fluctuations. Turkey is a vital... has long been accused of tolerating ISIL — whose fighters often transit through Turkey — because the group was useful in countering both Assad and the Kurds. Even if the vice president apologized to Erdoan, last week US Vice President Joe Biden blamed Turkey in part for the rise of groups like ISIL. “They poured hundreds of millions of dollars and thousands of tons of weapons into anyone who would fight against Assad,” he said. The current international coalition strategy is to focus only on fighting the extremists, which gives breathing space for President Bashar al-Assad, whose overthrow has long been Turkey’s top priority in Syria and the ongoing international support for Democratic Union Party (PYD) — the armed sister party of the Turkey-based Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) insurgency, which Ankara regards as a “terrorist” organization are the two main points of difference for Turkey and the international community. Opposing the current strategy, Turkey prime minister said “If ISIS[L] goes, another radical organization may come in,” he said. “So our approach should be comprehensive, inclusive, strategic and combined ... not just to punish -- to satisfy our public opinion -- to punish one terrorist organization, but to eliminate all terrorist threats in the future, and also to eliminate all brutal crimes against humanity committed by the regime.” From the outset, I think both Ankara and the international community know the importance of ground operations; and the Turkish army can defeat this group. Ankara waited this long for two reasons I think. The first thing being that before involving themselves in the current international coalition to tackle this group, Turkey demanded the overthrow of the Assad regime as a favor. The second and main thing to defeat this group is the role of Syrian Kurds because once Syrian Kurds are able to strengthen their power it will definitely send a clear message to Kurds in Turkey as well. The so-called giving military and financial support to moderate groups in Syria as strategy to topple the Assad regime might compromise the security interest of Turkey. As I tried to state in the above paragraphs, the support for PYD — the armed sister party of the Turkey-based Kurdish PKK insurgency, which Ankara regards as a “terrorist” organization can affect Turkey’s interest. The Ankara government is currently engaged in peace talks with the PKK and it has long been wary that Syrian Kurdish success would send an unwanted message. Last week I asked why the international community waited this long while ISIL has been killing thousands of civilians, religious and ethnic minorities in broad daylight. Why did the international community wait too long for intervention? For Turkey I think the government of Ankara was in ambiguity to decide which “terrorist group” it preferred to have as a southern neighbor: The PYD, which will affect the internal security of Turkey by sending bad messages to Kurds in Turkey, or ISIL, which is a terrorist group and its brutal tactics - including mass killings and abductions of members of religious and ethnic minorities, as well as the beheadings of soldiers and journalists www.thereporterethiopia.com CONT`D FROM PAGE 10 Simply put, if fiscal policy is to play a stabilizing role in the UK economy, it will have to be conducted at the federal or central level. The central government and its revenue-raising capacity cannot be allowed to wither away. Devolution is coming, and its appeal is undeniable. But it is important to know where devolution ends and dysfunction begins. Ed.’s Note: Barry Eichengreen is Pitt Professor of American History and Institutions at the University of Cambridge. His newest book, Hall of Mirrors: The Great Depression, The Great Recession, and the Uses – and Misuses – of History, will be published by Oxford University Press in December. The article was provided to The Reporter by Project Syndicate: the world’s pre-eminent source of original op-ed commentaries. Project Syndicate provides incisive perspectives on our changing world by those who are shaping its politics, economics, science, and culture. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of The Reporter. CONT`D FROM PAGE 10 but a counter force to tackle the Assad regime. What I understand from the current strategy of the international community is that indirectly the real game plan was first for ISIL to defeat and weaken the Kurd resistance, then for Turkey to involve her military to protect her borders. Because Turkey has a significant role in defeating this group and Ankara is also vital for cutting human supply of ISIL by securing border security. I strongly support the possibility of broadening the target towards the Assad regime. As the Prime Minister of Turkey Ahmet Davutoglu eloquently put it, “We said chemical weapons are the red line. He used chemical weapons. What happened to him?” “We didn’t do anything. “He killed people by punishing them through hunger. He surrounded cities, neighborhoods, and kept them hungry.” This is a time to consider Turkey’s role in defeating ISIL. This a time for the international community to consider Turkey’s demands to broaden the target and include the Assad regime, because for me, both are the same in their crimes, killings, and massacre and more importantly in there character of inhumanity. Ed.’s Note: Mesued Mustefa is a consultant and part time instructor at New Generation University College (NGUC). He has a Masters Degree in Journalism and Communication and a Postgraduate Certificate in International Diplomacy. He tries to understand and examine the dynamics of international politics. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of The Reporter. He can be reached at mesued1994@gmail.com. Vol. XIX No. 944 |29 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment www.thereporterethiopia.com 30| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 The new... Modern political processes and structures are simply not well suited for conducting – much less settling – philosophical disputes. Democratic institutions are designed for making deals between competing interests, with parliaments specializing in finding the right combination of concessions to enable agreement on a generally accepted solution. Likewise, international forums like the G-20 exist precisely to persuade a large number of vastly different countries to set aside philosophical questions for the sake of their shared economic, political, or security interests. Philosophies do not just give a little here and there, blurring over the difficult bits in the hope that everything will work out in the end. Imagine asking a Kantian to add just a bit of utilitarian calculation to the categorical imperative. Of course, resolving a philosophical debate is not impossible. It was standard pre-modern practice to overcome such differences with a formal disputation. In the early sixteenth century, the German princes attempted to settle the philosophical challenge presented by Protestant reformers by engaging Martin Luther to debate a prominent orthodox Catholic theologian, Johannes Eck. CONT`D FROM PAGE 14 There are not that many modern varieties of this sort of practice, but the 1944 United Nations Monetary and Financial Conference at Bretton Woods comes close. By systemically engaging with the economic issues involved in building a viable international system, experts created a new global economic and political order. In a sense, central banks have begun to resemble medieval philosophical faculties, with discussions addressing the issues underlying policy decisions, rather than just the policies themselves. In the ECB, for example, a debate is underway to determine under which deviation from fiscal conditions orthodoxy might be stabilizing in the long term. How that debate is resolved could lead to a new kind of international cooperation. At a time when political processes are stalled on both sides of the Atlantic, the US Federal Reserve and the ECB have been engaging in a series of policy innovations, feeling their way toward a solution that could promote and sustain economic recovery. On this basis, the ECB is recasting itself as the incubator of a new intellectual and philosophical synthesis. But central banks’ new role as supreme arbiters of policy truth is fraught with hazard. Given that the solutions that emerge from their disputations and analyses will be the product of technocratic – not democratic – processes, they are likely to trigger populist backlashes. Moreover, the policy approaches that central banks produce may be too complex and interlinked to function efficiently. In particular, the attempt to make expansionary policies conditional on the implementation of a host of microeconomic reforms is problematic. If only some parts of a complex package linking fiscal leeway with structural reform are realized, the outcome is likely to disappoint – or even prove counterproductive. When it does, the old philosophical divisions are likely to resurface. Ed.’s Note: Harold James is Professor of History at Princeton University and a senior fellow at the Center for International Governance Innovation. The article was provided to The Reporter by Project Syndicate: the world’s pre-eminent source of original op-ed commentaries. Project Syndicate provides incisive perspectives on our changing world by those who are shaping its politics, economics, science, and culture. