Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning The word cloud above was produced using the text of this document. Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 1 Executive Overview The purpose of this document is to outline the goals, objectives, fundamental processes and approaches, and to provide a sufficient outline of planned events and actions regarding Boy Scouts of America internal communications required to meet the business goals of the organization. This plan must begin with review of and agreement on the fundamental aspects of internal communication and the communication planning process. With that in place, the process can be launched in 2009 to develop an early BSA Internal Communication Plan that can then be approved, budgeted, and implemented for 2010. This document provides an overview of the fundamental principles of internal communication, the communication process, and the planning process. The communication process is: Research • De?ining and documenting management decisions, goals, and objectives • De?ining needs both organizational needs and employee needs Planning • Message development (selecting the key themes) • Integrating communication plans into corporate and group strategic plans Implementation • Communicating the plan • Full implementation of all aspects of the plan Measurement • How has the planned communication in?luenced beliefs? • How has the communication in?luenced results? 2 An excellent example of implementing a comprehensive communication process is around organizational change. With the New BSA launch in August 2008, a great deal of effort was expended around communicating the change itself and the reasons behind that change. The BSA is now following up with an employee survey to determine how that change has been implemented and, hopefully, to determine employee beliefs and attitudes around that change and it’s impact on the organization and on themselves. We are essentially going through the three‐stage change curve outlined below. The vertical axis is morale, competence, and emotion. The horizontal axis is time with the three states within each stage shown: Stage 1, shock, numbness, denial; Stage 2, fear, anger, depression; and Stage 3, understanding, acceptance, and moving on. Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 Moving On Numbness Shock Acceptance Denial Fear Understanding Anger Depression With the information collected from the employee survey, we can better determine where the majority of employees are along the change curve above. Hopefully, they are moving into the understanding phase. If not, more work is needed to revise the messaging and the overall communication plan. Thus, we’ve outlined the communication process ‐‐‐ research (where are we now and where do we want to go), planning (setting up the rollout via the big offsite meeting, NLTC, etc.), implementation (conducting the roll out meeting, running Bob’s blog, meetings with employees), followed by measurement (the employee survey to determine the effectiveness of communication and the attitudes of employees). Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 3 The action steps are: Research • Agree on or revise the definitions highlighted within this plan (bold italics) • Agree on or revise the processes that are outlined in this plan • Conduct the Research and Audit Phases • Document management decisions as the basis of the communication plan • Survey industry practices to benchmark BSA operations Planning • Establish and adjust communication goals • Develop action plans that will determine funding and staffing requirements Implementation • Begin implementation in late 2009 and early 2010 • Efforts will be adjusted based on funding and staffing available Measure • Conduct employee surveys on a periodic basis (sampling each quarter) • Adjust plans in light of results 4 Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning The purpose of this document is to outline the fundamental processes and approaches to building a BSA Internal Communication Plan. It will also begin to address the benefits of a concerted planning process, implementation according to that plan, and consistent measurements of success or failure of the communication efforts. Present Situation As part of the 2008 reorganization of the BSA National Office, an internal communication manager position was established. This, in turn, created an unrealistic expectation of a single individual taking leadership on all BSA internal communications. Therefore, many expected communications deliverables went unidentified and unaddressed. In addition, the individual who moved into that role, Marianne Elden, brought with her a full time job of developing and implementing the communication program for the Human Resource Group. Since that time, attention has been devoted to the employee communication newsletter, ProSpeak, and to the internal communication tools of the MyBSA intranet, National Office Staff Directories, the revised communication review process/forms, the Demand‐Based Communication e‐mail system, the BSA annual report, and the report to the nation. A substantial amount of time has remained devoted to Human Resources around the introduction and implementation of the new Performance Development System. Soon the medical benefits changes will be added to that task list. To add perspective to this situation, we’ve commissioned a benchmarking study of other similarly sized non‐profit organizations and their internal communication functions. The overview table shown below, supported