Download Report

Final Seniority Figures for
GMS GPs in England and
Wales
2011/12
Published 3rd March 2015
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
We are the trusted
national provider of
high-quality information,
data and IT systems for
health and social care.
www.hscic.gov.uk
enquiries@hscic.gov.uk
@hscic
2
Author:
Workforce and Facilities,
Health and Social Care Information Centre
Responsible statistician:
Ian Bullard, Section Head
Version:
V1.0
Date of publication:
3rd March 2015
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
Contents
1.
Summary
4
2.
Introduction
4
3.
Background
5
4.
Analysis
6
GP Coverage
6
Seniority Payment
6
FSF calculations
7
Annex A
8
5.
Inclusions
8
Exclusions
8
6.
Annex B
9
7.
Annex C
10
8.
Annex D
12
9.
Annex E
14
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
3
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
1. Summary
For GMS contractor GPs:
England
2011/12 Average superannuable income =
£97,918
2011/12 Average seniority payment =
£5,884
2011/12 Final Seniority Figure =
£92,034
2011/12 Interim Seniority Figure =
£93,972
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Wales
2011/12 Average superannuable income =
£89,996
2011/12 Average seniority payment =
£5,797
2011/12 Final Seniority Figure =
£84,199
2011/12 Interim Seniority Figure =
£82,099
2. Introduction
This paper is based on information supplied by NHS Pensions Agency for GMS Contractor GPs in
England and Wales for 2011/12.
This report has been agreed by the Technical Steering Committee (TSC), which is chaired by the
Health and Social Care Information Centre (HSCIC) and has representation from the four UK Health
Departments, NHS Employers, NHS England and the British Medical Association (BMA).
4
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
3. Background
The Final Seniority Figure is an earnings benchmark used to determine the level of seniority payment
that individual GPs are entitled to each year. The seniority payment that is awarded to an individual GP
is dependent on their years of reckonable service in the NHS and their qualifying income fraction.
Annex B shows the current seniority payment scales, where payments increase as the number of
years of reckonable service increase. The payment system operates using the following
superannuable income fractions:



A GP earning more than 2/3 of the national average superannuable income (excluding any
seniority component) in any year receives 100% of the available seniority payment (relevant to
the number of years they have been in service).
A GP earning between 1/3 and 2/3 of the national average superannuable income (excluding
any seniority component) receives 60% of the available seniority payment.
A GP earning less than 1/3 of the national average superannuable income (excluding any
seniority component) receives none of the available seniority payment.
Clearly, in any one financial year, it is not possible to know what the average superannuable income
is until the full year has actually passed and all payments have been made. Therefore, in order to
allow timely seniority payments to be made, an Interim Seniority Figure (ISF) is negotiated and
adopted for use during the year.
As with previously published Final Seniority Figures (FSF), and the ISF, the calculations are based
on GMS Contractor GPs only.
In order to calculate the FSF for 2011/12, it is necessary to know the average NHS income of all GMS
Contractor GPs in England and Wales. The best available source of data to enable this calculation is
available from the NHS Pensions Agency, using information declared via the GP superannuation
certificate.
Anecdotal evidence has suggested that not all payments managers are consistently applying this
definition, and that instead total NHS income (including the seniority income component) is used in the
calculation of entitlement. However, the analysis presented in this paper assumes that all payment
managers consistently applied the rules set out in the Statement of Financial Entitlements (SFE).
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
5
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
4. Analysis
GP Coverage
The analysis is based on superannuable income data for GMS Contractor GPs with a full accounting
year end. See Annex A for further information on the rules for inclusions and exclusions. These are the
same as the methodology for the 2010/11 Final Seniority Factors.
It is necessary to know a GP’s contract type and if they work in England or Wales since the FSF is
calculated for GMS GPs only and is calculated separately for England and Wales. However, country
markers and contract types are not part of the NHS pensions dataset. Therefore, these markers are
taken from the England and Wales GP census data, a dataset using information from the NHS GP
payments system. There are a number of GPs who do not appear on the census data, for whom it is
not possible to ascertain whether they work in England or Wales or who have duplicate rows in the
census data with conflicting contract types. Table 1 below shows that the average superannuable
income figures are very similar when these GPs are deleted from the dataset.
Table 1: Average superannuable income for FSF analysis, 2011/12, GPMS
Coverage
Average
Superannuable
Income
England and Wales 2011/12 before country
markers and contract types added
22,968
£100,429
England and Wales 2011/12 after country
markers and contract types added
22,556
£101,036
Seniority Payment
It is important to note the average superannuable income figure will include an unknown component
representing the actual seniority payment made to individuals for that year.