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of The Reporter. Investment... and write a success story,” Jean-Paul Gauthier, Principal of Locus Economica LLC, says. He argues forcefully that sometimes a bad system can be remedied via a good implementation practice. He insists that the government should focus on implementation. According to him, trust should come before verification of the investors. In a survey, he cited Kenya’s licensing and automation experience appeared to be a very good example here. “They have wellmaintained record since some decades ago, even during regime changes the records survived,” he explained. The adoption of basic principles starts with trusting the investor and evaluating the on-line company profiles of the investor or the electronic signatures, according to Jean-Paul. He recommends an on-line business forum that would ease the burden of safety beforehand. On-line business forum in South Africa has yielded in simplifying paperwork registration process and license issuance, he explains. “Ethiopia should become a one-stop shop,” he argues. Kenya’s experience shows that reviewing some 86 licenses, in which they maintained 34, eliminating 20 and simplifying 32 from January 2014 to September 2104. Thierry Mutombo, however, reassessed the causes for lagging behind of Ethiopia and most of the members. He argues that COMESA’s initial commitment towards trade issues rather than investment is the basic reason. Nevertheless, the investment reforms took place in some member states that have tremendously improved the investment. According to Mutombo, Zambia and Mauritius have been found to be exemplary in easing business deals, creating viable environment, and simplifying licensing. The creation of the Zambia Development Authority (ZDA) in 2007 has centralized and rationalized investment facilitation and promotion. It has also made generous incentives schemes available for investors and aftercare services. Furthermore, the development of multi-facility economic zones has provided investors with a more secure and well-equipped environment to operate. The ongoing reforms in the areas of automated registrations, permit and visa processing, registration of land, and customs clearings are said to have been transforming the country’s status to a leading position, he sates. In fact, the World Banks’ Second Investment Climate Assessment for Zambia (2009) confirmed that Zambia’s business environment has improved dramatically since the first assessment in 2004. With more positive business results, previously identified problems such as macroeconomic stability, high taxes, and corruption, among other things, are being tackled and did not figure among the major obstacles in 2008 survey. “Business registration is simplified when the country is doing its best on CONT`D FROM PAGE 17 easing burden with getting construction permit and sector-specific licenses as it was also joined by Zimbabwe to launch similar formality in licensing and custom transit,” Mutombo said. The same thing is true with Mauritius, as it appears to be one of the most competitive, stable and successful economies with the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of USD 9.5 billion, according to data by the US State Department. Since the reforms in 2006, it has attracted more than USD 1.6 billion in the form of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), including USD 443 million in 2010 and USD 339 million in 2011. The World Bank’s Doing Business report also ranks Mauritius first among African economies and 23rd worldwide, out of 183 economies in terms of overall ease of doing business. “There is a constructive dialogue with the government so that things will look much better than now,” Barbara Plinkert, Chargé D’affaires of the EU delegation to Ethiopia, says. “The EUBFE will do more in promoting the business climate in Ethiopia,” she predicts. On the other hand, COMESA’s newly-launched network would also boost the capacity of the agency for investment in Ethiopia. “We are nominating an Ethiopian CEO for the PTA (financial arm of COMESA),” Mutombo reflected on the stronger tie that his organization and Ethiopia will have to boot investment. The adoption of basic principles starts with trusting the investor and evaluating the on-line company profiles of the investor or the electronic signatures, according to Jean-Paul. He recommends an on-line business forum that would ease the burden of safety beforehand. On-line business forum in South Africa has yielded in simplifying paperwork registration process and license issuance, he explains. www.thereporterethiopia.com The American civil-rights struggle that reached its height in the 1960s fought racial prejudice and discrimination at home and opposed colonialism abroad. But there is a war of liberation that remains to be won worldwide – against child labor, child marriage, child trafficking, and discrimination against girls. A generation... CONT`D FROM PAGE 14 Sadly, the world’s response to pleas for donations has been slow and miserly. This indifference mirrors similar reactions to other recent global appeals, such as for schooling for Syrian refugees in Lebanon. The lack of concern seems particularly callous when one considers that the cost of educating a refugee child is no more than USD 8 a week. There is simply not enough outrage – except from young people themselves. They are more assertive in standing up for their right to education than the adults who are supposed to uphold that right. It was particularly encouraging to see hundreds of global youth ambassadors from 100 countries descend on New York recently to demand the right to education and to support the Bring Back Our Girls campaign in Nigeria. Bring Back Our Girls is the highestprofile campaign highlighting discrimination against girls. But it is only part of a growing global movement by young people for civil rights. The American civil-rights struggle that reached its height in the 1960s fought racial prejudice and discrimination at home and opposed colonialism abroad. But there is a war of liberation that remains to be won worldwide – against child labor, child marriage, child trafficking, and discrimination against girls. None of these evils will end until basic education is made compulsory for all – just as was done in the West more than a century ago. The campaign for the 219 Nigerian girls – kidnapped simply because they wanted to go to school – is an iconic battle of this freedom struggle. That struggle will be won some day. No injustice can last forever. But for the missing girls and their loved ones, it is a struggle that cannot be won soon enough. Ed.’s Note: Gordon Brown, a former prime minister of the United Kingdom, is the United Nations Special Envoy for Global Education. The article was provided to The Reporter by Project Syndicate: the world’s pre-eminent source of original op-ed commentaries. Project Syndicate provides incisive perspectives on our changing world by those who are shaping its politics, economics, science, and culture. The views expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of The Reporter. Vol. XIX No. 944 |31 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 PHONES... city. “The use of smart phone es has just become more than n luxury since life is getting a bit easier with it,” Kirube el Legesse, a smart phon ne technician, says. Sinc ce he got back here from m the Middle East a few w years ago, he has been n fixing smart phone es and tablets. Many y use their phone es for browsing th he web while others do additional things lik ke taking a photograph h. And fixing the problem m with the camera len ns could be a bit tougher and challenging. “Honestly y speaking technicians lack k some intricate knowledg ge with the camera of a phone,” he h says. When looking at the basic question n of how often do people use theiir phones to take images, the randomly y selected individuals approached by y The Reporterr replied “very much h” since self-shot photos (selfiess) appears to be more enjoyable than n professionally taken one. one “I really enjoy it. Whenever I’m alone sitting somewhere and if my phone is in my hand I take a picture or even take some video shots,” Zinash Enhancing... The report indicates that despite the fact that large-scale mining is still virtually non-existent, Ethiopia does have the geological potential for the discovery of new and sizeable economic deposits. The report identifies gold, copper, tantalum, and potash as the main foreign currency earners. In the 2011/12 fiscal year the Ethiopian mining sector contributed about 1.5 percent to the country’s GDP estimated at 32 billion dollars. The sector accounted for 618 million dollars (19 percent) of the country’s export, with gold making up close to 100 percent of the mining exports. According to the report in 2012, total sales from the mining sector in Africa were valued at 120 billion dollars representing nearly 10 percent of the continent’s GDP. In Africa metal mining and coal mining are about the same magnitude in terms of value. Among the metals, gold, copper and iron ore make up more than half of the value. “If one assumes that the geology of Ethiopia is as prospective as the African average, then these numbers would imply that the present day economic potential for the development of the Ethiopian mining sector would be to achieve an annual turnover of nearly 5 billion dollars,” the report said. The report highlights the hurdles in the Ethiopian mining sector. In adequate promotional work, in efficient licensing procedures, dearth of trained professionals, low productivity, and border conflicts (disagreements related to land use) are some of the challenges facing the mining sector. Back in 2011 the MoM suspended licensing for about two years saying that they wanted to review applications and working procedures. “In the absence of the recent success stories (apart from Allana Potash) and with limited geological data pertinent to exploration, the collection of new high quality data and the subsequent marketing of these data through a longterm strategy for investment promotion assume vital importance,” the report states. The report indicated that the existence of a modern and well-functioning mining cadastre and registry system and clear rules for the award of licenses are key features for the promotion of investments in the mining sector. The Ministry of Mines commissioned a computerized mining cadastre system in 2011 but it has not been functioning. According to the report, there are critical capacity constraints at the Ministry of Mines licensing department. The report stressed the importance of having a clear legal framework both to attract investors and to facilitate regulation of the industry. The lack of trained professionals and staff turnover at the Ethiopian Ministry of Mines and Ethiopian Geological Survey (GSE) were discussed. “While considerable competence exists in particular among many MoM and GSE long-term employees, the overall capacity at the ministry and GSE for proper promotion, supervision and regulation of the sector is limited,” says the report. “The main reasons for this include the historically non-existent large-scale mining sector, which has not provided the opportunity for consistent responds. On the hand, some also enjoy shooting each other while hanging out together. However, pictures are often left stored on the memory of the phone rather than being printed. “Pictures taken at a ceremony usually get printed more often,” Selam, the receptionist, told The Reporter. In a more irritating manner, those pictures stored on the phone can definitely get lost or corrupted suddenly. In spite of the growing market for smart phones in the heinous crimes on phones is also getting momentum. “This might be a good reason to keep my pictures printed or have a backup,” Ziansh terribly speaks about the awful experience she observed with her friend some time ago. “My friend lost her phone and everything on it. Now, she has learnt to backup her files,” she speaks on behalf of her friend. No doubt, phones, tablets and even laptops have served many in the place of cameras since a decade ago and that could have made a serious impact in the photo shop business. “Yes, I would say so, but it will never stop the business since a professional camera man is always needed in some circumstances,” Kalab argues. The quality of images differs from CONT`D FROM PAGE 27 capacity development; the high number of staff at MoM and the GSE (Totally 1,500 according to the structural plans with current number of employees being about 900) of which the majority are working in administration or support process rather than core process; a high turnover of staff and a decrease in the number of long term experienced staff, prevents