by the full document, shows that BSA’s internal communication staffing of 1 is down substantially from comparable organizations. Organization Boy Scouts of America American Cancer Society American Heart Assn Boys and Girls Clubs Habitat for Humanity YMCA Total Employees Total Locations 7,000 1,475 3,393 800,000 350 3,400 240 4,300 1,600 10,000 Internal Communication Staff 1 6 6 ~6 Split duties 5.5 Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 5 The Scope of Internal Communication Internal communication is an essential strategic business process whose purpose is to change employee behavior in measureable ways to support management decisions. It does this by showing employees that those decisions are in their self‐interest. Done properly, internal communication can motivate employees to better support and implement management decisions and to actively participate in improving all areas of the organization. Within the Boy Scouts of America, the internal communication audience is defined as employees of the national council at all its facilities and all local council employees. Within that audience are many segments: Scout executives, local council employees, hourly employees, etc. Every communication plan needs to clearly denote the intended audience within that broad scope of all BSA employees. The Internal Communication Process The four‐step communication process is shown below as: research, planning, implementation, and measurement of results. Once the particular outcome is measured, the process should start again to fine tune the plan and adjust the implementation. While this process may be streamlined in certain situations, it is the ideal methodology for crafting the optimum messages, channels, and frequency to obtain the desired results. Research Planning Implementation Measurement While a “ready, fire, aim” approach can be taken in many situations, measurement (aim) is always required to determine if the action has had its intended outcomes. This in turn can be used to inform the research and planning processes to optimize the next implementation iteration. 6 Research The purpose of research is to inform the planning process. The diagram below attempts to outline the major components of research that is focused on internal communication. It consists of defining/documenting management decisions (the focus of the communication), researching what employees currently believe and their attitudes toward those decisions, an audit of existing messages and the media or vehicles/channels used to communicate those messages, along with a review of current industry practices to better inform our organization on other approaches to similar communication challenges. The overall outcome is a full assessment of the current results of the internal communication program. Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 7 Define/Document Management Decisions Given the definition of internal communication (change employee behavior in measureable ways to support management decisions), research must include the management decisions themselves. The crux is defining the key management decisions and reaching agreement on exactly what needs to be communicated. This is then followed by defining the desired employee behavior required to support those decisions. A key area to start for overall corporate planning would be with the BSA Strategic Plan and the specific goals set in this plan. Research Employee Beliefs and Attitudes A survey of employees and their attitudes, beliefs, and knowledge of each goal and the aspects of the plan can set the baseline for planning communication that will move the current state to the next level. We should also be examining the broader scope of overall concerns from employees, being careful to distinguish between council, group, and national level employee concerns. These areas may not necessarily be related to specific BSA goals but will none‐the‐less have an impact on the employees’ overall frame of reference and subsequently their ability to support management decisions. It may be useful to establish sounding boards that can provide more immediate feedback as opposed to more formal surveys. However, caution should be exercised that the sounding boards that are established are composed of all levels of the organization and that their input is being evaluated within the context of their personal interests as opposed to the broader needs of the overall organization. Finally, it would be well to establish key performance indicators for employee perceptions that could be used year over year to better evaluate the return on investment for the BSA’s communication investment. These performance indicators could be determined by an annual employee survey. Moreover, survey results, sorted by council could provide valuable insight into council differences that could perhaps be addressed by area directors and Scout executives. For example, the appendix contains the questions from an employee survey used by a national office department every year in the 1990’s and early 21st century to gain insight into employee perceptions. A similar instrument could be developed to assess the broader BSA employee perceptions. Furthermore, within that survey were the following three questions that comprised an Employee Commitment Index: 1. Overall, I am satisfied with my job. 2. As openings arise, I would recommend employment with the BSA to a friend. 