However, by considering each GP’s date of birth, and assuming that each individual began to accrue
Years of Reckonable Service from the age of 23 onwards, it is possible to estimate the seniority
payment that was made to each individual in 2011/12 (periods of part-time and full-time working are
treated the same). Hence, it is possible to estimate the average superannuable income figure excluding
the seniority payment component. This figure is, by definition, the FSF that is required.
The average superannuable income figures have been calculated for 2011/12 and presented in Table 2
for England and Wales GMS Contractor GPs. Amongst GMS Contractor GPs in England, the average
NHS superannuable income is £97,918 in 2011/12 and for Wales, the average NHS superannuable
income is £89,996. The figures are based on a population of 12,151 GMS Contractor GPs in England
and 1,443 contractor GPs in Wales.
6
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
By taking the same GP coverage and analysing their dates of birth and superannuable income in the
manner described in paragraph 16, the average seniority payment for England is £5,884 and the
average seniority payment for Wales is £5,797. The calculations behind the average seniority
payment are shown in Annexes C and D for each country.
FSF Calculations
Table 2 shows the breakdown of the FSF calculations for England and Wales. It is important to note,
however, that this is merely an estimate of what the average seniority payment was, rather than a
precise calculation. In the absence of central recording of NHS superannuable pay before seniority
payment, it is not possible to do more than estimate what the size of the seniority component is for any
one individual GP in the sample.
Table 2: Breakdown of FSF calculations, England and Wales, GMS Contractor GPs, 2011/12
Coverage
England
Wales
Average
Superannuable
Income
Average
Seniority
Payment
Final Seniority
Figure
12,151
£97,918
£5,884
£92,034
1,443
£89,996
£5,797
£84,199
Note: Calculations are based on unrounded figures.
By deducting the average seniority payment from average superannuable income, the FSF can be
calculated for each country as shown in Table 2. The FSF for England is calculated as £92,034 and
the FSF for Wales is calculated as £84,199.
Annex E shows a comparison of Interim Seniority Factors (ISFs) and FSFs from 2006/07. The FSFs
for 2008/09 as calculated in this report are noticeably lower than the ISFs. TSC intended to calculate
a high ISF for 2008/09. As was the expectation, there is not such a difference between the ISF and
FSF in subsequent years.
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
7
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
5. Annex A
Inclusions
Only data related to those GMS Contractor GPs with a full accounting year of superannuable income
reported to the NHS Pensions Agency have been used in calculating the average superannuable
income. If the full-year GPs have any superannuable income from other work outside their usual
practice, whether in a contractor or salaried capacity, these have been included in order to calculate
a total superannuable income figure for those GPs.
Exclusions
The following GP records have been removed from the average superannuable income calculation:
a. All non-GMS GPs, and any GPs with both a GMS and a non-GMS contract.
b. Any duplicate records.
c. Any non-contractor records with only full-year earnings.
d. Any GPs with only part year earnings.
e. Any contractor GPs as described above who have full year superannuable income between
zero and £10.
In previous years, GP records that showed income solely received from NHS board and advisory
work (i.e. Professional Executive Committee board) were also excluded. However, it is not possible
to distinguish these GPs after 2005/06 in the dataset.
8
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
6. Annex B
Table B1: Available Seniority Payment values as a function of Years of Seniority Reckonable
Service, 2011/12
Years of seniority
reckonable service
0-5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47+
Full annual rate per
practitioner (£)
0
600
672
753
843
944
1,057
1,184
1,326
1,486
1,664
3,185
3,504
3,854
4,239
4,663
5,129
6,785
6,989
7,198
7,414
7,637
7,866
8,225
8,455
8,692
8,935
9,186
9,443
9,707
9,979
10,258
10,546
10,841
11,144
11,457
11,777
12,107
12,446
12,795
13,153
13,521
13,900
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
9
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
7. Annex C
Table C1: Age distribution of GMS Contractor GPs, England, 2011/12
Age
to 28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70+
Years of Seniority
Reckonable Service
Age
distribution
0-5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47+
Total:
0
31
60
94
162
207
227
281
307
333
346
377
350
368
401
387
429
499
533
569
577
558
599
602
536
548
513
437
512
399
336
226
59
71
51
42
32
25
21
19
8
6
13
12,151
Seniority
payments (£)
0
600
672
753
843
944
1,057
1,184
1,326
1,486
1,664
3,185
3,504
3,854
4,239
4,663
5,129
6,785
6,989
7,198
7,414
7,637
7,866
8,225
8,455
8,692
8,935
9,186
9,443
9,707
9,979
10,258
10,546
10,841
11,144
11,457
11,777
12,107
12,446
12,795
13,153
13,521
13,900
Costs (£)
0
18,600
40,320
70,782
136,566
195,408
239,939
332,704
407,082
494,838
575,744
1,200,745
1,226,400
1,418,272
1,699,839
1,804,581
2,200,341
3,385,715
3,725,137
4,095,662
4,277,878
4,261,446
4,711,734
4,951,450
4,531,880
4,763,216
4,583,655
4,014,282
4,834,816
3,873,093
3,352,944
2,318,308
622,214
769,711
568,344
481,194
376,864
302,675
261,366
243,105
105,224
81,126
180,700
77,735,900
Average full seniority payment: £6,397
10
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
Not every GP will receive the full seniority entitlement. It is apportioned out according to how much a
GP earns as shown in Table C2 which is based on average superannuable income = £97,918.