consistent capacity building and which is related to civil sector salaries being significantly lower than those offered by the private sector, and non-flexible budgeting and procurement procedures,” the report reads. In planning for future mining development, the report recommends the establishment of “resource corridor”. The recommendation includes the establishment of a clear policy direction, addressing organizational and capacity building needs at MoM and increased provision of information on the geological prospectiveness of Ethiopia. The report also highlighted the need for the engagement of civil society in the mining sector in dealing with communities’ concerns. The World Bank, the Canadian Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development (DFATD), the Australian, Chinese and the British governments assist the Ministry of Mines. The report said significant support to the Ethiopian mining sector is being planned through the Australian government, DFATD, DFID, the World Bank and Chinese initiatives, the work that is identified must be carefully coordinated to avoid duplications of efforts. In the course of the meeting DFATD www.thereporterethiopia.com CONT`D FROM PAGE 19 phone to phone as it often brings about a competition amongst the manufacturers. When Nokia first came up with Pure View technology used in 808, its announcement of the 41megapixel camera toting no sense, However, thanks to the camera companies the term megapixel had become a kind of short hand for image quality, states NDTV Gadgets website. Simply put, every new phone that launches has ads that focus on photography. While most refrain from saying it in as many words, manufacturers proclaim that their phone’s camera is better than what is in the market. Still the current thinking about megapixel is misleading, according to experts. Whatever the size of the market for smart phones in Ethiopia it looks pretty small, but retailers argue that the number of users is growing fast. And nowadays, selfies are gaining momentum over the professionally taken studio photos. For many, it has also become a permanent hobby as they are often seen taking selfshots in different places. “Experts argue that phone camera and pixels should matter since these days people share photos on social networking sites like Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. announced the launch of a new support program to the Ethiopian mining sector. Minister Counselor and head of development cooperation, Amy Baker, told The Reporterr that DFATD allocated 12.5 million Canadian dollars for technical assistance program that would last for five years. Baker said the program will assist Axum and Addis Ababa University Science and Technology in the areas of strengthening mining education. DFATD has been providing technical assistance for the MoM licensing department. The World Bank has been proving technical assistance to the MoM in the artisanal mining sector and the accession of Ethiopia to the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) with an outlay of 3.6 million dollars. Kristen Hund, senior mining specialist with the World Bank, told The Reporterr that the whole purpose of the study and the forum was to identify the gaps in the mining sector and cooperate in filling the existing gaps. “Based on the needs of the ministry the World Bank wants to assist in addressing policy issues, and capacity building programs. We want to help them in revising the petroleum law, if they think it is necessary,” Hund said. Guang Zhe Chen, World bank Country Director for Ethiopia, said, “Sharing of international best practices on Extractive Industries will contribute to building a solid base for their good governance, which in turn will facilitate sound management of revenue and equitable growth that will further the sustainable development of Ethiopia.” Officials of the Ministry of Mines seem to be happy with the World Bank’s study. Minister Tolossa Shagi said the ministry will work with development partners in the areas of capacity building. “The report is good. It identifies the gaps in the mining sector and where we can cooperate,” Tolossa said. 32| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment www.thereporterethiopia.com Vol. XIX No. 944 |33 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment MEDIA COUNCIL... CONT`D FROM PAGE 1 By establishing an independent Media Council, the industry avoids a possibility of having a mandatory statutory media council which the government warned it would promulgate. the council but a consensus was reached against the notion. A heated debate ensued on the issue of membership to the Ethics Panel, accountable to the General Assembly, with some arguing against the inclusion of government. In the draft Article of Association, the executive, judiciary and legislative organs of the government are represented. Hours of debates led to a consensus that welcomed the inclusion of the executive and legislative organs of the government. However, most argued against the inclusion of a member of the judiciary within the panel and in the event of an inclusion they opted for a member who is a retired judge. The 15-member Ethics Panel will also have representatives from the private and state media, journalists’ associations, civic societies, chamber of commerce, religious institutions, higher learning institutions and famous personalities. The Council hopes to get its finance from three main sources including membership contributions, donations from domestic sources and fundraising activities. The forum rejected democratic fund, which was stated in the draft code, as another main source of income leaving it for the general assembly to decide on the issue of finance from the government as it deems appropriate. However, the issue of legal registration remains unresolved despite the draft Article of Association stating that the Council will be registered in accordance with the Charities and Societies Proclamation. The Charities and Societies Agency, the regulatory body, claims it is not within its mandate to register the Media Council. However, Mimi Sebhatu, chair of the organizing committee, remains optimist the Media Council will be set up. “This is a huge step forward,” Mimi told The Reporter. “What is left now is only procedural and we expect to establish the council in two months.” After incorporating the feedback from the forum, the draft codes will be sent back to stakeholders for comments after which time the Council is expected to be established. By establishing an independent Media Council, the industry avoids a possibility of having a mandatory statutory media council which the government warned it would promulgate. www.thereporterethiopia.com 34| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 By Leyou Tameru @anchihoye Bits & Water ministers... Pieces What Ebola has taught me! Ebola has been on the headlines for the past couple of months. The media has been covering the epidemic from all sides. From the number of infected and dead to its potential spread to different parts of the world. Opinion polls, info graphics, data, probability and reality have all been put together to apparently inform the public but in reality they’re allcreating more confusion and fear than actually informing. The way this whole thing has evolved there are a few things that have bothered me. At the beginning the world didn’t care much, the first countries to have been affected were African. The reaction of other countries, including their African neighbors, was to close borders and isolate them. But that response was clearly not the right one, considering how communicable Ebola is and how small the world has gotten; it was a not-sowell-reasoned reaction. Before we knew it there were nonAfricans who became infected. And at that point, things began to change. The perception of the epidemic as incurable suddenly changed to a potentially curable epidemic. Talk of experimental drugs that magically cured the westerners who were affected started a whole new conversation about the value of black vis-à-vis white life. How come these drugs weren’t discussed prior to that? Once these drugs were “successful” pharmaceutical companies were eager to test them out on other patients in Africa, a move that has aroused my skepticism. The one thing that saddened me the most was that the first call for action on Ebola on an international level was made by President Barack Obama. African states followed his lead. In fact, the African Union had an “emergency” meeting about the topic in September, a good 6 months since the epidemic re-surfaced. The World Health Organization and the US government were among the first to respond to the crisis. What does this say about inter-continental support? Quarantines and testing centers were set up in airports and borders. During the US-Africa Summit, African presidents whose countries were affected by Ebola were actually tested prior to entering the US. The president of Guinea was one of them. What is the purpose of these testing centers in airports though? I feel that their main value is in making people feel safe and not in keeping them safe. Considering how the epidemic spreads, these centers come a little too late. By the time that plane has landed, many would have already been exposed and the centers can’t do very much. The issue gets complicated further, especially in light of the availability of these miracle drugs seldom discussed. As it turns out, making them available was no easy fit. This past week a black man died in Texas because the drug that was administered to him was not the same as the one used at Emory, those drugs worked. The reason these two hospitals did not use the same drug is because they had run out of the one used at Emory, and production will take a long time. I can’t help but think, how convenient? As it continues spreading, governments’ responses to Ebola have reminded me of how this world works. First off, when it comes to supporting each other African governments seem to be lagging behind. The western governments that always happen to be the first responders never do so without some sort of ulterior motives. And last but not least, it still looks like racism lives today. More than 3000 Africans have passed away because of the epidemic, what seems to be getting more attention is the infection of the westerners. And, whether it’s coincidental or not, the only black person to have been infected by Ebola and treated in the US, passed away. Ebola is just one of the problems we’re facing today, but there are real underlying problems that we refuse to deal with. Ed.’s Note: Leyou Tameru is a graduate of Georgetown and Addis Ababa University Law schools, specializing in International Legal Studies. Born and raised in Addis Ababa, she seeks to understand the impact of economic, political and social issues on everyday lives. She can be reached at bitsandpieces@ethiopianreporter.com CONT`D FROM PAGE 1 The Nile Basin includes 11 countries that either use or are the source of much of the river’s water. Eritrea has never been a member of NBI. to the organization for she sees no option other than