3. Even if I had the opportunity to get a similar job/salary with another organization, I would stay with the BSA. 8 Similar questions could be asked about Employee Engagement. Those questions should assess where employees are in the four stages of Employee Engagement regarding every goal, focus area, and priority of the BSA. The four stages are: Stages of Employee Engagement Awareness Understanding Agreement Commitment The benefits of actively committed and engaged employees are substantial. They include attracting and retaining high quality staff members who are guides for their subordinates, not gods. This approach develops a shared vision, strategy, and change agenda at every level of the organization. It further accelerates the delivery of organizational transformation and thereby enhanced organizational performance. Employees become personally implicated in the ambition of the organization. Audit Existing Messages and Media/Channel/Vehicles In addition, at least annually, an audit should be conducted of the current messages, media, and frequency of communication to employees. This would include an assessment of the effectiveness of messages and media, making adjustments where necessary. Review Industry Practices Our full assessment of the internal communication landscape should also include industry practices from similar sized non‐profit operations as well as best practices across the internal communication field. Since we are starting this operation from scratch, we have a great deal of information to accumulate to get us up to speed here. Toward that end, we have commissioned a study of non‐profit organizations and how they staff and operation their internal communication function. This is a separate report. In follow on years, it may only be necessary to remain active in industry trade groups and to keep in touch with other non‐profits. It would be well to revisit this document each year to determine if any updates are needed. Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 9 Assessment of Current Results The next step is to take all the data from the above steps and establish an assessment of the current results. The outcome of this review will then either modify the existing communication goals or establish new goals. Planning In the planning stage each goal is addressed through a specific action plan. Finally, the overall plan (or in some cases, the plan to meet a single goal) is shared with top management to gain their agreement and to thereby obtain the required resources (time, money, manpower) needed to implement the action plan. The communication plan also needs to be integrated into the organizations strategic plan to ensure that it has sufficient attention and funding. Medium/Channel/Vehicle Selection The chart below compares message significance and urgency versus the communication medium (sometimes referred to as channel or vehicle). This type of chart should be consulted during the planning process to best determine the appropriate medium for each of the messages within the communication plan. Moreover, different media may be more appropriate during different times within the communication plan. 10 Here’s a summary of the strengths of each major communication medium that should also be considered when crafting the internal communication plan. Medium Electronic Print Face‐to‐face Strengths Timely, brief, allows interaction In depth messages, portable Obtain agreement, commitment, behavior change Implementation “Nothing to it but to do it.” This simple phrase was often spoken by a buddy of mine in my Air Force days. The key is what is it that we are to do? Fortunately, we’ve conducted the necessary research, crafted the plan with considerations of goals, communication channels, etc. Now we need merely walk through those plans, measuring the results as we go to insure that we are meeting our goals. Measurement A sample employee survey is included in the appendix. This survey was implemented across several years within a publishing department. It was used to determine employee engagement and commitment with quality management efforts and to gain insight into the effectiveness of managers across different publishing teams. While surveys and focus groups are often used to determine the effectiveness of a communication plan, other measures are often readily available and quite possibly more to the point of the communication effort. For example, if the objective is to get employees to sign up for a health program, you need merely measure the sign‐ups to determine the effectiveness of the communication plan. Ideally, pilot communication programs will be conducted, say in different councils, and in this way competing communication approaches can be tested and the most effective communication program used in the full roll out of effort. Of vital importance is that the overall communication plan also provide for measurement of results that can then be used to adjust the communication plan for optimum effectiveness. Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 1 1 Random thoughts ‐‐‐ attempts Here’s examples of possible measurements. Council or Group Goals Track employee knowledge of goals Desired Actions Track employee attitudes toward membership goals 12 Compare to actual performance to goals Compare to actual membership gain or decline Sample Employee Survey From department employee survey implemented every year in the 1990s and early 21st century. Focus was on customer service, continuous improvement, working together, management effectiveness, and employee engagement/commitment. Customer Focus Question 1. Our mission statement directs the way we do our work. 2. We are continually searching for ways to improve our customers' products. 