Table C2: Distribution of England GMS Contractor GPs net income, 2011/12
Net income band
0-1/3 of average
(0- £32,952.16)
1/3 to 2/3 of average
(£32,952.16 to £65,904.32)
Above 2/3 of average
(above £65,904.32)
Total
Count
Seniority
entitlement
Total
seniority
payment
187
0%
£0
1,970
60%
£7,561,254
9,994
100%
£63,931,618
12,151
£71,492,872
Note: Calculations are based on unrounded figures.
Average seniority payment is £5,884.
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
11
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
8. Annex D
Table D1: Age distribution of GMS Contractor GPs, Wales, 2011/12
Age
to 28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70+
Total:
Years of Seniority
Reckonable Service
0-5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47+
Age
distribution
0
4
4
18
21
25
39
31
43
43
37
40
56
43
42
49
43
53
75
69
56
62
55
85
65
74
71
58
62
42
44
12
2
1
6
5
2
2
2
1
1
0
0
1,443
Seniority
payments (£)
0
600
672
753
843
944
1,057
1,184
1,326
1,486
1,664
3,185
3,504
3,854
4,239
4,663
5,129
6,785
6,989
7,198
7,414
7,637
7,866
8,225
8,455
8,692
8,935
9,186
9,443
9,707
9,979
10,258
10,546
10,841
11,144
11,457
11,777
12,107
12,446
12,795
13,153
13,521
13,900
Costs (£)
0
2,400
2,688
13,554
17,703
23,600
41,223
36,704
57,018
63,898
61,568
127,400
196,224
165,722
178,038
228,487
220,547
359,605
524,175
496,662
415,184
473,494
432,630
699,125
549,575
643,208
634,385
532,788
585,466
407,694
439,076
123,096
21,092
10,841
66,864
57,285
23,554
24,214
24,892
12,795
13,153
0
0
9,007,627
Average full seniority payment: £6,242
12
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
Not every GP will receive the full seniority entitlement. It is apportioned out according to how much a
GP earns as shown in Table D2 which is based on average superannuable income = £89,996.
Table D2: Distribution of Wales GMS Contractor GPs net income, 2011/12
Net income band
0-1/3 of average
(0- £30,518.75)
1/3 to 2/3 of average
(£30,518.75 to £61,037.51)
Above 2/3 of average
(above £61,037.51)
Total
Seniority
entitlement
Count
Total seniority
payment
20
0%
£0
207
60%
£775,256
1,216
100%
£7,590,272
1,443
£8,365,528
Note: Calculations are based on unrounded figures.
Average seniority payment is £5,797.
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
13
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
9. Annex E
Table E1: Interim and Final Seniority Figures - England
Interim Seniority Figure
Final Seniority Figure
2006/07
£95,355
£92,140
2007/08
N/A
£90,375
2008/09
£105,524
£92,955
2009/10
£94,743
£93,678
2010/11
£95,802
£94,080
2011/12
£93,972
£92,034
2012/13
£96,646
-
2013/14
£96,183
-
2014/15
£96,097
-
Table E2: Interim and Final Seniority Figures – Wales
Interim Seniority Figure
14
Final Seniority Figure
2006/07
£95,355
£82,399
2007/08
N/A
£78,938
2008/09
£105,524
£79,096
2009/10
£84,667
£82,266
2010/11
£85,690
£82,237
2011/12
£82,099
£84,199
2012/13
£82,261
-
2013/14
£84,479
-
2014/15
£84,012
-
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
Final Seniority Figures for GMS GPs in England and Wales, 2011/12
Published by the Health and Social Care Information Centre
Part of the Government Statistical Service
Responsible Statistician
Ian Bullard, Section Head
This publication may be requested in large print or other formats.
For further information:
www.hscic.gov.uk
0300 303 5678
enquiries@hscic.gov.uk
Copyright © 2015 Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
This work remains the sole and exclusive property of the Health and Social Care
Information Centre and may only be reproduced where there is explicit reference to the
ownership of the Health and Social Care Information Centre.
This work may be re-used by NHS and government organisations without permission
Copyright © 2015, Health and Social Care Information Centre. All rights reserved.
15