cooperating. “Those who don’t cooperate will only be on the victim’s side,” he stressed. He also assured that “Sudan will cooperate forever with and fully be committed to the NBI.” The Minister openly called upon Egypt to learn from Sudan and renew its membership. Musa told The Reporterr there is no reason for member states to be kept outside of NBI, which he assured is the only neutral and independent regional institution working on the Nile. The water ministers of member states supported this position in their concluding declarations, which were read before the participants of the meeting. Keynote addresses were given by ministerial level officials from Tanzania, Sudan, and by the World Bank. In her opening speech, Professor Judi W. Wakhungu, Cabinet Secretary-Ministry of Environment, Water, and Natural Resources of Kenya told participants: “We are hoping that cooperation around the Nile is going to increase security and stability.” She said the NBI had advanced a cooperative process to realize tangible benefits, build trust and confidence among its members. Mutaz Musa said investment preparation leveraged under the NBI currently stood at USD 6.5 billion. Out of which projects with total investment of 3bn$ have been implemented so far. He told the Forum that the NBI was at a critical juncture with resources declining with the closure of the World Bank-sponsored program (Nile Basin Trust Fund) in December. The Minister appealed to member states to honor their obligations to the NBI, and to development partners to continue their support to enable effective implementation of its programs. Talking about CFA, which has been signed by six of ten member states, despite its full commitment to cooperation, he said Sudan has not yet decided to Ethiopia loses... According to Tewodros, due to the country’s failure to process and export the gemstones it is losing jobs to India, China and other countries. He said that due attention is not given to the gemstone production and export sector. “The sector should be recognized and supported by the government. It should be administered under the Ministry of Industry as it is a manufacturing work. A committee should be established that would undertake a study on the potential of the sector and how it can be supported. The members could be drawn from the Ministry of Mines, the Ministry of Trade, the Ministry of Industry, the Ethiopian Revenues and Customs Authority and the Ministry of Culture and Tourism. A gemstone cutting and polishing industry should be established. The government should recognize it as a new industry and provide the required support to the industry,” he said. Tewodros said that the sector should be given protection and support, financing and industry zone. Nature has endowed Ethiopia with more than 20 precious stones. Ethiopia exports mainly opal to India, Europe and the US. Ethiopian opal is now dominating the international market. Previously, Australia was known for high grade opal. Now it seems that Ethiopian opal is more popular than the Australian opal. There are four types of opal found in Ethiopia. Most of the opal is coming from North Wello, Amhara Regional State. Tamrat Modjo, artisanal mining and transaction coordinating director with the Ministry of Mines, said that the sector was not ignored. Tamrat said the Ministry of Mines was closely working with gemstone producers in different regions. “We are providing support to the artisanal miners and www.thereporterethiopia.com sign the framework agreements. He, however noted his country is ready for re-negotiation over the conflicting issues included within the agreement. Commenting on the GERD, which was also one of the few topics that had attracted high attention of the participants, he expressed his positive outlook towards it by saying “provided that all necessary conditions are met, we should not see it from a negative side. The dam is extremely important to all of us and to the region as a whole.” He appreciates the current move by the three countries, Ethiopia, Sudan and Egypt, to reach a common agreement on how to implement the recommendations of the IPoE on the Renaissance Dam. The NBI Forum was accompanied by partners at a round table discussion on Wednesday (October 8) seeking to mobilize resources for the implementation of NBI-initiated projects. The forum, held under the theme “Building Sustainable Trans-boundary Cooperation in a Complex River Basin: Challenges, Lessons and Prospects,” brought together over 500 participants from across the world. Water experts, diplomats, researchers, high officials and media personnel attended the Forum. Several papers were presented and discussed among the participants. The Nile Basin includes 11 countries that either use or are the source of much of the river’s water. Eritrea has never been a member of NBI. They are Burundi, Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC,) Egypt, Ethiopia, Kenya, Rwanda, South Sudan, Sudan, Tanzania, and Uganda. Eritrea participates as an observer. The Nile Basin Initiative was created in 1999 to start negotiations for a treaty that would lead to an “all-inclusive” use of the river. The Comprehensive Framework Agreement was signed in 2010. It has been ratified by Ethiopia and Rwanda. Kenya says it will do so before the end of the year. CONT`D FROM PAGE 1 gemstone manufacturers. Three years ago we imposed a ban on rough gemstone exports. There are no adequate gemstone processors in the country. So the artisanal miners were unable to sell their rough gemstones. This caused serious social and economic problems. More than 50,000 artisanal miners especially in the North Wello region faced a serious financial problem. Then we were forced to lift the ban. Now we are trying to bring in foreign investors who can engage in processing gemstones here in Ethiopia,” Tamrat said. He added that the ministry was looking at the opportunity that artisanal miners could acquire mining equipment through lease finance scheme. According to him, in the 2013-2014 fiscal year the country exported 25,000 kg of gemstones valued at 16 million dollars. An expert from the Ministry of Mines said that there were no trained professionals in the sector. “We do not have gemology education in the country. We do not have a gemology laboratory. The government should give due attention to the sector like it does to the flower and manufacturing industries,” the expert said. The Ethiopian artisanal mining industry employs more than one million people. The major types of gemstones found in Ethiopia include garnets, emeralds, rubies, and opals. Opal accounts for nearly 98 percent of the precious stone exports of the country. According to the World Bank, the artisanal and small-scale mining sector’s size and characteristics is poorly understood. Border dispute with mining companies, poor safety awareness and impacts on the environment were some of the concerns in the artisanal mining sector. Vol. XIX No. 944 |35 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Presidential address... In his opening address, Mulatu was bold in describing the construction of the major infrastructure in the energy sector, particularly the progress of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD). He said that the project was proceeding as planned and was 40 percent accomplished. Similarly, his address to the nation also highlighted that the construction of Gilgel Gibe III, Genale Dawa and other power projects such as wind and geothermal energy sources were proceeding on time according to plan. In his address the president offered an apology publicly about the power interruption that is taking place across the nation, which has been one of the chronic challenges. “Allow me here, to express an apology for the interruption of electric power,” the president said, adding that it was an institutional inefficient management of the Ethiopian Electric Service. “… [the power interruption is] caused in part by maladministration in the institution, due to pressure arising from increased demand in major cities in connection with rapid industrialization, change in urban way of life, as well as malfunction of power transmitting lines,” the president said. The state-owned power company has CONT`D FROM PAGE 3 been under strong criticism and is accused of causing public discontent for frequent power interruptions in the previous years. In particular, some companies engaged in the manufacturing sectors were complaining that they were forced to undertake their production with low capacity due to the instability and shortage of power. Similarly, the Ministry of Industry has also reported that the power shortage and interruption had negatively affected the country’s export performance last year. The other issue addressed in the president’s speech was one of security which particularly singled out the terrorism attempts by the groups which the parliament had designated as terrorist groups such as the Oromo Liberation Front (OLF), the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) and Ginbot 7. “To move to a slightly different register, there is a pressing need to deepen religious tolerance in the public sphere. In the same vein, the government and the public have to work in concert to prevent unlawful acts and terrorism. This should serve notice to terrorist outfits like OLF, ONLF and Ginbot 7,” the president warned. Most importantly the president extended an over-toned warning to the neighboring arch-foe Eritrea to stop its provocative move against Ethiopia. “I need not remind anyone that the Ethiopian government will take a proportional measure against any provocation by the Shabia government of Asmara”, Mulatu said. In connection with the upcoming national elections scheduled to be held next year in May, the president called upon all participants of the election to play “responsibly” so as to make it fair, free and credible. In addition, he also stressed that the media had a big role to play in creating national consensus on the national issues. “In this connection one cannot overstress the indispensable function of the media in fighting extremism, public disorder and in raising the awareness of harmony and mutual respect. This year, since our digitalization process would have reached a decisive stage, it would help our effort to pluralize the media landscape and increase the existing number of alternative sources of information to the public,” the president said. However, the president did not comment on the growing criticism against the government for its alleged repression of free press nor did he say anything about the arrest of journalists, bloggers and member of opposition groups. Agency criticizes... also mention that their certification is for their quality management but not necessarily for their product.” In this regard, she also said that to clear this confusion and misunderstanding the agency is working closely with the Ethiopian Broadcasting Authority and other related governmental organizations. By the same token, Legesse Gebre, Standard Director, Ethiopian Standard Agency told The Reporter, “Those companies who are working against the procedure should