3. We share product improvement ideas with our customers. 4. We try to find ways of saving our customers' time and money. 5. We expect employees to make extraordinary efforts on behalf of our customers. 6. We reward employees for extraordinary efforts made on behalf of our customers. 7. Complete customer satisfaction is our first priority. 8. We encourage customers to offer feedback. 9. We implement changes based on customer feedback. 10. We are able to adjust quickly when our customers' needs change. 11. Our customers are aware of all the services we can provide. 12. We provide our customers with enough information so they can make informed decisions. 13. Overall, my team effectively meets our customers' needs. 14. In the past year, customer focus in my team has: Management Question 1. My manager clearly communicates the organization's goals and objectives. 2. My manager holds people accountable for producing high quality work. 3. My manager leads by example. 4. My manager conducts meaningful and productive meetings. 5. My manager confronts conflict directly rather than avoiding or ignoring it. Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 1 3 6. If an employee has a conflict or disagreement with my manager, they are able to work it out together. 7. My manager considers new ideas or innovations to increase organizational effectiveness. 8. My manager appropriately delegates authority to other employees. 9. I have the authority I need to do my job effectively. 10. My manager supports high achievers by providing appropriate rewards and recognition. 11. My manager provides underachievers with appropriate coaching and guidance. 12. My manager involves others in the planning process. 13. My manager effectively balances the needs of employees with getting the tasks done. 14. My manager encourages employees to express their opinions. 15. My manager supports coordination and cooperation among work groups. 16. My manager works well with other managers. 17. Overall, my manager is an effective manager. 18. In the past year, management in my team has: Working Together Question 1. Team members communicate well with each other. 2. Team members cooperate to get the job done. 3. We are flexible in our approaches to our work. 4. We consistently accomplish our goals and objectives. 5. Rules, regulations, and red tape seldom get in the way of doing the job effectively. 6. We are open and honest in our relations with each other. 7. My job effectively utilizes my skills and abilities. 8. There is good cooperation among work teams. 9. Team members work together to establish work processes and standards. 10. Within our team, feedback is provided in a constructive manner. 11. We respect each other's skills and abilities. 14 12. We understand the roles of others within the division. 13. Others within the division understand my role within the division. 14. We adapt readily when our roles and working relationships change. 15. Overall, my team works together effectively. 16. In the past year, team work in my team has: Continuous Improvement Question 1. Problems are identified based on facts and logical analysis. 2. We use effective problem solving techniques to find solutions to problems. 3. When we identify a problem, we become involved in finding the solution to it rather than leaving it up to others. 4. Our technical capabilities are continuously improving. 5. Rules, regulations, and red tape seldom get in the way of quality improvements. 6. Goals and objectives are based on customer feedback and not on our own wishes. 7. We prioritize our improvement objectives to emphasize those objectives most important to our customers. 8. We consistently evaluate our progress toward our goals. 9. We are able to modify our goals when necessary. 10. We have adequate training and educational opportunities to continuously improve our skills and abilities. 11. We receive appropriate rewards and recognition for performance improvements. 12. The working conditions here support high performance. 13. We continuously strive to improve our work conditions. 14. Overall, my team is effective at continuously improving our work products and processes. 15. In the past year, continuous improvement in my team has: Boy Scouts of America Internal Communication Planning 1 5 Employee Engagement/Commitment Question 1. I get a real sense of accomplishment from my job. 2. I am a valued part of the Custom Communication Division. 3. The amount of stress I experience on my job is manageable. 4. Within this division, all employees are treated honestly and with respect. 5. My job makes a meaningful contribution to the achievement of the Boy Scouts of America's objectives. 6. Within the Custom Communication Division, conflicts are resolved in a constructive manner. 7. Within the Custom Communication Division, people are recognized for a job well done. 8. There is good communication between my work group and other work groups within the division. 9. The CC Division does a good job providing opportunities for employees to develop and grow with the company. 10. My current position makes good use of my skills and abilities. 11. Overall, the Custom Communication Division is a better place to work than most other divisions of the BSA. 12. Overall, I am satisfied with my job. 13. As openings arise, I would recommend employment at the Custom Communication Division to a friend. 14. Even if I had the opportunity to get a similar job with another organization I would stay with the CC Division. 16
© Copyright 2024