get back in line quickly because their activity is illegal, and if they seek any advice in this regard the agency is willing to guide them.” According to the officials, to create awareness and to uplift the issue of standard in the society the agency has done a lot. “The agency has provided training for media practitioners, owners and professionals of advertisement companies in relation to standards and issues related to ISO 9001, but nobody cares,” the director said. He further told The Reporter, “ISO is a certification that is issued mainly for the CONT`D FROM PAGE 3 quality management system not for the product that the company produces.” He also criticized both the advertisers and the companies, “posting the ISO logo on a certain product is also an illegal activity,” he said. The agency also organized a half-day workshop in the presence of members of the parliament standing committee of science, information and technology and various stakeholders in relation to the celebration of International Day of Standards, which will be celebrated the coming Tuesday under the theme “Standards Level the Playing Field,” which will be celebrated internationally for the 45th and locally for the 18th time. The Agency is a governmental agency accountable to the Ministry of Science and Technology, and has a National Standardization Council that works together with the Agency. The members of the council are drawn from appropriate governmental and other bodies and designated by the government. Ethiopian Standard Body has undergone several structural and name changes since its birth back in 1970, and the agency was established as per the latest restructuring, by the Council of Minister Regulation No. 193/2010, which caused the splitting of former Quality and Standards Authority of Ethiopia (QSAE) into four including the new National Standards Body (NSB) – Ethiopian Standards Agency (ESA), Ethiopian Conformity Assessment Enterprise, Ethiopian Metrology Institute and Ethiopian Accreditation office. In Ethiopia, the need for standardization became evident during the early 1950s as it was noticed that the export of agricultural commodities was being affected due to a lack of the support of standardization. Following the emergence of Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia as a modern city, it was also noticed that there is an urgent need for standardization of buildings, electrical appliances and water supplies, especially in the new University campusAddis Ababa University, faculty of science. These were among the problems worth monitoring and that have led the way through to creating a national standardization body, which happened in 1972. Tullow moves... Nick said Tullow Oil will provide all the petroleum data it collected from South Omo and Chew Bahir to the Ethiopian Ministry of Mines Petroleum Licensing and Administration Directorate. “We have done by far more than our commitments. So we are not going to do extra work in the coming two years until the exploration agreement expires.” Experts of Tullow Oil are now CONT`D FROM PAGE 4 recalibrating the basin based on the data collected from the wells. “There is evidence of source rocks in the wells. That is not to mean that they do not exist in the kitchen,” Nick said. “We could not find the source rock.” However, he said, the subsurface data required from wells was obtained. According to him, the worldwide statistics of success rate ratio in drilling wild cat exploration wells is one out of 11. “Unfortunately, our wells were some of the ten failures.” Nick said the company is leaving behind the infrastructure it built in South Omo. “We are leaving behind the roads and bridges we built and the local persons we trained.” Tullow oil spent 250 million dollars on the South Omo oil exploration project. www.thereporterethiopia.com Ethiopia welcomes... CONT`D FROM PAGE 3 of foreign affairs and international cooperation, Bernard Membe, told his country’s parliament in June this year that his nation would push for the renegotiation of the CFA in favour of Egypt. However, days later the country’s water minister, Jumanne Maghembe (Prof.), dismissed the foreign minister’s statement saying that Tanzania remains committed to the treaty. Ethiopia became the first country to ratify the treaty in June 2013 when the House of Peoples’ Representatives unanimously voted to make the CFA part of the law of the land. The ratification was dubbed by parliamentarians as “an important step towards the realization of an equitable utilization of the Nile waters.” Rwanda is the other basin country which ratified the treaty out of the six signatories of the CFA which also included Kenya, Uganda and Burundi. These countries are reportedly on advanced stages of ratifying the protocol. Similar to the recent move made by the Tanzanian cabinet, the Kenyan government is also set to ratify the CFA before the end of the year. Egypt, Sudan and the Democratic Republic of Congo have not signed the CFA, also known as the Entebbe Agreement, while the now war-torn South Sudan had expressed its keenness to accede to the treaty. Upon ratification by the respective parliaments of all the six signatories, the CFA will serve as the only legally binding document governing the Nile river. It replaces colonial-era treaties of 1929 and 1959, which Ethiopia has never recognized, and strips Egypt of veto rights over water projects in upstream countries. eLearning conference... CONT`D FROM PAGE 4 “It has created a new understanding of what Africans can achieve and a belief that, working together, sharing our knowledge, making the most of the great opportunity that education and technology offer us, we will change the world,” the statement added. “I am delighted to be able to tell you that after 10 years ‘on the road’ around Africa –in Kenya, Ghana, Zambia, Tanzania, Senegal, Benin, Namibia and Uganda – we are returning to Ethiopia.” Stromeyer also launched an international ‘Call for Proposals’ for the conference, which offers an opportunity to anyone working in education, development and technology to showcase their outstanding projects and sustainable initiatives. It was also understood that eLearning Africa invites potential speakers from across the continent and the world to submit their ideas, innovations and research, under the main theme of “Enriching Tomorrow.” eLearning Africa 2015 is expected to address topics including innovative funding strategies, citizen empowerment, ICT4E in critical industries and open knowledge as well as to highlight the very best of African innovation. 36| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Israeli Knesset... CONT`D FROM PAGE 7 that reject the existence of the State of Israel as the state of the Jewish People, its democratic nature, or that incite racism may not participate in the elections. Within the framework of the Israeli democratic system, in which there is a separation of powers amongst the legislature, the executive branch, and the judiciary, the Knesset is the legislative branch, with the exclusive authority to enact laws. The Knesset may pass laws on any subject and in any matter, as long as a proposed law does not contradict an existing basic law, and the legislative process is carried out as required by the law. Legislation constitutes an important part of the Knesset’s work. In addition, the Knesset supervises the work of the Government through its committees and the work of the plenum. The Knesset has several quasi-judicial functions, which include the power to lift the immunity of its members, and the power to have the President of the State and State Comptroller (an official who oversees and inspects the executive branch of Israel’s governing administration) removed. The Knesset also has an elective function through which several public officials are elected. Nigusu Lemma, Secretary General of Ethiopian Parliament office, on his part briefed the Israeli delegation about Ethiopia’s government system on the foundation of the constitution enacted in 1995. Similarly, Shirley Avromi, Director of Research and Information Center at the Israelis parliament office has presented the institutional system and implementation mechanism that the research and information department assists the Knesset during legislation process and formulation. Ethiopian to commence... CONT`D FROM PAGE 7 commitment to our customers to provide them the best possible travel experience and connectivity options. Our flights to Dublin and Los Angeles will be operated with the B787 Dreamliner, which offers unmatched on-board comfort especially for such a very long haul route with its unique features such as greatly reduced noise, higher cabin air humidity, biggest windows in the sky and spacious cabin interior.” Tewolde said. With the addition of Dublin, the airline’s 11th European city and Los Angeles, its 4th point in the Americas, Ethiopian international network will cover 85 destinations across 5 continents. Ethiopian is a Pan-African global carrier voted by passengers as the Best in Africa for two years in a row by Passenger Choice Awards, the most comprehensive survey in the industry. The airline operates the youngest fleet in the continent with an average of less than 7 years and currently serves 83 international destinations across 5 continents with over 200 daily departures. Hospitality... expertise and consultant. Involvement of experts in the hotel business means more global brands and faces becoming interested in the industry. According to a recent study made by the research officers of Awash International Bank, published in the journal of business management, there is a surge in demand for a single night rooms service. In 2011 alone, the demand for rooms for a single night was a little over two million while the number of travelers was at half a million or so. Projections of the researcher suggests that by 2015, some three million guests will have to be accommodated for single night. However, the existing number of hotels annual capacity remains to be 1.7 million or so. Hence, unsatisfied demand of 1.25 million will still haunt the hospitality market in Ethiopia. The supply gap at this point gave property owners and the government to look for external big players. These brand operating companies actually do not come easy. They want to be more than sure that they can make money. But, they do have many requirements the country needs to address first. Making available properties which suit the standards are what they want to associate themselves with. Failure to host international brands means nothing but lesser travelers coming in to country. But Neway says at this point in time, the government is seriously considering the hospitality business. He justifies this by referring to the recent establishment of the tourism transformation council, chaired by Prime Minister Hailemariam Desalegn. With the absence of internationally branded hotels, it was daring for the government to set such a high target as three billion dollars by the end of 2015 form the tourism sector. During the same period, the number of travelers coming to Ethiopia is assumed to reach one million. However, the existing figures show that Ethiopia has landed close to 600 thousand visitors so far. Yet, the amount of hard currency secured was not far from USD 400 million. One reasons for such poor performance is the lack of tourist standard destinations and lack of hotels which meet the expectations of the visitors. The average stay is less than five days. On the other hand, the business travelers and conference attendees are increasingly frequenting the capital. Hence, Neway argues that star rating or grading is not an issue at this time. Rather, safety, hygiene and sanitation are the basics requiring consistent maintenance in the hospitality industry. To fulfill that, spatial limitations are battling the sector. Neway pointed out that lack of sufficient land made some global brand operators to withdraw deals. Lack of awareness of authorities about star rated hotels is also contributing to the matter. Days ago, the capital hosted the Africa Hotel Investment Forum (AHIF), an recognized event, internationally organized by the London-based Bench Events. During the three day event, local speakers and panelists have raised the challenges of hospitable infrastructure and land acquisitions. Some property owners made their point that the government was not availing finances to the sector. According to the research, the hospitality industry was able to access some 1.4 billion birr credit from the local banks in 2011. By contrast, the outstanding loan including the central bank’s deficit financing, grossed some 78 billion birr in the year in question. For instance, 7.3 billion birr was allocated for domestic trade. For agriculture 10.6 billion, for industry 20.6, for international trade 18 billion birr was provided. Government deficit financing amassed some 3.7 billion birr. The research team also noted that the hotel and tourism sector had been receiving an insignificant amount of finances. But for Neway, the absence of finance did not deter investors from taking part. Some 37 hotels had been given the green light and were licensed to go for developing the start rated hotels in the country. It is to be recalled that during the event, six international brand operators have inked deals to fetch six more brand EHRC, Irish... three years but has some finanical constraints and this support will enable the commission to work on the area further, he further stated that so far some 40 to 50 thousand vulnerable people have benefited from the program that the commission has undertaken with Ethiopian Women’s Lawyers Association (EWLA). The Irish ambassador further told The Reporter that “the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission, who has already working with EWLA will administer the money to work with eight universities in different regions.” Eight universities selected for the program are from four regions, Mekele and Axum Universities from the Tigray Regional State, Bahir Dar and Gondar Universities from the Amhara Regional State, Wolaita Sodo and Dilla Universities from Southern Nations, Nationalities and Peoples’ Regional State and Adama and Jimma universities from the Oromia Regional States. Through this scheme, “the commission through EWLA, professors of the law schools and students of these selected universities will provide free legal advice to vulnerable people with a certain emphasis on women,” Aidan CONT`D FROM PAGE 6 CONT`D FROM PAGE 5 added. Ethiopian and Irish relations are based on wide ranging issues of mutual interest. The most visible people-topeople interactions were during the height of the 1984 famine when so many Ethiopians died and which caused the country so many problems. Ireland’s response to that catastrophe still remains a vivid and warming memory. Most notable among the humanitarian efforts of the Irish people was, of course, the work of the Irish rock star, Sir Bob Geldof, whose initiative in organizing the Band Aid program mobilized the international community to provide the support that enabled the survival of millions of Ethiopians affected by the calamity. Diplomatically, Ethiopia and Ireland have only a short history dating back to 1994 when Ireland opened its embassy in Addis Ababa. Bilateral relations have been cemented by the high level visits of the late Prime Minister Meles Zenawi to Ireland in 2002 and of Irish Foreign Minister, Michael Martin to Ethiopia last year. Ethiopia’s decision to open its Embassy in Dublin in 2003 was another important milestone in further strengthening diplomatic relations. www.thereporterethiopia.com hotels in the capital. Yet, it will take one to three years for the brand hotels to materialize. However, the number of travelers coming to the country shows an increasing trend ensuring the domestic hospitality industry that there the pie is enough for everybody, Neway argues. The coming of brand hotels poses again a question of manpower availability. Individuals trained and tailored for the hospitality business are very scarce and the existing hotels scuffles one another to retain those. The inadequate supply is at the cross roads. Probably, two universities are currently producing graduates in the field of tourism and hospitality management. Short term trainings provided by institutes are set by the government. After all, as the big players of the industry say, it has been a journey of discovery coming here and seeking for opportunities. The country has been starting from the ground zero they say. For sure, the hospitality industry appears to one sector which can no be ignored both in job creation and hard currency generation. Yet, it is not in the lists of prioritized sectors as Esayas Bahre, president of the Development Bank of Ethiopia, confirms to The Reporter. The future, however, seems to be brighter at least on account of Prime Minister Hailemariam’s promise to support the sector. He called on big faces of the global businesses to come and invest. He promised his government will provide every requisite the brand operators are looking at. To the likes of Neway, it’s not a mere promise. He ascertains himself to that when he said he has learnt the PM was busy while meeting the executives of the upper ladder of the global hotel business. Why now? And why the international brands are coming to get the business going? No one gives precise and direct answers. The operators say that they cannot remain idle watching the country while there are many things going on. Ed.’s Note: Wudineh Zenebe of The Reporter has contributed to this story. AWiB to honor... CONT`D FROM PAGE 7 of the Young Women’s Christian Association, Tadelech Hailemikael, former Minister of the Ministry of Women’s Affairs and Ambassador, Founder and Director of the Women’s Development Fund, Tirhas Mezgebe, Founder and CEO of Mujujegwa Loka Women’s Development, and Zemi Yenus, Founder and Director of the NIA Foundation. According to the president of the association, presenting the nominees were conducted through various mass media, social media and via the website of the association. The winner of this title will receive a prize of one hundred thousand birr, and to cover such and other expenses, the association is partnering with various partners such as banks like the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia (CBE) and Dashen Bank. This year’s celebration will be the third of its kind and the opening speech will be delivered by the renowned Dr. Catherine Hamlin. Tsigie Haile, Founder and Director of WISE, and Sara Mohamed, Founder and Managing Director of Next Design and Modeling School, were the first and second award winners, respectively. AWiB is a women’s association committed to the development of women as well as the recognition of inspirational female Ethiopian leaders and their important contributions to the community. The association has been operational since April, 2010. LEISURE The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Vol. XIX No. 944 |37 Crossword ACROSS 1. Not rights 6. Bristle-like appendages of many grasses 10. People of eastern Europe 14. Not together 15. Indonesian for “Left” 16. Rip 17. Parson 18. Received (contraction) 19. Whale 20. Instigator 22. Saw 24. Bearing 25. Concerns 26. Ermine (plural) 29. German for “Mister” news reporting 31. Hampering 37. Sharp ride in molding 39. Lennon’s widow 40. Spruce 41. City in Alabama 44. Tailess amphibian 45. Norse god 46. Blots or debases 48. Plant body undifferentiated into stem, root or leaf 52. Musical piece 53. Works on something again 54. Infernal 58. Assistant 59. Egyptian goddess 61. Skylighted central areas 62. Mid-month days 63. Religious sisters 64. Fewest or smallest 65. Tops 66. Black and white 67. Model rocket company Down 1. Molten rock 2. Heroic narrative 3. Indisputably true 4. Harmful 5. Large channel of water 6. City in Ohio 7. Dam in a river 8. National Research Council 9. Pistol 10. Dutch for "Stop" 11. Weird 12. Stock car driver 13. Nails 21. Exam 23. _____ throat 25. Notes 26. Slap 27. Through 28. Paddles 29. City in Viet Nam 32. Chess pieces 33. Sues 34. Symbol 35. Tidy 36. Roves 38. French for "Room" 42. Flubbing 43. "Smallest" particle 47. Annual 48. Pathway 49. Children's story by Johanna Spyri 50. Supplemented 51. Accumulation of clay and silt 52. Spunky 54. Airborne electronic countermeasures 55. Pest 56. Short form of "Elizabeth" 57. Consumes 60. French for "On" US Box office Hey guys what are you doing? Kuncho Komments What type of game is it? That’s a weird game. What is it called? We are playing a game. It’s quiet easy. Both of us will place an air filled balloon in a box and open it and the one that floats the highest and can’t be reached is the loser. Your Zodiacs KUNCHO: Our dads’ salaries and how quickly it flies away. 1 Gone Girl 2 Annabelle 3 The Equalizer 4 The Boxtrolls 5 The Maze Runner 6 7 This Is Where I Leave You 8 Dolphin Tale 2 9 10 (astrology-online.com) ARIES (Mar. 21- April 20) CANCER (June 22-July 22) LIBRA (Sept. 24 -Oct. 23) ?"@%$?D%*'++;H+K= This is a week when you are very busy with your own affairs. Toward the end of the week you have a nice surprise for everyone. Unexpected changes that occur this week should improve your surroundings. Support comes when you need it. This week allows for conversations that tax your spiritual nature, give into your higher self when making decisions that count. This week lucky numbers are: 92, 41, 50, 17, 4 Some decisions that were made in secret meetings are being postponed for a couple of weeks while details are worked out. It’s time to take a break. You are likely to feel valued and appreciated as partners show the good feelings they have for you in splendid ways where the entertainment and sense of mutual well being is at a high, thanks to no expense being spared, even if you start incurring a lot of costs you will still feel it is all worth it. This week lucky numbers are: 89, 51, 26, 13, 83 This week you have nine out of the ten planets all in an excellent aspect to your sign. While things won’t be quite earthy balance. On Friday, the Moon enters Gemini and your energy is soaring again, just in time for the New Moon that night. This is the time to make a fresh start. Enjoy and make the most of the opportunity. This week lucky numbers are: 33, 53, 64, 9, 28 This is a time when you are handling bits and pieces of everything with nothing large or important going on around you. Taking care of old business and cleaning up this and that keeps you busy. It is a nice time for planning for or taking a vacation. A loved one is feeling somewhat neglected lately, show them that you really > start an exercise routine, try running or cycling. Here is a word of caution, beware what you wish for it just might happen. This week lucky numbers are: 93, 96, 68, 11, 29 TAURUS (Apr. 21- may 21) SCORPIO (Oct. 24 - Nov. 22) LEO (July 23-Aug 22) Your social instincts are in top gear as you search out any gatherings of people and magically get to hear of social occasions where the sense of good cheer is to be found, although you know there are serious matters lurking round the immediate future where good luck and lady fortune are in attendance. This week lucky numbers are: 88, 24, 77, 21, 95 something nice for yourself to lift your spirits. You are in the to launch a new phase. The week is once again taken over by many activities on a day to day level, oh well, at least you are energised. The moon is in opposition to your sun, let partners make the decisions in order to keep the peace. Comments have week lucky numbers are: 23, 44, 62, 17, 38 GEMINI (May 22-June 21) VIRGO (Aug. 23 -Sept. 23) !"#$"%$&!'*+/;+<= A vacation or a trip over water is on your mind now. You would do well dealing with boats or ships. Get out and mingle on Monday or if involved go for romantic atmosphere to make the difference. Partnership endeavors are possible this week, allow others to take the lead, fellow employees are key. You have a nice surprise by the end of the week. This week lucky numbers are: 47, 12, 79, 40, 82 You are just as happy to have some work put off this week until someone else solves a major problem for you. Finding that appliance or furniture you have been looking for might prove to be a problem this week, and maybe it be better put off until next week. Take time to show your spouse a little extra love this week as they have been doing a lot for you and deserve a little extra appreciation. This week lucky numbers are: 70, 35, 48, 62, 87 Money should be loosening up for you now and you have some choices to make this week. You have started to feel situation, old problems seem to have cleared so that you can see the way ahead more clearly, there is much in the world of nature and in your own local area and home that is a source of inspiration and comfort to you as you observe life in all its profusion. This week lucky numbers are: 10, 75, 13, 28, 81 This week is very lucky for you so get busy and straighten out all your affairs. Your personal magnetism and charm are adding to your aura now and make dating easy.---- Like Capricorn > ; conjunction between your ruler, Jupiter, lord of the far horizon and Saturn, ruler of restrictions. Quite possibly, the solution to your > Perhaps you should alter it instead of abandoning it. This week lucky numbers are: 16, 57, 46, 29, 86 SPOT THE DIFFERENCES Can you spot the 12 differences between the two pictures? www.thereporterethiopia.com Solution AQUARIUS (Jan. 21 -Feb. 19) > You seem to be on the right track. It’s time to put your efforts into your own goals for a change. Monday is good for artistic pursuits or just taking care of yourself, be lazy. New moon focus is on work projects that need your intense focus, you know how to make progress. The work week includes those from far away places who are or become your friends, open up with others. Thursday working alone is important. This week lucky numbers are: 41, 27, 95, 34, 78 PISCES (Feb. 20-Mar. 20) resources and to build up a savings account. Whatever you decide to do this week turns out well even though it requires a great deal of your time. Your imagination is working very well now and you could come up with something quite original and yet practical at the same time. The little thoughtful things you do can make a difference. You will get recognition on Tuesday and Wednesday for a job well done. This week lucky numbers are: 42, 97, 40, 9, 60 Solution 38| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 IMF vs. Government... night watchman style government at its helm. Countries like Ethiopia and its leaders argued for a strong state role in shaping its growth path. And, both had their own support base in the global scene. Local spectators on their part look to be growing into this friction and these days it is taken quite seriously. This year, it is debt. It is about sustaining the external debt level. And the role of the State-owned Enterprises (SoE) in piling up the debt levels was of a special focus. As a matter of fact, the two have not seen eye to eye regarding the state activities in the market. It is one of those ideological issues for them. To be fair, the debate have devolved so much through time and now, all the friction is happing around certain specific subjects. And one topic that is climbing fast to importance is the matter of the SoEs. The state on its part is firm on these enterprises being considered as fully autonomous entities, and whatever decision they make, it did not want it to be mixed with a regulatory decision. As can be imagined, the position of the government regarding the issue of external debt contracted by the SoEs is reflective of this approach. Meanwhile, it is highly unsettling for the Fund to exclude the books of the SoEs when dealing with external public debt of the country. What appeared as an observation a couple of years ago has now grown in importance to become the most contentious matter in the consultation process. The Fund is of the view that each and every bit of the activity of the SoEs should be taken as the activity of the general government. This means every bit of spending decision made on the SoEs would have macroeconomic impact almost as equal as the decision of the general government. To some extent, the Fund argued for the inclusion of the SoEs books to the budget schedule of the general government. This incorporates the revenue, expenditure and debt (a point of focus now) figures of these SoEs. It is for the sake of better management in the fiscal department, IMF says. But, authorities of the Ethiopian government greatly differ with this assessment and refuse to heed such advice. financial resources. Here is where things start to get more complicated. Since both are important part of GTP, finding financing is priority to authorities. So now, both central government programs and projects and those offbudget programs mainly carried out by SoEs is accessing financing from both domestic and external markets. But, although for all practical purposes SoEs are part of the state, their cumulative financial position, debt in particular, is not scrutinized as those of other state agencies. This bothered the IMF for years. But, now the concern looks to be more serious in a sense that the IMF is indicating a potential risk from debt contracted by these SoEs. According to the report, the stock of external debt climbed to USD 12.2 billion in the first half of 2013/14 from 11.2 just few months ago. In this, the Fund accuses the SoEs basically utility and other big companies. It further says that the state has to check heavy borrowing by the SoEs for sake of sustainable debt stock. A macro-economist, who spoke to The Reporter under the condition of anonymity, backs the Funds position that SoEs’ risky borrowing is putting overall debt level at a dangerous threshold. He even goes further in saying SoEs borrowing is progressing in such a way that it is making the overall debt stock to be unsustainable. According to the report, borrowing of SoEs has reached 10 percent of the GDP thereby raising the public and publicly CONT`D FROM PAGE 6 guaranteed debt stock of the nation to 23 percent of the GDP. The authorities disagree. In fact, they did so even in the report that Fund made public. For the government, the borrowing of the SoEs is driven by the commercial consideration as corporations and if they access any external finance it should be because the financiers have believed that the projects on the table would be able to repay the loan extended to them within the specified data of maturity. Individually, the Fund hails Ethiopian Airlines and states that it could manage debt it contracts from the market. In fact, Ethiopian is one of SoEs in Ethiopia which do not require treasury’s guarantee to access finances. But, large SoEs like Ethio Telecom and the power company do have their own risk, it says. With large telecom services purchase in recent years, Ethio Telecom was mostly featured in the report as the face of SoE group. The authorities are not also inclined to accept the so-called future potential risk of the building-up debt today. By extension, the overall debt level is considered to be not a risky one, it maintained. Here, one issue that begs explanation is how big and real this risk of borrowing of SoEs is. Luckily, the article four consultation contains a debt statistic analysis annex that shows the details of the debt level and its potential risk in the future. The Debt Stainability Analysis (DSA) was conducted on the basis of the three different debt sustainability indicators: Debt to Export, Debt to Advertisment GDP and Debt to Revenue. And of course, various scenarios of flow of debt and macro and external economic conditions were assumed to see future trajectory and potential risk. Various shock scenarios were also assumed and simulated to tell the story. Currently, the country’s external debt stress level remain to be LOW at best. And projection of the various scenarios of external debt levels for the period 2012/13 to 2033/34 and calculation of the three various indicators as well do not seem to be that risky. To beginning under all the indicators, the country would not face the feasibility of becoming a moderately stress by external debt. The threshold of ratio of debt to export, GDP and revenue are 150 percent, 40 percent and 250 percent respectively. In that, it was only in the debt to export ratio (141 percent) that Ethiopia comes close to or becomes a borderline case to cross the moderately stressed threshold (150 percent). And that was projected for 2016 and 2017 right in the middle of GTP II. Currently, debt to export ration is around 115.0 percent well in low stress category. The Fund’s analysis simulated various shock scenarios and in all of them finding a risk of becoming a borderline case to cross the moderately stressed threshold at best. However remote, the risk still exists and the recommended caution on borrowing is valid from all angle. Such debate as well come at the period where the treasury was getting ready to float sovereign bonds in the international money market. This too is another dimension to the debt structure. The macro-economist quoted earlier thinks that this should be more reason for consolidating the debt structure and even the fiscal stance of the country by including the SoEs. “It is important for fiscal management in face entering sovereign bond market,” he argued. The bond market will surely open up the economy for exchange rate and fiscal risk, he explains, and this is the time to consider consolidating. The Fund’s concern as well is about the possible impact of SoEs for the overall macroeconomy. And, argues for consolidating SoEs’ finances with general government to clearly see and respond to the impact of these entities. To put this into context, the Fund is not exactly a fan of what government is doing with SoEs. In fact, not even with existence of such institutions in favor of further liberalization and limiting the participation of the state in the market. One of the highlight of the Article IV consultation is hence the issue of consolidating the fiscal side of the public sector. At least, the debt statistic. The Fund recommended all government debt most importantly that of the debt of the SoEs be put in the same basket if one is to talk about the overall debt burden that the country can and is carrying at the moment. The rationale behind this is a perceived debt risk that Ethiopia faces at this time. The report out of the consultation anchored on this issue this year. It is mostly about external debt. But, another economist Girma Abebe [named changed because he is not at liberty to comment] feels that such debate is a waste of time at best. He says, the only thing that matters is not agreeing on an accounting methodology rather making sure that the SoEs can repay their debts in a timely manner. Whether in the same books or separate, the level of debt that SoEs are accessing first needs to be in line with their servicing capacity. “In this regard, the likes of the Ethiopian and Ethio Telecom do have a sustainable income stream to suggest they can probably carry the level of debt at their rosters,” he says. However, for the rest of them, if there is a closely monitored debt contracting and debt servicing plan consolidation can not be a point of friction. Owing to the massive financing needs of the Growth and Transformation Plan (GTP), the resource gap greatly calls for huge alternative financing mechanism to realize it. And debt is almost the only instrument to make this happen. The Ethiopian authorities are not shy to deep into financiers’ coffers whether domestic or foreign. In fact, the availability of such credit facilities and favorable terms of borrowing is the main problem. The GTP, however, is a combination of both off-budget and formal budget programs requiring almost equivalent amount of As far as, plans are concerned, the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development (MoFED), have completed its Medium-term Debt Management Strategy in 2013 to guide the financing activities for the period up to 2017. In the document, MoFED admits that SoEs’ borrowing activities requires some sort of guidelines which it pledges to include in its next edition. “Had it not been for shortage of data and time constraints, it would have been good to include the SoEs in overall debt management strategy,” it said. www.thereporterethiopia.com Sport The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Vol. XIX No. 944 |39 Walias face crucial test against Mali Elsewhere in the competition, Cameroon will look to continue their powerful start in Group D. After a wretched World Cup in Brazil, the new-look Indomitable Lions have begun with wins against RD Congo and Côte d’Ivoire, and now face two matches in five days against Sierra Leone. By Mark Jenkin The Ethiopia national football team face a crucial Africa Cup of Nations double header against Mali this week. After hosting the Eagles at Addis Ababa stadium today (Saturday, 4pm), the return fixture for the Walias takes place in Mali’s Stade du 26 Mars in Bamako on Wednesday. The outbreak of the Ebola virus in their country is not the only factor causing disruption to the Sierra Leone players’ preparations. A bizarre row has broken out around the team after the Sierra Leone Football Association and the country’s sports ministry named two different coaches for the Cameroon fixtures. Having lost the opening two qualifiers against Algeria and Malawi last month, Ethiopia need positive results to have a realistic chance of reaching the 2015 tournament in Morocco. Mariano Barreto, the national team’s Portuguese coach who was appointed in April, is seeking to develop a younger side but results have so far been disappointing. Saladin Said scored a penalty in the 2-1 home defeat to Algeria in September but the inspirational striker has since suffered a calf injury while making his debut for Egyptian side Al Ahlly. Ethiopia were underdogs against Algeria, the top-ranked African team who performed admirably at the 2014 World Cup before bowing out after extra time to eventual champions Germany in the round of 16. More was expected, though, in the second qualifying fixture in Malawi where Atusaye Nyondo struck twice to give the home team a 3-2 win at the Kamuzu Stadium in Blantyre. Getaneh Kebede and Yussef Saleh were on target for Ethiopia. Mali, 59th in the FIFA world rankings, have Henryk Kasperczak, from Poland, in his second spell as coach having previously guided them to fourth place at the 2002 Afcon tournament. They are sure to provide a stern test to Ethiopia who have slipped to 132nd in the FIFA rankings following their slow start to the qualifiers. The Walias will need to be wary of the threat posed by French-born Mali forwards Nouha Dicko and Bakary Sako Athletics round-up By Mark Jenkin Legendary Ethiopian athlete Haile Gebreselassie was forced to pull out of the Great Scottish Run. The former Olympic champion ran only 19 minutes of the half-marathon in Glasgow, Scotland, last Sunday before being forced to withdraw due to breathing problems. men’s race, the Ethiopian women were also in great form on the fast and flat streets of the German capital. Tirfi Tsegaye was crowned champion in a time of 2-20-18 and her training partner Feyse Tadese came in second in 2-20-27, both recording personal bests. Haile, 41, was attempting to defend the title he won last year in a time of 61 minutes 9 seconds – a record for the 13.1mile distance in Scotland. With Tadelech Bekele fourth in 2-2305 and Abebech Afework fifth in 2-2502, Ethiopians claimed four of the top five places. Shalane Flanagan was the only athlete to break that dominance, securing third for the US in 2-21-14. Haile said on twitter: “Today in Glasgow again problems with my lungs; exercise enduced asthma. But I am still enjoying running so much.” Tirfi, 29, raced brilliantly to improve her best by more than a minute and record the fastest women’s time in the world this year. The race was won by South Africa’s Stephen Mokoka in 61-25 with Edna Kiplagat, of Kenya, taking the women’s title in 67-57. While Flanagan was leading at the halfway stage, the patience of Tirfi and 25-year-old Feyse were rewarded as they went to the front after 30 kilometers. Tirfi pulled clear to secure the best win of her distinguished career, adding to previous marathon titles earned in Paris, Dubai and Tokyo. There was victory in Scotland last month, however, for another Ethiopian athlete, Tomas Abyu, who won the Loch Ness Marathon in two hours 22 minutes 41 seconds. The 36-year-old, who has lived in England for 15 years, is originally from Arsi and has recently been back training in Ethiopia. Tomas represents Salford Harriers near Manchester and has previously won marathons throughout Great Britain in York, Liverpool, Jersey and Manchester. He recorded a personal best of 2-10-37 finishing second at the Dublin Marathon in Ireland in 2007. The pride of East African running was clear to see in an historic Berlin Marathon on September 28. While Dennis Kimetto, of Kenya, set a stunning world record of 2-02-57 in winning the The nation will hope for more racing glory tomorrow (Sunday, October 12) as Kenenisa Bekele is due to compete in the Chicago Marathon in the US. Having made his debut over the 26.2mile distance in Paris in April, one of Ethiopia’s greatest sports stars aims to continue his progression following a golden career in track and cross country. Kenenisa won the Paris race in 2-0503 and has stated he is targeting the Chicago course record of 2-03-45 set by Dennis Kimetto last year. Ed.’s Note: The writer is on an internship at The Reporter. who have both impressed in the English Championship with Wolverhampton Wanderers. Sako, a winger, has scored five goals for Wolves this season and is attracting interest from English Premier League clubs. Ethiopia are aiming to emulate their achievements from their previous Afcon campaign when, under the management of Sewenet Bishaw, they qualified for the 2013 tournament finals for the first time in more than 30 years. Algeria, who top Group B with two wins from two, play home and away games against Malawi this week. Following the sacking of Northern Irishman Johnny McKinstry, the ministry appointed former player Atto Mensah. However, the SLFA then claimed Mensah was not qualified and instead named John Ajina Sesay as head coach for the two games. Congo Brazzaville, who gained a surprise opening-day victory over champions Nigeria, lead Group A ahead of today’s meeting with South Africa. Burkina Faso, the 2013 runners-up, seek to maintain their winning record in Group C with a trip to Gabon while Group F leaders Cape Verde hope to protect their 100 percent record when they go to Mozambique. Ed.’s Note: The writer is on an internship at The Reporter. Advertisment IMMEDIATE IMMEDIAT ATE VACANCY VA Y Institutional Capacity acity Development Advisor Advisor V { J{X @ services of a consultant to support the programs of the Department 9 &!J9X area off Institutional Capacity apacity ty Development. Develo Developme pment nt.. Eligibility ility t crite ty criteria ria Suitable candidates must meet the following eligibility criteria for their application to be considered: x Be legally and operationally in a position to work in Ethiopia; x Hold a Master degree from a recognized university in a social x Have a minimum of 5 years of relevant experience working in the area of capacity development. Detailed Te Terms of Refere Reference fere fe ence with information on expected j - " j! for this consultancy can be found at www.cida-ecco.org g under the Vacancy page. Application Deadline: Deadline Deadli ne:: All applications must be received byy 12:30 12:30 on on Monday, onday, y, November November 3rd, 2014 as follows: a. By post or personally delivered to: ECCO, Ethiopia-Canada {J{X \%@ %$V $ 04, H. No. 161/01, P.O.Box 1009,Addis Ababa Ethiopia OR b. By e-mail at: info@cida-ecco.org @ g, Reference: Institutional Capacity Development Advisor Please note that only short-listed shorrt-listed rt applicants applicants will receive re eceive furt fur further rtherr rthe communication tion fro from rom m EC E ECCO. CO. O. www.thereporterethiopia.com 40| Vol. XIX No. 944 The Reporter | Saturday | October 11, 2014 Advertisment Design & Page Making Media & Communications Centre (MCC) Publisher Media & Communication Center (MCC) Printed d by Berhanena Selam Printing Enterprise Sub-city: Arada, Kebele: 17, H.No: 984
© Copyright 2024